Re: My Morning Jacket
Posted: Mon April 21, 2025 5:58 am
amazing show tonight. still one of the best live bands.
I really like Time Waited actually.Buby wrote:Took me a while, but I'm loving "Is" right now.
Maybe not thrilled by "Time Waited" but it's the only one.
I don't know why I singled that one out, I don't dislike it either.liebzz wrote:I really like Time Waited actually.Buby wrote:Took me a while, but I'm loving "Is" right now.
Maybe not thrilled by "Time Waited" but it's the only one.
Much of their self-titled record is focused on building to the MMJ cacophony climax that Z masters. Wasted, off The Waterfall II, is maybe the peak of that sound but much of the next album explores that. Is doesn’t attempt too much in the way of that, and plays with sonic textures in spots, but I don’t think even in generalities that this is the case. I think really the biggest post-Z crime is that they haven’t used the reverb on James’s voice that was a signature of their earlier sound. The band, I think, still sounds mostly great on their albums. I guess in graduating from recording albums in a grain silo that they didn’t want to explore those vocal effects again.OmegaprimeVKM wrote:Struggled with the records since The Waterfall came out. After that I feel they've become more a support band for JJ's desire to be a soul singer.
Perhaps, and that's fine. It's just that the records since don't have tracks on them that stick in the mind beyond an initial listen for that very reason. I can still listen to the non-notable early tracks from early records, even stuff from Circuitual and feel there's enough to warrant that 100th listen. I guess that's what I am missing.liebzz wrote:Much of their self-titled record is focused on building to the MMJ cacophony climax that Z masters. Wasted, off The Waterfall II, is maybe the peak of that sound but much of the next album explores that. Is doesn’t attempt too much in the way of that, and plays with sonic textures in spots, but I don’t think even in generalities that this is the case. I think really the biggest post-Z crime is that they haven’t used the reverb on James’s voice that was a signature of their earlier sound. The band, I think, still sounds mostly great on their albums. I guess in graduating from recording albums in a grain silo that they didn’t want to explore those vocal effects again.OmegaprimeVKM wrote:Struggled with the records since The Waterfall came out. After that I feel they've become more a support band for JJ's desire to be a soul singer.
Buby wrote:We can finally talk about “The Devil’s Peanut Butter”.
Without generalizing too much, I would say as nearly every artist’s catalogue grows over the years that happens though. I mean, fast forward the Stones 25 years from their first album, and by the mid-80s, there’s a handful of memorable tracks but it is the exception over the rule.OmegaprimeVKM wrote:Perhaps, and that's fine. It's just that the records since don't have tracks on them that stick in the mind beyond an initial listen for that very reason. I can still listen to the non-notable early tracks from early records, even stuff from Circuitual and feel there's enough to warrant that 100th listen. I guess that's what I am missing.liebzz wrote:Much of their self-titled record is focused on building to the MMJ cacophony climax that Z masters. Wasted, off The Waterfall II, is maybe the peak of that sound but much of the next album explores that. Is doesn’t attempt too much in the way of that, and plays with sonic textures in spots, but I don’t think even in generalities that this is the case. I think really the biggest post-Z crime is that they haven’t used the reverb on James’s voice that was a signature of their earlier sound. The band, I think, still sounds mostly great on their albums. I guess in graduating from recording albums in a grain silo that they didn’t want to explore those vocal effects again.OmegaprimeVKM wrote:Struggled with the records since The Waterfall came out. After that I feel they've become more a support band for JJ's desire to be a soul singer.
I'll still see them every time they play London
Glad to read this. I listened it "Is" twice and never put it back on. I still spin a lot of Waterfall II regularly and some songs from Self-Titled. The new didn't feel as good. I'll try again!Buby wrote:I don't know why I singled that one out, I don't dislike it either.liebzz wrote:I really like Time Waited actually.Buby wrote:Took me a while, but I'm loving "Is" right now.
Maybe not thrilled by "Time Waited" but it's the only one.
I suddenly really really liked all the rest.