Round H: Inside Job vs. 1/2 Full vs. Yellow Ledbetter

[digster]

I really don't have any dog in this, as I can't really make up my mind, but I don't really get anyone saying one of these songs is eons better than the other. I'd be a bit surprised if Ledbetter lost, but not shocked.

[stip]

Every second of Yellow Ledbetter just aches with beautiful longing. The take of 1/2 Full on Riot Act is a flat and lifeless clone of Red Mosquito.

The reason one of these songs has grown stale is that you've been listening to its awesomeness for twenty years, and 1/2 Full has only recently been worth your time is that you've exhausted all the more interesting songs that surround it.

This bodes well for backspacer and l-bolt songs for our 2036 tournament!

[stip]

I really don't have any dog in this, as I can't really make up my mind, but I don't really get anyone saying one of these songs is eons better than the other. I'd be a bit surprised if Ledbetter lost, but not shocked.

I should cease being shocked, but here we are...

[PHATJ]

Every second of Yellow Ledbetter just aches with beautiful longing. The take of 1/2 Full on Riot Act is a flat and lifeless clone of Red Mosquito.

The reason one of these songs has grown stale is that you've been listening to its awesomeness for twenty years, and 1/2 Full has only recently been worth your time is that you've exhausted all the more interesting songs that surround it.

This bodes well for backspacer and l-bolt songs for our 2036 tournament!

Though every word of this may be true, that doesn't mean that people can't legitimately want to hear 1/2 Full more than YL today. I'm not voting on which song I liked better 10 or 15 years ago, I'm voting on which song I'd rather listen to today. I'm voting on the song I currently prefer, because it is not currently 10 years ago, it is now.

[stip]

Every second of Yellow Ledbetter just aches with beautiful longing. The take of 1/2 Full on Riot Act is a flat and lifeless clone of Red Mosquito.

The reason one of these songs has grown stale is that you've been listening to its awesomeness for twenty years, and 1/2 Full has only recently been worth your time is that you've exhausted all the more interesting songs that surround it.

This bodes well for backspacer and l-bolt songs for our 2036 tournament!

Though every word of this may be true, that doesn't mean that people can't legitimately want to hear 1/2 Full more than YL today. I'm not voting on which song I liked better 10 or 15 years ago, I'm voting on which song I'd rather listen to today. I'm voting on the song I currently prefer, because it is not currently 10 years ago, it is now.

I never said your vote was illegitimate, just that it was stupid.

[digster]

I'll admit, my feelings on Yellow Ledbetter are slightly colored by the place it's come to occupy in PJ's live show. Over time, I've seen it less as a song than as the relaxing cigarette at the end of a long show. It's a nice, loose pleasant way of capping the evening. And I like that about it; I don't mind the fact that it closes many shows and I think it occupies that role perfectly. So maybe that's colored my opinion on the actual song, but on the other hand, the song has never been so arresting that it demanded I view it in a different way.

[stip]

There are few songs more immediately arresting than Yellow Ledbetter. The live version has morphed into something completely different (your description is apt) but the studio take is something sublime

[stip]

whereas half full is 210 seconds of mike solos looped through a stifled yawn

[PHATJ]

There are few songs more immediately arresting than Yellow Ledbetter. The live version has morphed into something completely different (your description is apt) but the studio take is something sublime

It's not immediately arresting after 25+ years of a bazillion listens.

[EJ]

Every second of Yellow Ledbetter just aches with beautiful longing. The take of 1/2 Full on Riot Act is a flat and lifeless clone of Red Mosquito.

The reason one of these songs has grown stale is that you've been listening to its awesomeness for twenty years, and 1/2 Full has only recently been worth your time is that you've exhausted all the more interesting songs that surround it.

This bodes well for backspacer and l-bolt songs for our 2036 tournament!

Though every word of this may be true, that doesn't mean that people can't legitimately want to hear 1/2 Full more than YL today. I'm not voting on which song I liked better 10 or 15 years ago, I'm voting on which song I'd rather listen to today. I'm voting on the song I currently prefer, because it is not currently 10 years ago, it is now.

I never said your vote was illegitimate, just that it was stupid.

We're all buttslaves. Get over it.

[chewm]

I dont want to change my vote because I genuinely like Inside Job the most but I might because Yellow Ledbetter is so much better than 1/2 Full.

[E.H. Ruddock]

I dont want to change my vote because I genuinely like Inside Job the most but I might because Yellow Ledbetter is so much better than 1/2 Full.

Do it. I just did.

[epilogue]

Every second of Yellow Ledbetter just aches with beautiful longing. The take of 1/2 Full on Riot Act is a flat and lifeless clone of Red Mosquito.

[LoathedVermin72]

Every second of Yellow Ledbetter just aches with beautiful longing. The take of 1/2 Full on Riot Act is a flat and lifeless clone of Red Mosquito.

he's not entirely wrong

[epilogue]

Every second of Yellow Ledbetter just aches with beautiful longing. The take of 1/2 Full on Riot Act is a flat and lifeless clone of Red Mosquito.

he's not entirely wrong

Well, every second of Yellow Ledbetter does not ache with beautiful longing. So, yeah, he is wrong. Also, the album take of 1/2 Full is far from flat and lifeless. So, again, yes, yes he is entirely wrong.

[LoathedVermin72]

Every second of Yellow Ledbetter just aches with beautiful longing. The take of 1/2 Full on Riot Act is a flat and lifeless clone of Red Mosquito.

he's not entirely wrong

Well, every second of Yellow Ledbetter does not ache with beautiful longing. So, yeah, he is wrong. Also, the album take of 1/2 Full is far from flat and lifeless. So, again, yes, yes he is entirely wrong.

[epilogue]

Every second of Yellow Ledbetter just aches with beautiful longing. The take of 1/2 Full on Riot Act is a flat and lifeless clone of Red Mosquito.

he's not entirely wrong

Well, every second of Yellow Ledbetter does not ache with beautiful longing. So, yeah, he is wrong. Also, the album take of 1/2 Full is far from flat and lifeless. So, again, yes, yes he is entirely wrong.

It does sound a lot like Red Mosquito, though, musically. I'll give him that. BUT THAT'S IT. YOU HEAR ME, STIP. THAT'S ALL YOU GET.

[thesound]

"Yellow Ledbetter" is very obviously better than "1/2 Full"

But it's a cover!!!

[Leatherhead]

I made this post in the "Sonic Reducer v Save You v Spin the Black Circle" thread.

How does one vote on this shit?

Which song have I liked harder at any one given time?
Which song have I listened to more?
Which song would I rather listen to right now?
Which song would I rather listen to a week from right now?
Which song would I rather listen to yesterday?
Which song do I think is crafted better?
Which song elicits a stronger emotional response?
Which song can I listen to the most without tiring of it?
Which song do I purposely listen to or seek out live versions of, more?
Which song do I think I can play on guitar?
Which song did I more enjoy after just now listening to them?
Which song do I listen to first? Does the order at which I listen to them affect my enjoyment of each individual song? If so, that's not fair.
Which song does Eddie sound more like a lion?

........

.............

But it doesn't apply here. Yellow Ledbetter is so full of cheese and 1/2 Full kicks all kinds of ass. I mean, YL doesn't even have real lyrics, fuckin cheesy.

[William Bloke]

I need to start advertising this on the pit so we can get some people with sensible taste voting here.

Ha!