Red Mosquito

theplatypus wrote:

knee tunes wrote:

WtOB? wrote:spenno, yellow moon is fantastic.

it is.

this is the only song ever where I ever thought (at the start of "round") it to be a perfect place to have a chorus of black lady back up singers. the song would, like, double

I wish they had done that. It would've been hilarious

why?

Birds in Hell wrote:

WtOB? wrote:spenno, yellow moon is fantastic.

In the words of Shaun Micallef, INTO THE BIN.

knee tunes wrote:

McParadigm wrote:

knee tunes wrote:

WtOB? wrote:spenno, yellow moon is fantastic.

it is.

this is the only song ever where I ever thought (at the start of "round") it to be a perfect place to have a chorus of black lady back up singers. the song would, like, double

I can at least admit that Abattoir era Nick Cave would destroy the shit out of this song. The Pearl Jam take was unremarkable.

to gather a remarkable song even from an unremarkable take makes the song remarkable plus? (? or is my math off ?)

Okay song + unremarkable/uninspired arrangement and performance = Pearl Jam
Okay song + fantastic arrangement and performance = Nick Cave

theplatypus wrote:

knee tunes wrote:

WtOB? wrote:spenno, yellow moon is fantastic.

it is.

this is the only song ever where I ever thought (at the start of "round") it to be a perfect place to have a chorus of black lady back up singers. the song would, like, double

I wish they had done that. It would've been hilarious

McParadigm wrote:

knee tunes wrote:

McParadigm wrote:

knee tunes wrote:

WtOB? wrote:spenno, yellow moon is fantastic.

it is.

this is the only song ever where I ever thought (at the start of "round") it to be a perfect place to have a chorus of black lady back up singers. the song would, like, double

I can at least admit that Abattoir era Nick Cave would destroy the shit out of this song. The Pearl Jam take was unremarkable.

to gather a remarkable song even from an unremarkable take makes the song remarkable plus? (? or is my math off ?)

Okay song + unremarkable/uninspired arrangement and performance = Pearl Jam
Okay sog + fantastic arrangement and performance = Nick Cave

Pre 2003 pearl jam would've made it awesome

To myself I surrender

PJ hasn't made anything 'awesome' since Riot Act. I take what I can get. A million artists could do PJ songs better than PJ now; so what? Sigur Ros is better than all of them anyway.

harmless wrote:PJ hasn't made anything 'awesome' since Riot Act. I take what I can get. A million artists could do PJ songs better than PJ now; so what? Sigur Ros is better than all of them anyway.

Wow. I remember when you were crazy about this album.

VinylGuy wrote:

harmless wrote:PJ hasn't made anything 'awesome' since Riot Act. I take what I can get. A million artists could do PJ songs better than PJ now; so what? Sigur Ros is better than all of them anyway.

Wow. I remember when you were crazy about this album.

I don't see that the two sentiments are opposing, necessarily.

I think pendulum is pretty much at the level they were at with riot act. It wouldn't be one of the best tracks on that album, but it's in it's league. Parachutes is the only other post RA song you could say that about.

Infallible is what they tried with RA, but well made.

McParadigm wrote:

VinylGuy wrote:

harmless wrote:PJ hasn't made anything 'awesome' since Riot Act. I take what I can get. A million artists could do PJ songs better than PJ now; so what? Sigur Ros is better than all of them anyway.

Wow. I remember when you were crazy about this album.

I don't see that the two sentiments are opposing, necessarily.

I'm constantly accused of going back and forth on my opinions. I don't, but I am capable of holding two opinions in tension. Paradox is a great thing!

I was never crazy about the album in relation to the first seven. What I've always been is pleasantly surprised at how good it is considering their output since 2006. Grading on a curve, people.

harmless wrote:I'm constantly accused of going back and forth on my opinions. I don't, but I am capable of holding two opinions in tension. Paradox is a great thing!

I was never crazy about the album in relation to the first seven. What I've always been is pleasantly surprised at how good it is considering their output since 2006. Grading on a curve, people.

It can sometimes read like flip-flopping, but that's the internet for you. Lots of trying to explain feelings in short, punctuative posts, and lots of contextual shifts. Disaster ensues.

I remember when the album first dropped you said something about grading on a curve, then, too...which is why I posted what I did above. Then I think stip asked what I grade on, and I said a knife. It might be the only thing I remember out of all those thousands of pages we filled up.

I was just trying to mess with Harmless.

VinylGuy wrote:I was just trying to mess with Harmless.

Man I wish we still had all the riot act era postings on this board

Did Chud think it sucked?

stip wrote:Man I wish we still had all the riot act era postings on this board

it would be pretty fun to read through again, but as one who want a fan for a pretty long time, feelings can definitely change. for me riot act was SO good at first just like all of their albums aside from Binaural, but after a few months i kinda got tired of it, i would use some songs in PJ mix cds since i was listening to a ton of stuff that way, but couldnt do the whole album, it just didnt really work for me, but i think within the last year or so i started to revisit it and im finding myself loving a lot of the songs i didnt before, its been a real nice turn around. but saying all that, its still near the bottom of my album rankings

SW is really good.

McParadigm wrote:

harmless wrote:I'm constantly accused of going back and forth on my opinions. I don't, but I am capable of holding two opinions in tension. Paradox is a great thing!

I was never crazy about the album in relation to the first seven. What I've always been is pleasantly surprised at how good it is considering their output since 2006. Grading on a curve, people.

It can sometimes read like flip-flopping, but that's the internet for you. Lots of trying to explain feelings in short, punctuative posts, and lots of contextual shifts. Disaster ensues.

I remember when the album first dropped you said something about grading on a curve, then, too...which is why I posted what I did above. Then I think stip asked what I grade on, and I said a knife. It might be the only thing I remember out of all those thousands of pages we filled up.

bahahaha ...mcparadigster doesn't grade on a curve...he grades on a knife