Red Mosquito

Im still hoping Han isnt dead. Its weird we didnt get a funeral or something...it was pretty anti climatic even if the whole scene was really pushed in that direction.

Chris_H_2 wrote:My only other criticism is that we spent 5 1/2 movies watching and being reminded that an apprentice needs to be trained in the force before doing anything meaningful, while here Rey seems to have figured things out quite well for herself, and did so in little less than an hour. So either she is a special brand of Jedi, or Obi Wan and Yoda were full of shit.

Unless she was under the training of Luke before Kylo Ren's attack on the academy.

VinylGuy wrote:Im still hoping Han isnt dead. Its weird we didnt get a funeral or something...it was pretty anti climatic even if the whole scene was really pushed in that direction.

I bet he's in his direwolf

VinylGuy wrote:Im still hoping Han isnt dead. Its weird we didnt get a funeral or something...it was pretty anti climatic even if the whole scene was really pushed in that direction.

I'm sure they'll reflect on him at the beginning of the next movie. That's about all they really need to do. It would be beyond terrible to have him survive this. They're trying to pass the baton to these new characters - who certainly showed in this movie that they're worthy successors.

Monkey_Driven wrote:

Chris_H_2 wrote:My only other criticism is that we spent 5 1/2 movies watching and being reminded that an apprentice needs to be trained in the force before doing anything meaningful, while here Rey seems to have figured things out quite well for herself, and did so in little less than an hour. So either she is a special brand of Jedi, or Obi Wan and Yoda were full of shit.

Unless she was under the training of Luke before Kylo Ren's attack on the academy.

That would be great. That scene of her being ripped away showed her as a really young girl though

Chris_H_2 wrote:

Monkey_Driven wrote:

Chris_H_2 wrote:My only other criticism is that we spent 5 1/2 movies watching and being reminded that an apprentice needs to be trained in the force before doing anything meaningful, while here Rey seems to have figured things out quite well for herself, and did so in little less than an hour. So either she is a special brand of Jedi, or Obi Wan and Yoda were full of shit.

Unless she was under the training of Luke before Kylo Ren's attack on the academy.

That would be great. That scene of her being ripped away showed her as a really young girl though

Could be a very young apprentice.

Fairly confident she never met or knew Luke.

Think back on the scene with Han in the falcon
'You knew Luke skywalker????'
'Yeah. I knew luke'
That puts that notion that she knew him to bed

I have some questions that I think could be answered prior to EP8, or even by someone who has seen it twice...

Who was the old man at the beginning who had the map to Luke? In our post-viewing discussion we were calling him "Obi-Wan's brother."
Why did Yaz (was that her name) have the Lightsabre and who's sabre was it originally?
During the Rey flashback was she watching Ren kill other Jedi in training? And who are the guys with Ren?

southp wrote:I have some questions that I think could be answered prior to EP8, or even by someone who has seen it twice...

Who was the old man at the beginning who had the map to Luke? In our post-viewing discussion we were calling him "Obi-Wan's brother."
Why did Yaz (was that her name) have the Lightsabre and who's sabre was it originally?
During the Rey flashback was she watching Ren kill other Jedi in training? And who are the guys with Ren?

Max Von shadow was the old man. He clearly knew leia at least in the past as he says 'she'll always be royalty to me' an he smiles. *think* his mission was to be around for Rey I think I'm not 100% (to give the map to Rey when the time came?)

Maz has Lukes original lightsaber which was anakins before him. How she came to have it??
Mystery totally

The flashback could possibly be a flash forward

Think about how we see Luke sitting with R2.. Clearly a shot of the future as Luke left R2 behind and is only reunited with him at the end of the film so I'm thinking that force vision she had was flashback and flash forwards of what is to come

BTW, I'm seeing it again this afternoon with my kids. Is it weird that I'm more excited seeing it for the second time less than 24 hours after seeing it the first time?

Chris_H_2 wrote:BTW, I'm seeing it again this afternoon with my kids. Is it weird that I'm more excited seeing it for the second time less than 24 hours after seeing it the first time?

I actually thought it better the second time.
Be interested to see if you do too

dimejinky99 wrote:

southp wrote:I have some questions that I think could be answered prior to EP8, or even by someone who has seen it twice...

Who was the old man at the beginning who had the map to Luke? In our post-viewing discussion we were calling him "Obi-Wan's brother."
Why did Yaz (was that her name) have the Lightsabre and who's sabre was it originally?
During the Rey flashback was she watching Ren kill other Jedi in training? And who are the guys with Ren?

Max Von shadow was the old man. He clearly knew leia at least in the past as he says 'she'll always be royalty to me' an he smiles. *think* his mission was to be around for Rey I think I'm not 100% (to give the map to Rey when the time came?)

Maz has Lukes original lightsaber which was anakins before him. How she came to have it??
Mystery totally

The flashback could possibly be a flash forward

Think about how we see Luke sitting with R2.. Clearly a shot of the future as Luke left R2 behind and is only reunited with him at the end of the film so I'm thinking that force vision she had was flashback and flash forwards of what is to come

Thanks for clearing some of that up Dime. I suspected it was Luke's only because it looked like it came from the 70's and because of the way Rey handed it back to him at the end. In which case it makes you wonder about the "Luke hand clone theory".

p.s. Don't forget, wasn't just Luke's, it was actually Anakin's saber.

The clip of him sitting with R2 and then removing his hood at the end..no glove even..it doesn't mean anything I just thought it strange

dimejinky99 wrote:The clip of him sitting with R2 and then removing his hood at the end..no glove even..it doesn't mean anything I just thought it strange

I liked your idea of it being a flashforward, but I interpreted it as being the moment that Luke gave R2 the main piece of the map.

If anyone didn't feel their heart melt when R2 was in low-power mode... then you're just a very sad sad sad person.

Yeah R2 is my favourite character after Han. He always saves the day:)


Good thinking on him giving R2 the map!

Also went to tears when leia walks outta the transport and Hans standing there.

That was done soooo well

southp wrote:If anyone didn't feel their heart melt when R2 was in low-power mode... then you're just a very sad sad sad person.

#5 IS ALIVE!

The opening crawl for anyone who wants to see it again:

https://vid.me/qa3w

Obviously spoilery so avoid if not yet seen

BB-8 and R2 need to have a standalone movie.