mastaflatch wrote:i think it's only Ed's isolated guitar/vocals from the Wrigley show. definitely not a proper studio recording, not even a demo IMO. still better without the fucking sissy keyboards.
Yea, for sure.
mastaflatch wrote:i think it's only Ed's isolated guitar/vocals from the Wrigley show. definitely not a proper studio recording, not even a demo IMO. still better without the fucking sissy keyboards.
I thought ed sounded too good for it to be live and halfway through a show.Strat wrote:mastaflatch wrote:i think it's only Ed's isolated guitar/vocals from the Wrigley show. definitely not a proper studio recording, not even a demo IMO. still better without the fucking sissy keyboards.
Yea, for sure.
stupidmop wrote:Still cheesy as fuck. I mean its ok but its a straight up gooey love song. Ed sounds nice mostly, cept for the usual pronunciation weirdness.
The studio version is gonna be godawful man, its cheesy with just a dude and a guitar, add the piano and who knows what the fuck else and well....
I thought ed sounded too good for it to be live and halfway througha show.Strat wrote:mastaflatch wrote:i think it's only Ed's isolated guitar/vocals from the Wrigley show. definitely not a proper studio recording, not even a demo IMO. still better without the fucking sissy keyboards.
Yea, for sure.
Oh god.....me too, pretty please.Buby wrote:I want it... PM please.
stupidmop wrote:Still cheesy as fuck. I mean its ok but its a straight up gooey love song. Ed sounds nice mostly, cept for the usual pronunciation weirdness.
The studio version is gonna be godawful man, its cheesy with just a dude and a guitar, add the piano and who knows what the fuck else and well....
I thought ed sounded too good for it to be live and halfway through a show.Strat wrote:mastaflatch wrote:i think it's only Ed's isolated guitar/vocals from the Wrigley show. definitely not a proper studio recording, not even a demo IMO. still better without the fucking sissy keyboards.
Yea, for sure.
RisingTides wrote:There is more kindness on the internet than we would care to admit to ourselves. Sometimes we are so afraid of falling victim to a ruse, we miss out on actual opportunities.
RisingTides wrote:There is more kindness on the internet than we would care to admit to ourselves. Sometimes we are so afraid of falling victim to a ruse, we miss out on actual opportunities.
PM sentharmless wrote:It's pretty nice, but a patchy performance. I'm not dreading the studio version anyway since the arrangement doesn't sound too bad (real piano apparently).
Forums are being encapsulated.everything wrote:"i hate this song" "that song blows" "this song sucks!" [time elapses] [isolated track surfaces] "oh my god, can i have it?" "PM me please!" "I wanna hear it!"
silly stuff. also, oh my god, can i have it? PM me please. I wanna hear it!
Strat wrote:Alas, we are RM
Well we wanna see if it's better than the first version we heard... seems pretty simple to me.everything wrote:"i hate this song" "that song blows" "this song sucks!" [time elapses] [isolated track surfaces] "oh my god, can i have it?" "PM me please!" "I wanna hear it!"
silly stuff. also, oh my god, can i have it? PM me please. I wanna hear it!
I'm a sucker for sparse acoustic tracks, so even if i liked this song i'd probably end up prefering the demo (or whatever this is). But i don't see how more bells and whistles will help it any. Specially in the form of that piano.HardTI wrote:stupidmop wrote:Still cheesy as fuck. I mean its ok but its a straight up gooey love song. Ed sounds nice mostly, cept for the usual pronunciation weirdness.
The studio version is gonna be godawful man, its cheesy with just a dude and a guitar, add the piano and who knows what the fuck else and well....
I thought ed sounded too good for it to be live and halfway through a show.Strat wrote:mastaflatch wrote:i think it's only Ed's isolated guitar/vocals from the Wrigley show. definitely not a proper studio recording, not even a demo IMO. still better without the fucking sissy keyboards.
Yea, for sure.
I think the studio is the only way to save this song.
RisingTides wrote:There is more kindness on the internet than we would care to admit to ourselves. Sometimes we are so afraid of falling victim to a ruse, we miss out on actual opportunities.
I don't think it'll be that piano, though. I think it's a real one, according to a review we've had.stupidmop wrote:I'm a sucker for sparse acoustic tracks, so even if i liked this song i'd probably end up prefering the demo (or whatever this is). But i don't see how more bells and whistles will help it any. Specially in the form of that piano.HardTI wrote:stupidmop wrote:Still cheesy as fuck. I mean its ok but its a straight up gooey love song. Ed sounds nice mostly, cept for the usual pronunciation weirdness.
The studio version is gonna be godawful man, its cheesy with just a dude and a guitar, add the piano and who knows what the fuck else and well....
I thought ed sounded too good for it to be live and halfway through a show.Strat wrote:mastaflatch wrote:i think it's only Ed's isolated guitar/vocals from the Wrigley show. definitely not a proper studio recording, not even a demo IMO. still better without the fucking sissy keyboards.
Yea, for sure.
I think the studio is the only way to save this song.
I'm not shitting on the song btw, i can see why people would like it, just ain't my thang.
RisingTides wrote:There is more kindness on the internet than we would care to admit to ourselves. Sometimes we are so afraid of falling victim to a ruse, we miss out on actual opportunities.