Page 5 of 5
Re: Bands where the very first song defines their whole deal
Posted: Thu January 13, 2022 12:28 am
by warehouse
oasisfan35 wrote:warehouse wrote:Chris_H_2 wrote:warehouse wrote:'first song' as in 'first hit' or 'first track on their first album'? i'm going with the former
teen spirit
one armed scissor
sail
pumped up kicks
put your hands where my eyes can see
get at me dog
break on through
ants marching
its literally 'warehouse' and i will quote myself from 12 years ago about why
Warehouse very much encapsulates a lot of what DMB was before 2009 but it is neither their first hit or the first track on their first album.
Ants Marching would be both of these, depending on your criteria of 'hit'.

Re: Bands where the very first song defines their whole deal
Posted: Thu January 13, 2022 12:33 am
by liebzz
Ants Marching is very much their whole deal for the first couple of albums, but I think they grew a bit more…I don’t want to use dark or gritty…but more substantial with Before These Crowded Streets and much of the albums beyond that. But that buoyant jazzy sound mostly left them after Crash. Some flashes of it from a song or two. They became much more of a rock band.
Re: Bands where the very first song defines their whole deal
Posted: Thu January 13, 2022 12:58 am
by oasisfan35
liebzz wrote:Ants Marching is very much their whole deal for the first couple of albums, but I think they grew a bit more…I don’t want to use dark or gritty…but more substantial with Before These Crowded Streets and much of the albums beyond that. But that buoyant jazzy sound mostly left them after Crash. Some flashes of it from a song or two. They became much more of a rock band.
Before These Crowded Streets being crafted so much in the studio is just such a different animal than its predecessors, it is 'bigger' on many levels and wonderfully produced. Not that the previous two albums aren't produced well I just feel Lillywhite's propensity to push toward grandeur really synced with a band on the rise after a few comfortable albums together. The mire of the Dave Matthews Band's relationship with producers and studio output from the
Lillywhite Sessions onward is really something to behold.
Re: Bands where the very first song defines their whole deal
Posted: Thu January 13, 2022 1:22 am
by liebzz
Nevertheless, they’ve still had some very solid albums that get buried by their live reputation.
Re: Bands where the very first song defines their whole deal
Posted: Thu January 13, 2022 1:43 am
by oasisfan35
liebzz wrote:Nevertheless, they’ve still had some very solid albums that get buried by their live reputation.
The live entity is also quite the examination over the last thirty years.
I adore many of the albums and have come to respect many other tracks, along with the band's musicianship and ability to be a cohesive touring act, through their live renditions. Idunno, I lived with this band for quite a while and these days just gets me thinking about a long journey.
Re: Bands where the very first song defines their whole deal
Posted: Thu January 13, 2022 6:33 am
by Higgs
USA for Africa
Re: Bands where the very first song defines their whole deal
Posted: Fri January 14, 2022 11:00 pm
by warehouse
oasisfan35 wrote:liebzz wrote:Ants Marching is very much their whole deal for the first couple of albums, but I think they grew a bit more…I don’t want to use dark or gritty…but more substantial with Before These Crowded Streets and much of the albums beyond that. But that buoyant jazzy sound mostly left them after Crash. Some flashes of it from a song or two. They became much more of a rock band.
Before These Crowded Streets being crafted so much in the studio is just such a different animal than its predecessors, it is 'bigger' on many levels and wonderfully produced. Not that the previous two albums aren't produced well I just feel Lillywhite's propensity to push toward grandeur really synced with a band on the rise after a few comfortable albums together. The mire of the Dave Matthews Band's relationship with producers and studio output from the
Lillywhite Sessions onward is really something to behold.
ants marching makes sense. even today most of their songs are born from dave matthews and his acoustic guitar. they definitely got darker with later albums and heavier, especially live.