Page 38 of 42

Re: Song of the Moment: Yellow Moon

Posted: Thu April 30, 2020 3:53 am
by Rob
Yellow Moon with a Gigaton level of production would be amazing.

Re: Song of the Moment: Yellow Moon

Posted: Thu April 30, 2020 3:53 am
by E.H. Ruddock
Are you doing an impression

Re: Song of the Moment: Yellow Moon

Posted: Thu April 30, 2020 3:54 am
by Rob
Wow, look at the poll for this song. The board loved it then. Curious what people think now.

Re: Song of the Moment: Yellow Moon

Posted: Thu April 30, 2020 3:54 am
by Rob
E.H. Ruddock wrote:Are you doing an impression
That or drinky drinky, or weed, or corona.

Re: Song of the Moment: Yellow Moon

Posted: Thu April 30, 2020 3:55 am
by tragabigzanda
pearl jam sucks now

Re: Song of the Moment: Yellow Moon

Posted: Thu April 30, 2020 4:21 am
by bodysnatcher
tragabigzanda wrote:
E.H. Ruddock wrote:Are you doing an impression
PM me for dick pix and Yellow Moon rehearsal bootlegs
Yellow Moon rehearsal = album cut

Re: Song of the Moment: Yellow Moon

Posted: Thu April 30, 2020 4:22 am
by tragabigzanda
pearl jam sucks now

Re: Song of the Moment: Yellow Moon

Posted: Thu April 30, 2020 5:03 am
by Hypnos

Re: Song of the Moment: Yellow Moon

Posted: Thu April 30, 2020 9:32 am
by Ms Harmless
it's OK, I was grateful for a song like this when it first came out; it's pretty

but we had "Lowlight", and now we have "Buckle Up", so it's a tad redundant

Re: Song of the Moment: Yellow Moon

Posted: Thu April 30, 2020 11:58 am
by warehouse
i can usually just ignore lyrics and pay attention to music/vocals, but the second verse is maybe the worst thing eddie vedder ever wrote. they bridge is fine, but i have really have no desire to hear this song.

Re: Song of the Moment: Yellow Moon

Posted: Thu April 30, 2020 12:45 pm
by Ms Harmless
warehouse wrote:i can usually just ignore lyrics and pay attention to music/vocals, but the second verse is maybe the worst thing eddie vedder ever wrote. they bridge is fine, but i have really have no desire to hear this song.
how does the second verse go again?

Re: Song of the Moment: Yellow Moon

Posted: Thu April 30, 2020 12:50 pm
by stip
round and round we go
where we stop no one knows
so tonight the moon I go

Perfectly good lyrics that tie in well with a song about contemplating suicide in the face of a seemingly meaningless or insignificant existence


the post, however, is a great example of the hyperbolic illiteracy that categorizes most conversations about lightning bolt

Re: Song of the Moment: Yellow Moon

Posted: Thu April 30, 2020 12:52 pm
by stip
I gave this a listen last night. Eddie sounds really good on this

Re: Song of the Moment: Yellow Moon

Posted: Thu April 30, 2020 12:53 pm
by Juvenal
stip wrote:I gave this a listen last night. Eddie sounds really good on this
:thumbsup:

Re: Song of the Moment: Yellow Moon

Posted: Thu April 30, 2020 12:54 pm
by warehouse
stip wrote:round and round we go
where we stop no one knows
so tonight the moon I go

Perfectly good lyrics that tie in well with a song about contemplating suicide in the face of a seemingly meaningless or insignificant existence


the post, however, is a great example of the hyperbolic illiteracy that categorizes most conversations about lightning bolt
those lyrics sound like they were written by a child. sure, if you want to say they are good in the context of the song, go for it, but they are terrible.

also, i had no idea you were such an arrogant dickhead.

edit: seriously, what a ridiculously pretentious insult. how smug do you have to be to post something like that?

Re: Song of the Moment: Yellow Moon

Posted: Thu April 30, 2020 1:06 pm
by Ms Harmless
when you say "those lyrics sound like they were written by a child", you should know that it's literally a children's nursery rhyme, so leaving aside how you may feel about using children's traditional merry-go-round mantras in a song in general, these lyrics are fine and aren't Ed being juvenile

I just wish the production and instrumentation of the song was more nuanced and creative, so that we could hear a little of that quaint music-box Victoriana aesthetic in more than just the lyrics

I don't mind seeing the whole song as a nursery rhyme

Re: Song of the Moment: Yellow Moon

Posted: Thu April 30, 2020 1:09 pm
by warehouse
Ms Harmless wrote:when you say "this looks like it's written by a child", you should know that it's literally a children's nursery rhyme, so leaving aside how you may feel about using children's traditional merry-go-round mantras in a song in general, these lyrics are fine and aren't Ed being juvenile

I just wish the production and instrumentation of the song was more nuanced and creative, so that we could hear a little of that quaint music-box Victoriana aesthetic in more than just the lyrics

I don't mind seeing the whole song as a nursery rhyme
i never looked at it as a nursery rhyme the way 'around the bend' is, but thats an interesting thought. i think i heard the same line in a pink floyd song recently and had the same thought: "that was the line?"

i think like most songs, this would improve with the new producer. maybe ill try to find a good live version of it.

Re: Song of the Moment: Yellow Moon

Posted: Thu April 30, 2020 1:09 pm
by stip
warehouse wrote:
stip wrote:round and round we go
where we stop no one knows
so tonight the moon I go

Perfectly good lyrics that tie in well with a song about contemplating suicide in the face of a seemingly meaningless or insignificant existence


the post, however, is a great example of the hyperbolic illiteracy that categorizes most conversations about lightning bolt
those lyrics sound like they were written by a child. sure, if you want to say they are good in the context of the song, go for it, but they are terrible.

also, i had no idea you were such an arrogant dickhead.

edit: seriously, what a ridiculously pretentious insult. how smug do you have to be to post something like that?
Less smug, more exhausted

Re: Song of the Moment: Yellow Moon

Posted: Thu April 30, 2020 1:11 pm
by warehouse
stip wrote:
warehouse wrote:
stip wrote:round and round we go
where we stop no one knows
so tonight the moon I go

Perfectly good lyrics that tie in well with a song about contemplating suicide in the face of a seemingly meaningless or insignificant existence


the post, however, is a great example of the hyperbolic illiteracy that categorizes most conversations about lightning bolt
those lyrics sound like they were written by a child. sure, if you want to say they are good in the context of the song, go for it, but they are terrible.

also, i had no idea you were such an arrogant dickhead.

edit: seriously, what a ridiculously pretentious insult. how smug do you have to be to post something like that?
Less smug, more exhausted
exhausted from what? patting yourself on the back?

Re: Song of the Moment: Yellow Moon

Posted: Thu April 30, 2020 1:13 pm
by stip
Harmless just said it, but it is a child's nursery rhyme, and it evokes the feeling of a carousel. Constant movement with no destination that is enchanting as a child but feels pointless as an adult. Likewise, the image/lyric of 'to the moon I go' as a way to process/understand what happens when you die/what comes next is there to highlight how overmatched and overwhelmed the singer feels. He is reduced to a childlike level of understanding against the existential enormity of the moment.