Red Mosquito

dimejinky99 wrote:

stip wrote:

dimejinky99 wrote:OH god.
The red letter media review is out and the TLJ hate brigade are using it as their new favourite argument.

Ugh.

what did they say?

They hate it. ‘But they’d have a well thought out articulate argument about WHY ITS THE WORST FILM EVER MADE!’

Apparently

Slightly disappointing but not all together surprising. They are slavishly devoted to a certain idea of what Star Wars is

Rian did a Q&A after a screening in LA and was asked specifically about Rey's parentage.

Basically, Rian said he wrote down every possible parent idea he could think of: Obi-Wan, Luke, Han & Leia, Snoke, Plagueous, Palpatine and on and on. He tried to play out how all of these would go and he ultimately decided that the best possible/most satisfying and appropriate option was for her parents to be "no one special" because it presented an obstacle for Rey to overcome.

stip wrote:

VinylGuy wrote:Joe is getting anxious with all these opinions.

No one is arguing with your opinions. We are arguing with your apparent fundamental misunderstanding of the text

It’s the difference between not liking betterman because you don’t care for the melody and not liking betterman because you think it’s an upbeat affirmation of two people’s enduring love

What Stip said.

stip wrote:

dimejinky99 wrote:

stip wrote:

dimejinky99 wrote:OH god.
The red letter media review is out and the TLJ hate brigade are using it as their new favourite argument.

Ugh.

what did they say?

They hate it. ‘But they’d have a well thought out articulate argument about WHY ITS THE WORST FILM EVER MADE!’

Apparently

Slightly disappointing but not all together surprising. They are slavishly devoted to a certain idea of what Star Wars is

Having said that - I’ll watch his eventual video. I Can’t stand his sidekicks on the review show, though. They are never insightful and walking embodiments of nerd fanboy destructive privelage

Speaking of....DID KEVIN SMITH LIKE IT?!

stip wrote:

VinylGuy wrote:Joe is getting anxious with all these opinions.

No one is arguing with your opinions. We are arguing with your apparent fundamental misunderstanding of the text

It’s the difference between not liking betterman because you don’t care for the melody and not liking betterman because you think it’s an upbeat affirmation of two people’s enduring love

Well, i feel i have a stronger point that what you say with the betterman comparison...but maybe yeah, im wayy off !!!

Why should I care what red letter media says?

stip wrote:Speaking of....DID KEVIN SMITH LIKE IT?!

http://comicbook.com/starwars/2017/12/1 ... vin-smith/

Haven't watched yet.

stip wrote:Speaking of....DID KEVIN SMITH LIKE IT?!

Gonna take a punt and say he hates it cos he wasn’t given a cameo in it.

Strat wrote:

stip wrote:Speaking of....DID KEVIN SMITH LIKE IT?!

http://comicbook.com/starwars/2017/12/1 ... vin-smith/

Haven't watched yet.

I thought you were saying he hasn't watched it yet, and on no planet in any galaxy at any time is that the case

stip wrote:

Strat wrote:

stip wrote:Speaking of....DID KEVIN SMITH LIKE IT?!

http://comicbook.com/starwars/2017/12/1 ... vin-smith/

Haven't watched yet.

I thought you were saying he hasn't watched it yet, and on no planet in any galaxy at any time is that the case

lol!

Yea. Anyone get the gist of it?

Strat wrote:

stip wrote:

Strat wrote:

stip wrote:Speaking of....DID KEVIN SMITH LIKE IT?!

http://comicbook.com/starwars/2017/12/1 ... vin-smith/

Haven't watched yet.

I thought you were saying he hasn't watched it yet, and on no planet in any galaxy at any time is that the case

lol!

Yea. Anyone get the gist of it?

He thinks the film is Oscar worthy.

Did Mr. Plinkett review this yet

yes, but not as plinkett

stip wrote:yes, but not as plinkett

Then NO

durdencommatyler wrote:Rian did a Q&A after a screening in LA and was asked specifically about Rey's parentage.

Basically, Rian said he wrote down every possible parent idea he could think of: Obi-Wan, Luke, Han & Leia, Snoke, Plagueous, Palpatine and on and on. He tried to play out how all of these would go and he ultimately decided that the best possible/most satisfying and appropriate option was for her parents to be "no one special" because it presented an obstacle for Rey to overcome.

So this was my post from August:

http://forums.theskyiscrape.com/viewtop ... 85#p984785

Sgt. Crackpot wrote:I hate the fact that it seems the movies are now becoming less of a progression of the story, and an expansion of the universe, and more of a thrill for the directors/writes to have:

• Have someone related to somebody. i.e. One of the key good guys is related to one of the bad guys. And someone is the descendant of someone.
• Kill someone off.

Star Wars makers, stop trying to find links and kill off people to try to gain shock value. We had the brilliant "No, I am your father" moment in the past. Stop trying to recreate that moment.

Please, just tell great stories, with lots of pew pews and gold bikinis.

I'm so glad that Rian took this path in regards to Rey's parents. I hope JJ sticks with it through EP IX.

On another note, while Rian killed off Luke - he did it in such an amazing and unexpected way. Only when we see Luke fade, was when I realised what was happening. A sad but amazing moment.

I fucking love Rian for what he did with some of these aspects.

I have a load of respect for Rian doing what he did. He made choices in this movie not to be popular or do what he thinks everyone wanted him to do. He made these choices for the purposes of amazing story telling and challenging not only his audience, but the characters within his story.

The sad thing is that a good portion of the audience don't like to be challenged. They want an easy story.

stip wrote:

VinylGuy wrote:Joe is getting anxious with all these opinions.

No one is arguing with your opinions. We are arguing with your apparent fundamental misunderstanding of the text

It’s the difference between not liking betterman because you don’t care for the melody and not liking betterman because you think it’s an upbeat affirmation of two people’s enduring love

That's the most arrogant thing I've read in this thread.

And it's competing with a lot like this:

Sgt. Crackpot wrote:The sad thing is that a good portion of the audience don't like to be challenged. They want an easy story.