Red Mosquito

Collider have a piece up about what’s has changed doe to the time thing.

I’m not linking to that shithole but feel feee to look it up.

dimejinky99 wrote:If you were on a plane and got dusted do you reappear at 35,000 feet and fall to your death?

If so presumably thousands of people fell from the sky at that moment

Maybe Hulk wished everyone to reappear in a safe manner. The stones can do anything.
I hope the Avengers alerted the rest of the world that they were attempting this otherwise millions of people would be in for a shock.

doone wrote: I hope the Avengers alerted the rest of the world that they were attempting this otherwise millions of people would be in for a shock.

doone wrote:

dimejinky99 wrote:If you were on a plane and got dusted do you reappear at 35,000 feet and fall to your death?

If so presumably thousands of people fell from the sky at that moment

Maybe Hulk wished everyone to reappear in a safe manner. The stones can do anything.
I hope the Avengers alerted the rest of the world that they were attempting this otherwise millions of people would be in for a shock.

Goes back to much question.

Millions of people would have moved on with their lives and found new loves.

Then their dead ex turns up at the door, Quite alive.

doone wrote:

dimejinky99 wrote:If you were on a plane and got dusted do you reappear at 35,000 feet and fall to your death?

If so presumably thousands of people fell from the sky at that moment

Maybe Hulk wished everyone to reappear in a safe manner. The stones can do anything.
I hope the Avengers alerted the rest of the world that they were attempting this otherwise millions of people would be in for a shock.

Except bring the dead back. Hulk even says, "I tried, I really did, but I couldn't bring her back."

Also animals, think about that. Fluffy was dusted five years ago and suddenly she's back but now you have another dog, a rescue dog named Kevin, and things are weird.

As for the time travel: The explanation from Hulk was confusing because he said it so fast but iirc it's something like when you travel to the past that's your future because it's on your timeline so for them Thanos has always performed the snap. I'm good with the explanation at that point. It's the one where Thanos - and his entire gigantic-ass spaceship - pop through that gate that confuses me. Also Nebula killing her old self...kind of makes Timecop look like it knew what it was talking about.

Anders wrote:But if it never happened at all, then shouldn’t time change?

Guess it all depends on which fictional story/movie/tv shows rules of time travel youre going to follow. This movie appeared to just make it up as they went as they had too much going on to worry about the nuances of fictional time travel?

It is a great question. If Thanos from 2014, travels to 2023 to stop the Avengers from undoing what Thanos of 2018 did, and dies in the process, Thanos from 2014 would never have been able to do the finger snap in 2018.

The 90's X-men animated series has some great episodes with Cable and Bishop and time travel. In one, Bishop goes back from his time stream to stop a plague from spreading. This causes the time line to readjust all but erasing Cables as hes fighting Apocalypse. So Cable, before he gets dusted jumps back in time. Cable, helps Apocalypse cause the plague, but has Wolverine get infected. His healing factor kicks the plagues ass saving humanity and mutant kind from the plague. Cable returns to his future and its all back to normal. Bishop however, returns to find things even more messed up... so goes time travel.


I really feel like Kahn the Conqueror has to be the next phases build up. The way this movie was toying with time travel and realities. It should also be a good way to introduce Cable/Deadpool and X-Force ahead of the Mutants.

I know its not going to happen but for whatever reason the idea of the x men being in avengers movies doesnt suit for me.

VinylGuy wrote:I know its not going to happen but for whatever reason the idea of the x men being in avengers movies doesnt suit for me.

Same. X men really doesn’t come flosexand would water it all down if they were included.

Cool spoiler free interview with the Russo brothers at empire magazine pod
All about the making of

https://itunes.apple.com/WebObjects/MZS ... 0436591827

I read Dark Phoenix as a kid in the 80s, and it was the greatest thing I had ever read, the only thing that could compete with Star Wars. I still feel the same way.

MadTIGERmaN wrote:

Anders wrote:But if it never happened at all, then shouldn’t time change?

Guess it all depends on which fictional story/movie/tv shows rules of time travel youre going to follow. This movie appeared to just make it up as they went as they had too much going on to worry about the nuances of fictional time travel?

It is a great question. If Thanos from 2014, travels to 2023 to stop the Avengers from undoing what Thanos of 2018 did, and dies in the process, Thanos from 2014 would never have been able to do the finger snap in 2018.

The 90's X-men animated series has some great episodes with Cable and Bishop and time travel. In one, Bishop goes back from his time stream to stop a plague from spreading. This causes the time line to readjust all but erasing Cables as hes fighting Apocalypse. So Cable, before he gets dusted jumps back in time. Cable, helps Apocalypse cause the plague, but has Wolverine get infected. His healing factor kicks the plagues ass saving humanity and mutant kind from the plague. Cable returns to his future and its all back to normal. Bishop however, returns to find things even more messed up... so goes time travel.


I really feel like Kahn the Conqueror has to be the next phases build up. The way this movie was toying with time travel and realities. It should also be a good way to introduce Cable/Deadpool and X-Force ahead of the Mutants.

They definitely created an alternative universe where Thanos wasn't around to snap, but their universe is already set. Of course, according to these rules, I'm not sure Cap would have been able to go back, live his life in the past, and then show up at the lake. He should have been in an alternative timeline/universe.

B wrote:

MadTIGERmaN wrote:

Anders wrote:But if it never happened at all, then shouldn’t time change?

Guess it all depends on which fictional story/movie/tv shows rules of time travel youre going to follow. This movie appeared to just make it up as they went as they had too much going on to worry about the nuances of fictional time travel?

It is a great question. If Thanos from 2014, travels to 2023 to stop the Avengers from undoing what Thanos of 2018 did, and dies in the process, Thanos from 2014 would never have been able to do the finger snap in 2018.

The 90's X-men animated series has some great episodes with Cable and Bishop and time travel. In one, Bishop goes back from his time stream to stop a plague from spreading. This causes the time line to readjust all but erasing Cables as hes fighting Apocalypse. So Cable, before he gets dusted jumps back in time. Cable, helps Apocalypse cause the plague, but has Wolverine get infected. His healing factor kicks the plagues ass saving humanity and mutant kind from the plague. Cable returns to his future and its all back to normal. Bishop however, returns to find things even more messed up... so goes time travel.


I really feel like Kahn the Conqueror has to be the next phases build up. The way this movie was toying with time travel and realities. It should also be a good way to introduce Cable/Deadpool and X-Force ahead of the Mutants.

They definitely created an alternative universe where Thanos wasn't around to snap, but their universe is already set. Of course, according to these rules, I'm not sure Cap would have been able to go back, live his life in the past, and then show up at the lake. He should have been in an alternative timeline/universe.

What if there is only one timeline?

B wrote:

MadTIGERmaN wrote:

Anders wrote:But if it never happened at all, then shouldn’t time change?

Guess it all depends on which fictional story/movie/tv shows rules of time travel youre going to follow. This movie appeared to just make it up as they went as they had too much going on to worry about the nuances of fictional time travel?

It is a great question. If Thanos from 2014, travels to 2023 to stop the Avengers from undoing what Thanos of 2018 did, and dies in the process, Thanos from 2014 would never have been able to do the finger snap in 2018.

The 90's X-men animated series has some great episodes with Cable and Bishop and time travel. In one, Bishop goes back from his time stream to stop a plague from spreading. This causes the time line to readjust all but erasing Cables as hes fighting Apocalypse. So Cable, before he gets dusted jumps back in time. Cable, helps Apocalypse cause the plague, but has Wolverine get infected. His healing factor kicks the plagues ass saving humanity and mutant kind from the plague. Cable returns to his future and its all back to normal. Bishop however, returns to find things even more messed up... so goes time travel.


I really feel like Kahn the Conqueror has to be the next phases build up. The way this movie was toying with time travel and realities. It should also be a good way to introduce Cable/Deadpool and X-Force ahead of the Mutants.

They definitely created an alternative universe where Thanos wasn't around to snap, but their universe is already set. Of course, according to these rules, I'm not sure Cap would have been able to go back, live his life in the past, and then show up at the lake. He should have been in an alternative timeline/universe.

He probably did. Then towards the end of that life, he hit his thingamabob and came back to the original timeline.

Anders wrote:

B wrote:

MadTIGERmaN wrote:

Anders wrote:But if it never happened at all, then shouldn’t time change?

Guess it all depends on which fictional story/movie/tv shows rules of time travel youre going to follow. This movie appeared to just make it up as they went as they had too much going on to worry about the nuances of fictional time travel?

It is a great question. If Thanos from 2014, travels to 2023 to stop the Avengers from undoing what Thanos of 2018 did, and dies in the process, Thanos from 2014 would never have been able to do the finger snap in 2018.

The 90's X-men animated series has some great episodes with Cable and Bishop and time travel. In one, Bishop goes back from his time stream to stop a plague from spreading. This causes the time line to readjust all but erasing Cables as hes fighting Apocalypse. So Cable, before he gets dusted jumps back in time. Cable, helps Apocalypse cause the plague, but has Wolverine get infected. His healing factor kicks the plagues ass saving humanity and mutant kind from the plague. Cable returns to his future and its all back to normal. Bishop however, returns to find things even more messed up... so goes time travel.


I really feel like Kahn the Conqueror has to be the next phases build up. The way this movie was toying with time travel and realities. It should also be a good way to introduce Cable/Deadpool and X-Force ahead of the Mutants.

They definitely created an alternative universe where Thanos wasn't around to snap, but their universe is already set. Of course, according to these rules, I'm not sure Cap would have been able to go back, live his life in the past, and then show up at the lake. He should have been in an alternative timeline/universe.

What if there is only one timeline?

There’s definitely more than one. 2014 Thanos and Nebula being dead confirms that.

If you paid attention to the hulk and sorceress supreme scene then you’d know that changing that taking a stone away would create an alternate timeline. But if the stones once used are put back at the time they are taken (didn’t say it had to be the exact place they were taken from) time would heal itself and be restored in one linear direction instead of splintered

Peeps wrote:If you paid attention to the hulk and sorceress supreme scene then you’d know that changing that taking a stone away would create an alternate timeline. But if the stones once used are put back at the time they are taken (didn’t say it had to be the exact place they were taken from) time would heal itself and be restored in one linear direction instead of splintered

Ah yes, the ripple effect Beast talked about in Days of Future Past.

dimejinky99 wrote:

VinylGuy wrote:I know its not going to happen but for whatever reason the idea of the x men being in avengers movies doesnt suit for me.

Same. X men really doesn’t come flosexand would water it all down if they were included.

The funny part, is a lot of us X-men fans, dont want to see the X-men included in the MCU, because we believe Marvel is most likely going to treat them like the B-team.

I do look forward to the day when Onslaught kills the MCU

Peeps wrote:If you paid attention to the hulk and sorceress supreme scene then you’d know that changing that taking a stone away would create an alternate timeline. But if the stones once used are put back at the time they are taken (didn’t say it had to be the exact place they were taken from) time would heal itself and be restored in one linear direction instead of splintered

But with the Thanos of the past being dead, that created a branch off from the original timeline. Yes, the original stayed the same, but an alternate timeline was created

They explicitly explained the concept of branching-off separate timelines more than once, guys, wtf

1.2 billion


dayum. this movie definitely drew in more than just comic fans

Peeps wrote:1.2 billion


dayum. this movie definitely drew in more than just comic fans

no the comic book fans just saw it three times or more each