Red Mosquito

Glad you’re enjoying SW, but that ranking hurts looking at.

Anders wrote:Glad you’re enjoying SW, but that ranking hurts looking at.

I would have thought his ranking would have been much worse than that.

Empire
New Hope
Andor
Rogue One
Jedi
Mando
Genndy Tartakovsky's Clone Wars


the rest...I know that seems dismissive but over time I've become pretty neutral on the rest of it nether really high or low figure I'd just focus on the parts I loved.

Anders wrote:Glad you’re enjoying SW, but that ranking hurts looking at.

I'm sorry

With Andor S1 complete, here's my ranking of the live-action Star Wars shows:

1. Andor S1
2. Obi-Wan Kenobi
3. The Book of Boba Fett
4. The Mandalorian S2
5. The Mandalorian S1

Obi-Wan in a second should be a bannable offense.

That's certainly a take.

1 Mando

2 obi-Wan
3 BOBF/Andor


Movies
Empire
New hope
Revenge of the sith
Rogue one
Force awakens
Return of the Jedi
Attack of the clones
Phantom menace
Last Jedi
Rise of the skywalker
Solo

1. The Mandalorian (s1 started a new era, and was excellent, second half of s2, is the best SWTV has ever been)
2. Andor (already want to rewatch this, was excellent, could rival Mando with an even better s2)
3. Obi-Wan Kenobi (interesting story I’ve been waiting for, but only partly delivered)
4. The Book of Boba Fett (had higher highs than OBK, but too uneven)

Think even TBOBF has been a good show, and is far above the worst SW shows out there. Even the best of the animated shows are at least as uneven as this show.

Anders wrote:1. The Mandalorian (s1 started a new era, and was excellent, second half of s2, is the best SWTV has ever been)
2. Andor (already want to rewatch this, was excellent, could rival Mando with an even better s2)
3. Obi-Wan Kenobi (interesting story I’ve been waiting for, but only partly delivered)
4. The Book of Boba Fett (had higher highs than OBK, but too uneven)

Think even TBOBF has been a good show, and is far above the worst SW shows out there. Even the best of the animated shows are at least as uneven as this show.

Agreed I love Clone Wars but I can’t rate it higher than anything live action.

Live action clone wars would be a dream.

Anders wrote:1. The Mandalorian (s1 started a new era, and was excellent, second half of s2, is the best SWTV has ever been)
2. Andor (already want to rewatch this, was excellent, could rival Mando with an even better s2)
3. Obi-Wan Kenobi (interesting story I’ve been waiting for, but only partly delivered)
4. The Book of Boba Fett (had higher highs than OBK, but too uneven)

Think even TBOBF has been a good show, and is far above the worst SW shows out there. Even the best of the animated shows are at least as uneven as this show.

Agreed I love Clone Wars but I can’t rate it higher than anything live action.

Live action clone wars would be a dream.

i liked Mando S2 better than 1 i think. Both of them are alright. Fett was laughably bad. Obi Wan feels like a missed chance but it was still fun to see Obi Wan and Vader. Havent seen nor i care about Andor at all. I do wanna see Ahsoka.

VinylGuy wrote:i liked Mando S2 better than 1 i think. Both of them are alright. Fett was laughably bad. Obi Wan feels like a missed chance but it was still fun to see Obi Wan and Vader. Havent seen nor i care about Andor at all. I do wanna see Ahsoka.

You should really watch Andor.

Monkey_Driven wrote:

VinylGuy wrote:i liked Mando S2 better than 1 i think. Both of them are alright. Fett was laughably bad. Obi Wan feels like a missed chance but it was still fun to see Obi Wan and Vader. Havent seen nor i care about Andor at all. I do wanna see Ahsoka.

You should really watch Andor.

I really dont have it in me

Did you see the Fett stuff that had a lot of Mando in it? Either way, the top 2-3 episodes in the TBOBF series were really good.

Yeah to clarify I saw the first of Fett, then the mando eps and the finale

I liked that mando ep with Luke

VinylGuy wrote:

Monkey_Driven wrote:

VinylGuy wrote:i liked Mando S2 better than 1 i think. Both of them are alright. Fett was laughably bad. Obi Wan feels like a missed chance but it was still fun to see Obi Wan and Vader. Havent seen nor i care about Andor at all. I do wanna see Ahsoka.

You should really watch Andor.

I really dont have it in me

Did you like any of Tony Gilroy's films?

As a director ? Not really.

As a writer yes, but also those films were directed by talented directors.

VinylGuy wrote:

Monkey_Driven wrote:

VinylGuy wrote:i liked Mando S2 better than 1 i think. Both of them are alright. Fett was laughably bad. Obi Wan feels like a missed chance but it was still fun to see Obi Wan and Vader. Havent seen nor i care about Andor at all. I do wanna see Ahsoka.

You should really watch Andor.

I really dont have it in me

suck it up, you're missing out.

VinylGuy wrote:As a director ? Not really.

As a writer yes, but also those films were directed by talented directors.

He doesn't direct any of Andor, if that helps. He's the head writer and show runner but doesn't direct.