Re: Quick Escape
Posted: Thu May 14, 2020 12:48 pm
More praise for phrasing in this one: "Living life on the back porch, lifting rocks to make a wage" is probably my favorite vocal moment.
Uh. Tons of people. Construction, landscapers, manual labor jobs. That is what it is referring to.Ms Harmless wrote:"lifting rocks to make a wage" is kind of embarrassing; who does that except for slaves and prisoners?
Monkey_Driven wrote:Lifting rocks can mean a lot of different things. I don't think it is intended to only be read in a literal way.
like sysiphus I move the rockMonkey_Driven wrote:Lifting rocks can mean a lot of different things. I don't think it is intended to only be read in a literal way.
OK, that makes senseStrat wrote:Uh. Tons of people. Construction, landscapers, manual labor jobs. That is what it is referring to.Ms Harmless wrote:"lifting rocks to make a wage" is kind of embarrassing; who does that except for slaves and prisoners?
It’s not even just that. It’s for anyone struggling through life even a minimum wage burger flipper.Ms Harmless wrote:OK, that makes senseStrat wrote:Uh. Tons of people. Construction, landscapers, manual labor jobs. That is what it is referring to.Ms Harmless wrote:"lifting rocks to make a wage" is kind of embarrassing; who does that except for slaves and prisoners?
yeah, I don't like it as a metaphor for all that personallyBammer wrote:It’s not even just that. It’s for anyone struggling through life even a minimum wage burger flipper.Ms Harmless wrote:OK, that makes senseStrat wrote:Uh. Tons of people. Construction, landscapers, manual labor jobs. That is what it is referring to.Ms Harmless wrote:"lifting rocks to make a wage" is kind of embarrassing; who does that except for slaves and prisoners?
I take it as very metaphorical and a tip of the cap to the hard-working 99%.Ms Harmless wrote:"lifting rocks to make a wage" is kind of embarrassing; who does that except for slaves and prisoners?
yeah I think it calls to mind that term "wage slave", one I've never been too comfortable with... but hey no biggieguitar_davey wrote:I take it as very metaphorical and a tip of the cap to the hard-working 99%.Ms Harmless wrote:"lifting rocks to make a wage" is kind of embarrassing; who does that except for slaves and prisoners?
I support myself and family well being a rock flipper. It like Springsteen singing about the various people in his songs. The difference is Springsteen knows he is a fraud and Ed hasn't figured it out yet.Ms Harmless wrote:yeah I think it calls to mind that term "wage slave", one I've never been too comfortable with... but hey no biggieguitar_davey wrote:I take it as very metaphorical and a tip of the cap to the hard-working 99%.Ms Harmless wrote:"lifting rocks to make a wage" is kind of embarrassing; who does that except for slaves and prisoners?
yeah that's a lot to do with itTj wrote:I support myself and family well being a rock flipper. It like Springsteen singing about the various people in his songs. The difference is Springsteen knows he is a fraud and Ed hasn't figured it out yet.Ms Harmless wrote:yeah I think it calls to mind that term "wage slave", one I've never been too comfortable with... but hey no biggieguitar_davey wrote:I take it as very metaphorical and a tip of the cap to the hard-working 99%.Ms Harmless wrote:"lifting rocks to make a wage" is kind of embarrassing; who does that except for slaves and prisoners?
This is how I took it as well.Kevin Davis wrote:I listened to this today, with this lyrical discussion in mind, and I think that, taken in the context of the verse, Ed actually intends a positive meaning of "lifting rocks to make a wage."
Living life on the back porch
Lifting rocks to make a wage
Every sunset paid attention to
Not a starry night went to waste
He's effectively describing a kind of pressure free "simple life," where the rock-lifting represents "an honest day's work" before coming home and reveling in the small pleasures of everyday life, now enlightened enough to take none of them for granted. All in the context of this sort of Utopian retreat from whatever horrors are being visited upon the rest of the civilized world.
Thematically this song is basically "In Hiding" on a global level.
I resemble this threadstip wrote:like sysiphus I move the rockMonkey_Driven wrote:Lifting rocks can mean a lot of different things. I don't think it is intended to only be read in a literal way.
Likewise.LikeLukin wrote:This is how I took it as well.Kevin Davis wrote:I listened to this today, with this lyrical discussion in mind, and I think that, taken in the context of the verse, Ed actually intends a positive meaning of "lifting rocks to make a wage."
Living life on the back porch
Lifting rocks to make a wage
Every sunset paid attention to
Not a starry night went to waste
He's effectively describing a kind of pressure free "simple life," where the rock-lifting represents "an honest day's work" before coming home and reveling in the small pleasures of everyday life, now enlightened enough to take none of them for granted. All in the context of this sort of Utopian retreat from whatever horrors are being visited upon the rest of the civilized world.
Thematically this song is basically "In Hiding" on a global level.
Jaeti wrote:LikeLukin wrote:This is how I took it as well.Kevin Davis wrote:I listened to this today, with this lyrical discussion in mind, and I think that, taken in the context of the verse, Ed actually intends a positive meaning of "lifting rocks to make a wage."
Living life on the back porch
Lifting rocks to make a wage
Every sunset paid attention to
Not a starry night went to waste
He's effectively describing a kind of pressure free "simple life," where the rock-lifting represents "an honest day's work" before coming home and reveling in the small pleasures of everyday life, now enlightened enough to take none of them for granted. All in the context of this sort of Utopian retreat from whatever horrors are being visited upon the rest of the civilized world.
Thematically this song is basically "In Hiding" on a global level.![]()
Likewise.
Well said, as usual. I just wanted to lend my voice to the choir agreeing with you here. I was trying to formulate a post that said this same basic thing but it wasn't coming out the right way. So thank you.Kevin Davis wrote:I listened to this today, with this lyrical discussion in mind, and I think that, taken in the context of the verse, Ed actually intends a positive meaning of "lifting rocks to make a wage."
Living life on the back porch
Lifting rocks to make a wage
Every sunset paid attention to
Not a starry night went to waste
He's effectively describing a kind of pressure free "simple life," where the rock-lifting represents "an honest day's work" before coming home and reveling in the small pleasures of everyday life, now enlightened enough to take none of them for granted. All in the context of this sort of Utopian retreat from whatever horrors are being visited upon the rest of the civilized world.
Thematically this song is basically "In Hiding" on a global level.
I reject the notion that one must be required to have a specific experience or background to write from that perspective. Both Springsteen and Ed can be very empathetic writers.Ms Harmless wrote:yeah that's a lot to do with itTj wrote:I support myself and family well being a rock flipper. It like Springsteen singing about the various people in his songs. The difference is Springsteen knows he is a fraud and Ed hasn't figured it out yet.Ms Harmless wrote:yeah I think it calls to mind that term "wage slave", one I've never been too comfortable with... but hey no biggieguitar_davey wrote:I take it as very metaphorical and a tip of the cap to the hard-working 99%.Ms Harmless wrote:"lifting rocks to make a wage" is kind of embarrassing; who does that except for slaves and prisoners?