Red Mosquito

theplatypus wrote:So wait, on balance, what is RM's opinion of the finale?

Just respond to this post with the word "Good" or "Bad". DON'T GET INTO DETAILS

Good, but...

Chris_H_2 wrote:

washing machine wrote:My wife just relayed to me that Robin Arryn was the young lord on that electoral council that I didn't recognize last night. That kind of blew my mind.

i thought the part of that scene where they continued to play on ridiculing edmure was a little too kitschy for my tastes.

Yes.

darth_vedder wrote:

EJ wrote:I think I was mostly disppointed that Varys' "reveal" notes never became part of the finale's drama.

Yeah, I kept wondering if any of those made it out. Also was curious why Jon's lineage wasn't brought up with the electoral college.

Because, like a great many, many, many threads of this epic story... those things ultimately didn't matter. And that's part of what I'm thinking about/struggling with regarding this show and how it ended.

durdencommatyler wrote:

darth_vedder wrote:

EJ wrote:I think I was mostly disppointed that Varys' "reveal" notes never became part of the finale's drama.

Yeah, I kept wondering if any of those made it out. Also was curious why Jon's lineage wasn't brought up with the electoral college.

Because, like a great many, many, many threads of this epic story... those things ultimately didn't matter. And that's part of what I'm thinking about/struggling with regarding this show and how it ended.

Same. Feels like a lot of the build up with the NK, with R+L=J, etc... didn't matter.

Simple Torture wrote:

theplatypus wrote:So wait, on balance, what is RM's opinion of the finale?

Just respond to this post with the word "Good" or "Bad". DON'T GET INTO DETAILS

Some good, some bad.

You have to pick one

ok, so i just read who was all there. here's the list of knowns and unknowns:

-bran
-sansa
-arya
-brienne
-davos
-gendry
-edmure tully
-sam tarly
-man with no sigils between edmure and sam (perhaps howland reed)
-yara
-unknown northern lord to the left of yara
-unnamed dornish prince to the right of yara
-unnamed man to the right of gendry
-robin arryn
-yohn royce
-unnamed man to the right of yohn royce (could be from the reach)

washing machine wrote:My wife just relayed to me that Robin Arryn was the young lord on that electoral council that I didn't recognize last night. That kind of blew my mind.

When you drink breast milk until you are 12, you go through some weird growth spurts.

Boring episode. Worst of the season.

darth_vedder wrote:

durdencommatyler wrote:

darth_vedder wrote:

EJ wrote:I think I was mostly disppointed that Varys' "reveal" notes never became part of the finale's drama.

Yeah, I kept wondering if any of those made it out. Also was curious why Jon's lineage wasn't brought up with the electoral college.

Because, like a great many, many, many threads of this epic story... those things ultimately didn't matter. And that's part of what I'm thinking about/struggling with regarding this show and how it ended.

Same. Feels like a lot of the build up with the NK, with R+L=J, etc... didn't matter.

It does feel that way. Honestly, I'm having a hard time working through what the point was in bringing Jon back from the dead in the first place.

I was really hoping Arya would hand out some punishment. Instead the Unsullied and the Dothraki got to keep on doing whatever they wanted.

durdencommatyler wrote:

darth_vedder wrote:

durdencommatyler wrote:

darth_vedder wrote:

EJ wrote:I think I was mostly disppointed that Varys' "reveal" notes never became part of the finale's drama.

Yeah, I kept wondering if any of those made it out. Also was curious why Jon's lineage wasn't brought up with the electoral college.

Because, like a great many, many, many threads of this epic story... those things ultimately didn't matter. And that's part of what I'm thinking about/struggling with regarding this show and how it ended.

Same. Feels like a lot of the build up with the NK, with R+L=J, etc... didn't matter.

It does feel that way. Honestly, I'm having a hard time working through what the point was in bringing Jon back from the dead in the first place.

again, i think you can attribute 90% of this nonsense to the showrunners' bizarre choice to abbreviate the last two seasons.

i just don't understand why you'd put so many countless resources and time into something where you meticulously pour your heart and soul into it, only to have your give-a-shitter break at the end which colors everything you accomplished up until that point.

durdencommatyler wrote:

darth_vedder wrote:

durdencommatyler wrote:

darth_vedder wrote:

EJ wrote:I think I was mostly disppointed that Varys' "reveal" notes never became part of the finale's drama.

Yeah, I kept wondering if any of those made it out. Also was curious why Jon's lineage wasn't brought up with the electoral college.

Because, like a great many, many, many threads of this epic story... those things ultimately didn't matter. And that's part of what I'm thinking about/struggling with regarding this show and how it ended.

Same. Feels like a lot of the build up with the NK, with R+L=J, etc... didn't matter.

It does feel that way. Honestly, I'm having a hard time working through what the point was in bringing Jon back from the dead in the first place.

Totally.

Here are a few more questions I have...

1. We just spent time learning how the unsullied aren't taking prisoners, but then when Jon kills their leader, THAT'S when they decide to take a prisoner? Why not execute him on the spot?
2. Why did Varys, Tyrion, Davos, the North, etc.. support Jon UNTIL he stabbed Dany? Literally everyone was begging him to take the throne, and then they all were like, "ugh, I don't know who to choose...." when it came time to pick the next ruler.
3. Why didn't Drogon torch Jon? The throne didn't stab his mom.
4. Why didn't Dany have any guards around her?
5. Why would ANYONE want Bran to be king, after being totally unhelpful and uncaring toward everyone around him the past 3 or 4 seasons?
6. Why did Bran WANT to be king at all, after having lost all interest in the world around him?
7. What happened to the Dothraki? Did they just pack up and leave, off screen?
8. Why would Yara Greyjoy have more loyalty to the queen instead of the house (Stark) her brother died defending?
9. Does Jon killing Dany fulfills the Azor Azahi prophecy?

I never watched a single minute of this show.

Chris_H_2 wrote:

durdencommatyler wrote:

darth_vedder wrote:

durdencommatyler wrote:

darth_vedder wrote:

EJ wrote:I think I was mostly disppointed that Varys' "reveal" notes never became part of the finale's drama.

Yeah, I kept wondering if any of those made it out. Also was curious why Jon's lineage wasn't brought up with the electoral college.

Because, like a great many, many, many threads of this epic story... those things ultimately didn't matter. And that's part of what I'm thinking about/struggling with regarding this show and how it ended.

Same. Feels like a lot of the build up with the NK, with R+L=J, etc... didn't matter.

It does feel that way. Honestly, I'm having a hard time working through what the point was in bringing Jon back from the dead in the first place.

again, i think you can attribute 90% of this nonsense to the showrunners' bizarre choice to abbreviate the last two seasons.

i just don't understand why you'd put so many countless resources and time into something where you meticulously pour your heart and soul into it, only to have your give-a-shitter break at the end which colors everything you accomplished up until that point.

Exactly. This is why I'm really starting to believe those "whispers" out there that this is all Star Wars' fault.

Spoiler: show

I'm only half kidding

PHATJ wrote:I never watched a single minute of this show.

Bran wins.

Chris_H_2 wrote: again, i think you can attribute 90% of this nonsense to the showrunners' bizarre choice to abbreviate the last two seasons.

i just don't understand why you'd put so many countless resources and time into something where you meticulously pour your heart and soul into it, only to have your give-a-shitter break at the end which colors everything you accomplished up until that point.

Agreed. Season 7 should have been the full 10 episodes ending with Battle of Winterfell. Leave it on a cliffhanger then wrap it up episode 1 Season 8. If they wanted a shorter season fine, but at least we would have gotten like 3 additional episode which would have helped develop and finish all these story lines. It was all just too rushed and it didn't have to be. That and Jon should not have been outcast.

EJ wrote:

PHATJ wrote:I never watched a single minute of this show.

Bran wins.

What?

PHATJ wrote:

EJ wrote:

PHATJ wrote:I never watched a single minute of this show.

Bran wins.

What?

the Iron Wheelchair

durdencommatyler wrote:

darth_vedder wrote:

durdencommatyler wrote:

darth_vedder wrote:

EJ wrote:I think I was mostly disppointed that Varys' "reveal" notes never became part of the finale's drama.

Yeah, I kept wondering if any of those made it out. Also was curious why Jon's lineage wasn't brought up with the electoral college.

Because, like a great many, many, many threads of this epic story... those things ultimately didn't matter. And that's part of what I'm thinking about/struggling with regarding this show and how it ended.

Same. Feels like a lot of the build up with the NK, with R+L=J, etc... didn't matter.

It does feel that way. Honestly, I'm having a hard time working through what the point was in bringing Jon back from the dead in the first place.

Nothing matters because we all die. The end.

So Jon wrote I’d Like to Buy the World a Coke? Huh.