Re: Parting Ways vs. Sleight of Hand vs. Gods' Dice
Posted: Fri March 17, 2017 4:46 pm
by tragabigzanda
durdencommatyler wrote:
LoathedVermin72 wrote:
durdencommatyler wrote:
LoathedVermin72 wrote:
PHATJ wrote:
theplatypus wrote:Also, "Sleight of Hand" isn't just my favorite song in Binaural; it's their best song of the 21st century
Wrong. Only in that it is their best song. Period.
*fourth
This sounds about right. I might put it 3rd or 5th too though. Not sure. Somewhere in there.
1. Go
2. Brain of J.
3. Hail, Hail
4. Sleight of Hand
Respectable and hard to be angry at that fine list right there. I think I'd have to go with something like...
1. In My Tree
2. Tremor Christ
3. Black
4. Sleight of Hand
Something like that. But In the Moonlight, No Way, Help Help, Do the Evolution and Hard to Imagine would all be up there too. I also struggle with Black. Like, do I have it so high because it's really that good? Or is it just pure nostalgia? I think I just really love that song, no matter how overwrought it feels know that I'm not 13. Annie Clark's cover is outstanding. So... I feel like I really love it. But maybe I just love it the way a 13 year old loves things. Who can say? Anyway...
What is this Annie Clarke cover of which you speak? Can you link me to your favorite version?
Re: Parting Ways vs. Sleight of Hand vs. Gods' Dice
Posted: Fri March 17, 2017 4:51 pm
by PHATJ
durdencommatyler wrote:
LoathedVermin72 wrote:
durdencommatyler wrote:
LoathedVermin72 wrote:
PHATJ wrote:
theplatypus wrote:Also, "Sleight of Hand" isn't just my favorite song in Binaural; it's their best song of the 21st century
Wrong. Only in that it is their best song. Period.
*fourth
This sounds about right. I might put it 3rd or 5th too though. Not sure. Somewhere in there.
1. Go
2. Brain of J.
3. Hail, Hail
4. Sleight of Hand
Respectable and hard to be angry at that fine list right there. I think I'd have to go with something like...
1. In My Tree
2. Tremor Christ
3. Black
4. Sleight of Hand
Something like that. But In the Moonlight, No Way, Help Help, Do the Evolution and Hard to Imagine would all be up there too. I also struggle with Black. Like, do I have it so high because it's really that good? Or is it just pure nostalgia? I think I just really love that song, no matter how overwrought it feels know that I'm not 13. Annie Clark's cover is outstanding. So... I feel like I really love it. But maybe I just love it the way a 13 year old loves things. Who can say? Anyway...
My top three:
1. Sleight of Hand
2. Release
3. Immortality
I'm not positive what I'd put next but these would be in the running: Jeremy, I Got Shit, Leash, Corduroy, Faithfull, Animal.
Re: Parting Ways vs. Sleight of Hand vs. Gods' Dice
Posted: Fri March 17, 2017 5:02 pm
by epilogue
PHATJ wrote:
My top three:
1. Sleight of Hand
2. Release
3. Immortality
I'm not positive what I'd put next but these would be in the running: Jeremy, I Got Shit, Leash, Corduroy, Faithfull, Animal.
Goddamnit! Release and Immortality! BAAAAAAAAAAAAH!
Guys, I can't do this. In My Tree is my favorite. Everything else is tied for second.
Re: Parting Ways vs. Sleight of Hand vs. Gods' Dice
Posted: Fri March 17, 2017 5:05 pm
by epilogue
tragabigzanda wrote:
durdencommatyler wrote:
LoathedVermin72 wrote:
durdencommatyler wrote:
LoathedVermin72 wrote:
PHATJ wrote:
theplatypus wrote:Also, "Sleight of Hand" isn't just my favorite song in Binaural; it's their best song of the 21st century
Wrong. Only in that it is their best song. Period.
*fourth
This sounds about right. I might put it 3rd or 5th too though. Not sure. Somewhere in there.
1. Go
2. Brain of J.
3. Hail, Hail
4. Sleight of Hand
Respectable and hard to be angry at that fine list right there. I think I'd have to go with something like...
1. In My Tree
2. Tremor Christ
3. Black
4. Sleight of Hand
Something like that. But In the Moonlight, No Way, Help Help, Do the Evolution and Hard to Imagine would all be up there too. I also struggle with Black. Like, do I have it so high because it's really that good? Or is it just pure nostalgia? I think I just really love that song, no matter how overwrought it feels know that I'm not 13. Annie Clark's cover is outstanding. So... I feel like I really love it. But maybe I just love it the way a 13 year old loves things. Who can say? Anyway...
What is this Annie Clarke cover of which you speak? Can you link me to your favorite version?
I've only seen one video of it. It's from the Portlandia Tour. Live version. She starts playing the song like 2:50 into the clip. The quality isn't stellar.
Re: Parting Ways vs. Sleight of Hand vs. Gods' Dice
Posted: Fri March 17, 2017 5:08 pm
by darth_vedder
SOH. Parting Ways was an early favorite of mine, as was GD, but SOH took a few years / album revisits to fully appreciate. I really do love all three of these songs though.
Re: Parting Ways vs. Sleight of Hand vs. Gods' Dice
Posted: Fri March 17, 2017 5:11 pm
by LoathedVermin72
durdencommatyler wrote:
tragabigzanda wrote:
durdencommatyler wrote:
LoathedVermin72 wrote:
durdencommatyler wrote:
LoathedVermin72 wrote:
PHATJ wrote:
theplatypus wrote:Also, "Sleight of Hand" isn't just my favorite song in Binaural; it's their best song of the 21st century
Wrong. Only in that it is their best song. Period.
*fourth
This sounds about right. I might put it 3rd or 5th too though. Not sure. Somewhere in there.
1. Go
2. Brain of J.
3. Hail, Hail
4. Sleight of Hand
Respectable and hard to be angry at that fine list right there. I think I'd have to go with something like...
1. In My Tree
2. Tremor Christ
3. Black
4. Sleight of Hand
Something like that. But In the Moonlight, No Way, Help Help, Do the Evolution and Hard to Imagine would all be up there too. I also struggle with Black. Like, do I have it so high because it's really that good? Or is it just pure nostalgia? I think I just really love that song, no matter how overwrought it feels know that I'm not 13. Annie Clark's cover is outstanding. So... I feel like I really love it. But maybe I just love it the way a 13 year old loves things. Who can say? Anyway...
What is this Annie Clarke cover of which you speak? Can you link me to your favorite version?
I've only seen one video of it. It's from the Portlandia Tour. Live version. She starts playing the song like 2:50 into the clip. The quality isn't stellar.
Does she always sing like this?
Re: Parting Ways vs. Sleight of Hand vs. Gods' Dice
Posted: Fri March 17, 2017 5:12 pm
by epilogue
Gods' Dice used to be my least favorite Pearl Jam song. Now I really like it. It's still not top tier Binaural for me but I appreciate and enjoy the song quite a bit.
Parting Ways is a song I can appreciate but I'm not sure that I really like all that much. Sometimes it really clicks and then other times its just sort of a pretty noise. I like things about it but it never quite lives up for me.
Sleight of Hand is a masterpiece.
Re: Parting Ways vs. Sleight of Hand vs. Gods' Dice
Posted: Fri March 17, 2017 5:13 pm
by epilogue
LoathedVermin72 wrote:Does she always sing like this?
I'm not sure how to answer you. What exactly do you mean?
Re: Parting Ways vs. Sleight of Hand vs. Gods' Dice
Posted: Fri March 17, 2017 5:19 pm
by tragabigzanda
Thanks for posting!
Re: Parting Ways vs. Sleight of Hand vs. Gods' Dice
Posted: Fri March 17, 2017 5:25 pm
by epilogue
tragabigzanda wrote:Thanks for posting!
I just like how slow and deliberate the vocal is. There's so much less emotion in her voice than Ed's and yet the lyrics still have tremendous meaning, he emotion still comes through. Really though it's all about the guitar work in that version, for me. I could listen to/watch her play that fucking thing all goddamn night.
Re: Parting Ways vs. Sleight of Hand vs. Gods' Dice
Posted: Fri March 17, 2017 6:07 pm
by Kaius
Switched to Parting Ways after listening to both.
Re: Parting Ways vs. Sleight of Hand vs. Gods' Dice
Posted: Fri March 17, 2017 10:35 pm
by PHATJ
LoathedVermin72 wrote:
durdencommatyler wrote:
tragabigzanda wrote:
durdencommatyler wrote:
LoathedVermin72 wrote:
durdencommatyler wrote:
LoathedVermin72 wrote:
PHATJ wrote:
theplatypus wrote:Also, "Sleight of Hand" isn't just my favorite song in Binaural; it's their best song of the 21st century
Wrong. Only in that it is their best song. Period.
*fourth
This sounds about right. I might put it 3rd or 5th too though. Not sure. Somewhere in there.
1. Go
2. Brain of J.
3. Hail, Hail
4. Sleight of Hand
Respectable and hard to be angry at that fine list right there. I think I'd have to go with something like...
1. In My Tree
2. Tremor Christ
3. Black
4. Sleight of Hand
Something like that. But In the Moonlight, No Way, Help Help, Do the Evolution and Hard to Imagine would all be up there too. I also struggle with Black. Like, do I have it so high because it's really that good? Or is it just pure nostalgia? I think I just really love that song, no matter how overwrought it feels know that I'm not 13. Annie Clark's cover is outstanding. So... I feel like I really love it. But maybe I just love it the way a 13 year old loves things. Who can say? Anyway...
What is this Annie Clarke cover of which you speak? Can you link me to your favorite version?
I've only seen one video of it. It's from the Portlandia Tour. Live version. She starts playing the song like 2:50 into the clip. The quality isn't stellar.
Does she always sing like this?
I really respect Annie Clark as a musician and songwriter. Generally I think she's pretty great, but I didn't like this one bit. I couldn't even finish the song.
Re: Parting Ways vs. Sleight of Hand vs. Gods' Dice
Posted: Fri March 17, 2017 10:58 pm
by LoathedVermin72
I tried some of her original songs after this and didn't like them at all.
Re: Parting Ways vs. Sleight of Hand vs. Gods' Dice
Posted: Fri March 17, 2017 11:31 pm
by chewm
I think Parting ways is very close to being my favorite thing the band has done.
I wont be mad when it loses to Sleight of hand, because its fantastic too, but I love Parting Ways so much.
Re: Parting Ways vs. Sleight of Hand vs. Gods' Dice
Posted: Fri March 17, 2017 11:38 pm
by PHATJ
chewm wrote:I think Parting ways is very close to being my favorite thing the band has done.
I wont be mad when it loses to Sleight of hand, because its fantastic too, but I love Parting Ways so much.
How can you love Parting Ways but think All or None is boring?
Re: Parting Ways vs. Sleight of Hand vs. Gods' Dice
Posted: Fri March 17, 2017 11:42 pm
by chewm
They're quite different
Re: Parting Ways vs. Sleight of Hand vs. Gods' Dice
