Sgt. Crackpot wrote:Both LB and FD days are really a bit of a grey area. However, if any of one us were at the concert - should they be penalised?
I'm happy to let those ones be counted as offical release, because PJ played them to a buttload of people in a public arena. That's not really a leak, because they want people to hear it.
The soundcheck song is a hard one. But, considering:
A) We don't even know if it's PJ.
2) We don't even know if it's PJ playing a song from LB.
D) It's just loud, rhythmic, groovy noise - it could've just been a jam.
IX) If it's legit, they played it really fucking loud so surely they knew people would hear/record it.
It's like showing someone a blurry, shitty photo of a lightbulb and trying to tell them it's a flying saucer. I'm willing to let it slide.
Someone should have asked one of the Germany fans which album track "soundcheck song" was. It doesn't really sound like any of the descriptions they made...
Re: No Leak Club
Posted: Wed September 04, 2013 5:46 am
by Lounge Lizard
verb_to_trust wrote:
Sgt. Crackpot wrote:Both LB and FD days are really a bit of a grey area. However, if any of one us were at the concert - should they be penalised?
I'm happy to let those ones be counted as offical release, because PJ played them to a buttload of people in a public arena. That's not really a leak, because they want people to hear it.
The soundcheck song is a hard one. But, considering:
A) We don't even know if it's PJ.
2) We don't even know if it's PJ playing a song from LB.
D) It's just loud, rhythmic, groovy noise - it could've just been a jam.
IX) If it's legit, they played it really fucking loud so surely they knew people would hear/record it.
It's like showing someone a blurry, shitty photo of a lightbulb and trying to tell them it's a flying saucer. I'm willing to let it slide.
Someone should have asked one of the Germany fans which album track "soundcheck song" was. It doesn't really sound like any of the descriptions they made...
"A) We don't even know if it's PJ." -- I'm pretty certain I hear Ed's voice, although I can't hear the lyrics
"2) We don't even know if it's PJ playing a song from LB" -- true
Re: No Leak Club
Posted: Wed September 04, 2013 6:36 am
by Lament
I'm in. I was at Wrigley so I heard Lightning Bolt and Future Days, but I don't think I should punished for that. I mean, I already sat through Future Days, so I've been punished enough.
Re: No Leak Club
Posted: Wed September 04, 2013 8:59 am
by Release_Me
Soundcheck song was Infallible.
Re: No Leak Club
Posted: Wed September 04, 2013 11:22 am
by LikeLukin
You guys are crazy. Bring on a leak. Any of us could die tomorrow, I'm sure as hell not going to put off listening to new PJ if it's out there.
Re: No Leak Club
Posted: Wed September 04, 2013 11:49 am
by Sgt. Crackpot
LikeLukin wrote:You guys are crazy. Bring on a leak. Any of us could die tomorrow, I'm sure as hell not going to put off listening to new PJ if it's out there.
If I died tomorrow, I'm pretty sure my last thought won't be "oh fuck, I'll never hear lightning bolt".
Re: No Leak Club
Posted: Wed September 04, 2013 11:54 am
by Lounge Lizard
Sgt. Crackpot wrote:
LikeLukin wrote:You guys are crazy. Bring on a leak. Any of us could die tomorrow, I'm sure as hell not going to put off listening to new PJ if it's out there.
If I died tomorrow, I'm pretty sure my last thought won't be "oh fuck, I'll never hear lightning bolt".
Right
"Why did I wait? Who told me to wait? Just you die, motherfuckers, I'll get you on the other side"
Re: No Leak Club
Posted: Wed September 04, 2013 11:57 am
by epilogue
Sgt. Crackpot wrote:
LikeLukin wrote:You guys are crazy. Bring on a leak. Any of us could die tomorrow, I'm sure as hell not going to put off listening to new PJ if it's out there.
If I died tomorrow, I'm pretty sure my last thought won't be "oh fuck, I'll never hear lightning bolt".
Re: No Leak Club
Posted: Wed September 04, 2013 12:00 pm
by harmless
It would probably cross my mind if I was dying. But so would the fact that I need to eat another welsh rarebit before I die.
Re: No Leak Club
Posted: Wed September 04, 2013 12:01 pm
by stip
Sgt. Crackpot wrote:
LikeLukin wrote:You guys are crazy. Bring on a leak. Any of us could die tomorrow, I'm sure as hell not going to put off listening to new PJ if it's out there.
If I died tomorrow, I'm pretty sure my last thought won't be "oh fuck, I'll never hear lightning bolt".
What if you died by getting hit by lightning?
Re: No Leak Club
Posted: Wed September 04, 2013 12:21 pm
by LikeLukin
I dunno man, if I don't hear what Getaway is like I will leave the world unfulfilled.
No time to be void or save up on life, boys.
Re: No Leak Club
Posted: Wed September 04, 2013 12:23 pm
by harmless
I hope it's like Ghost. Man, let it be like Ghost. That's a song some people find unremarkable; it's fast but mid-tempo fast... fits that description at least.
Re: No Leak Club
Posted: Wed September 04, 2013 12:42 pm
by Mike
The descriptions makes it sound like a R.E.M. song. Something like this
That would be cool.
Re: No Leak Club
Posted: Wed September 04, 2013 1:10 pm
by Dr. Van Nostrand
im thinking that if they release another single and its not lightning bolt or future days then i will try to avoid it until the album comes out, i dont know if i wanna hear another song with out having them all
Re: No Leak Club
Posted: Wed September 04, 2013 2:46 pm
by melonhead4
Sgt. Crackpot wrote:
LikeLukin wrote:You guys are crazy. Bring on a leak. Any of us could die tomorrow, I'm sure as hell not going to put off listening to new PJ if it's out there.
If I died tomorrow, I'm pretty sure my last thought won't be "oh fuck, I'll never hear lightning bolt".
Honestly that would be one of my last thoughts....maybe not thee last one but it would def run thru my mind...kinda sad actually
Re: No Leak Club
Posted: Wed September 04, 2013 2:47 pm
by melonhead4
harmless wrote:I hope it's like Ghost. Man, let it be like Ghost. That's a song some people find unremarkable; it's fast but mid-tempo fast... fits that description at least.
Ghost rocks
Re: No Leak Club
Posted: Wed September 04, 2013 3:06 pm
by melonhead4
stip wrote:
Sgt. Crackpot wrote:
LikeLukin wrote:You guys are crazy. Bring on a leak. Any of us could die tomorrow, I'm sure as hell not going to put off listening to new PJ if it's out there.
If I died tomorrow, I'm pretty sure my last thought won't be "oh fuck, I'll never hear lightning bolt".
What if you died by getting hit by lightning?
his last words would be LIGHTNING BAWLLLLT
Re: No Leak Club
Posted: Wed September 04, 2013 3:40 pm
by stip
verb_to_trust wrote:
Sgt. Crackpot wrote:Both LB and FD days are really a bit of a grey area. However, if any of one us were at the concert - should they be penalised?
I'm happy to let those ones be counted as offical release, because PJ played them to a buttload of people in a public arena. That's not really a leak, because they want people to hear it.
The soundcheck song is a hard one. But, considering:
A) We don't even know if it's PJ.
2) We don't even know if it's PJ playing a song from LB.
D) It's just loud, rhythmic, groovy noise - it could've just been a jam.
IX) If it's legit, they played it really fucking loud so surely they knew people would hear/record it.
It's like showing someone a blurry, shitty photo of a lightbulb and trying to tell them it's a flying saucer. I'm willing to let it slide.
Someone should have asked one of the Germany fans which album track "soundcheck song" was. It doesn't really sound like any of the descriptions they made...
I believe it was confirmed as infallible. And that pendulum has the tour video music.
Re: No Leak Club
Posted: Wed September 04, 2013 3:53 pm
by WaitingForBluey
Dr. Van Nostrand wrote:im thinking that if they release another single and its not lightning bolt or future days then i will try to avoid it until the album comes out, i dont know if i wanna hear another song with out having them all
Yea, I was just thinking the same thing. I was hoping it would be LB. Since I listened to that song once and have at least a vague idea of what it sounds like I would have no problem listening to it a few times if it was released as the 2nd single. But now the rumors are all pointing towards Sirens as being the 2nd single, and for a track that really seems to be the anchor of the album, I'm not sure if I'd rather wait and hear it in the context of the full album.
Re: No Leak Club
Posted: Wed September 04, 2013 4:02 pm
by southp
Dr. Van Nostrand wrote:im thinking that if they release another single and its not lightning bolt or future days then i will try to avoid it until the album comes out, i dont know if i wanna hear another song with out having them all
What if they play Letterman... you figure it's going to be MYM and then they start playing something altogether different. Do you turn it off?
Sorta like the NAIS -> Grievance situation.
I dunno man, if I don't hear what Getaway is like I will leave the world unfulfilled. 