Red Mosquito

I appreciate Carrie´s words. No bullshit. More truthful that Janet for sure.

i'm surprised janet lasted as long as she did

I'm okay with a band releasing a flop. At least they're trying something new. Hopefully they regroup and review why the album flops. Do they still really believe in it and it was the right album at the wrong time? Or was it a piece of shit and no one had the balls to tell the band?
Other creative mediums are much more allowing of a flop.

I'm totally in defense of Janet leaving the band if she felt like she needed to, but I also don't really get how someone could understand Carrie being pissed off about how it went down, particularly if it was truly that sudden. It's a situation where everyone is completely justified in their perspective.

tragabigzanda wrote:I think Carrie’s words have a fair amount of bullshit

Which part to you was the low key dig at men?

durdencommatyler wrote:

tragabigzanda wrote:I think Carrie’s words have a fair amount of bullshit

Which part to you was the low key dig at men?

Lol

Janet definitely thinks the record sucks, and based on what we've heard that is true. What I'd like to know is if she expressed frustration during recording that wasn't taken into consideration. If that was the scenario you can't really fault her for saying screw it.

verb_to_trust wrote:

durdencommatyler wrote:

tragabigzanda wrote:I think Carrie’s words have a fair amount of bullshit

Which part to you was the low key dig at men?

Lol

That's exactly what I thought.

fuck i love the new song.

VinylGuy wrote:fuck i love the new song.

I'm excited to hear it. I liked the first one so much that I just pre-ordered the record and decided not to listen to anything else until I have the whole album.

I'm down with everything SK right now.

VinylGuy wrote:fuck i love the new song.

definitely the best one of the bunch so far.

verb_to_trust wrote:Janet definitely thinks the record sucks, and based on what we've heard that is true. What I'd like to know is if she expressed frustration during recording that wasn't taken into consideration. If that was the scenario you can't really fault her for saying screw it.

After one album where she gets her feelings hurt? Lame.
Stone didn't leave Pearl Jam after Vitalogy.

Leatherhead wrote:

verb_to_trust wrote:Janet definitely thinks the record sucks, and based on what we've heard that is true. What I'd like to know is if she expressed frustration during recording that wasn't taken into consideration. If that was the scenario you can't really fault her for saying screw it.

After one album where she gets her feelings hurt? Lame.
Stone didn't leave Pearl Jam after Vitalogy.

He probably should have left after Backspacer. Boom is Annie Clark in this scenario.

I just don't see how there's enough information to form a reliable, informed opinion on this either way.

Trag, you at least have personal experience with SK to pull from. But I'm seeing too many strong opinions in general, all around, that it gives me pause and makes this whole thing feel weird and icky.

Im on team Carrie just knowing what we know.

durdencommatyler wrote:I just don't see how there's enough information to form a reliable, informed opinion on this either way.

Trag, you at least have personal experience with SK to pull from. But I'm seeing too many strong opinions in general, all around, that it gives me pause and makes this whole thing feel weird and icky.

This is where I stand. From an outsider's perspective it seems pretty shitty of Janet to leave the band at this time, but there's probably much more there.