Red Mosquito

Oh wow we're almost on the next page.

Let's keep trying

The Argonaut wrote:

Mickey wrote:If only there was a way to accommodate the fact that this is a small board with few active members. Ah well nevertheless.

The three ballots rule accommodates exactly that. Do the math Mickey

You're welcome to hide behind the abstract concept of "math" to hide your arbitrary preferences all you like, but you shan't convince me

Mickey wrote:

Anders wrote:No love for The Shins on RM?

Thankfully no.

Too bad. I think they are great.

Mickey wrote:

The Argonaut wrote:

Mickey wrote:If only there was a way to accommodate the fact that this is a small board with few active members. Ah well nevertheless.

The three ballots rule accommodates exactly that. Do the math Mickey

You're welcome to hide behind the abstract concept of "math" to hide your arbitrary preferences all you like, but you shan't convince me

Do the math on how much I care!

The Argonaut wrote:

Mickey wrote:

The Argonaut wrote:

Mickey wrote:If only there was a way to accommodate the fact that this is a small board with few active members. Ah well nevertheless.

The three ballots rule accommodates exactly that. Do the math Mickey

You're welcome to hide behind the abstract concept of "math" to hide your arbitrary preferences all you like, but you shan't convince me

Do the math on how much I care!

So would that be counting how many times you've responded to this critique rather than ignoring it?

Anders wrote:

Mickey wrote:

Anders wrote:No love for The Shins on RM?

Thankfully no.

Too bad. I think they are great.

Convince two friends, otherwise they don't exist.

It equals the number of times it has been brought up. Y'all are obsessed

release the vote counts for each band, argo

Going to be very interesting if some of the also-rans had higher point totals but didn't clear the completely whimsical three-list threshold.

Mickey wrote:Going to be very interesting if some of the also-rans had higher point totals but didn't clear the completely whimsical three-list threshold.

was pearl jam on your list

The three vote rule is my crowning achievement, put it on my gravestone

The Argonaut wrote:The three vote rule is my crowning achievement, put it on my gravestone

"Librarian, stick collector, suppressed the will of the people"

hope charli xcx wins

Simple Torture wrote:We should recommend albums from artists in our personal Top 10 that didn't make the final list

Destroyer - Rubies.
I don't think any album so perfectly captures the sort of fin-de-siecle decadence and cultural exhaustion of the early 2000s like this one.

Deafheaven - New Bermuda
I experience a form of ego death about four minutes into the second track.

Mount Eerie - Lost Voices.
Hard choice between this and The Glow Pt. 2 but this sparse little album is one of the most beautiful bits of songwriting I've ever heard.

Sun Kil Moon - Ghosts of the Great Highway
Koz is a piece of shit but the epic scope of this album is really something else.

The Knife - Silent Shout
I don't have a write-up. It's good.

Mickey wrote:Going to be very interesting if some of the also-rans had higher point totals but didn't clear the completely whimsical three-list threshold.

Agreed.

spike wrote:release the vote counts for each band, argo

This thread is really flirtin' with disaster.

chewm wrote:hope charli xcx wins

BurtReynolds wrote:This thread is really flirtin' with disaster.

I bet that turns you on