Re: Superblood Wolfmoon
Posted: Tue February 18, 2020 8:32 pm
tree you're a weird dude. I don't like the song either, but I'm not trying to convince everyone else they shouldn't like it.
And considering Who Ever Said is going to be a top-20 song, Gigaton is actually off to a tremendous start.Jaeti wrote:First listen letting SBWF roll into DOTC. I'll buy.
Big fan of the melodies here.PHATJ wrote:These songs are delicious
Maybe he should meditate moreE.H. Ruddock wrote:tree you're a weird dude. I don't like the song either, but I'm not trying to convince everyone else they shouldn't like it.
I'm not trying to convince anyone. Just talking about why I don't like it. Sharing my opinion, just like everyone else. I'm really not upset, Strat, I promise. But when people like Stip mock me and misrepresent my opinions, I have every right to defend myself and my views.E.H. Ruddock wrote:tree you're a weird dude. I don't like the song either, but I'm not trying to convince everyone else they shouldn't like it.
No and I was definitely ready for it to do that.Superblood Wolfmoon wrote:Does it sound good to you? Did it put a smile on your face when it kicked in?
It absolutely is a great song. It’s a stunner, and I am stunned.Homeboyd wrote:Listening to SBWM and then DotC back to back my main conclusion is that wow, DotC might just be a great song...
can it not be AC/DC pleaseRAG319 wrote:Time to find a new band. We need a band to unite us, not divide us.
Shucks. Was hoping you'd come around to it. For no particular reason other than its been good to see you excited about pearl jam!Birds in Hell wrote:No and I was definitely ready for it to do that.Superblood Wolfmoon wrote:Does it sound good to you? Did it put a smile on your face when it kicked in?
As I would hope everyone on the board knows, I am often a cheerleader for the band's weirder Matt Cameron-era rockers. I'm a big fan of Evacuation, Cropduster, Big Wave, Johnny Guitar, My Father's Son, Olé, etc.
I wish I felt the same way about this song. It's not the vocals I have an issue with, it's the song structure, melody and chord choices. It's a bafflingly strange song and not in a "pleasantly weird" way. It feels badly-written, badly-constructed and subsequent listens haven't revealed any hidden depths.
me tooStrat wrote:Shucks. Was hoping you'd come around to it. For no particular reason other than its been good to see you excited about pearl jam!Birds in Hell wrote:No and I was definitely ready for it to do that.Superblood Wolfmoon wrote:Does it sound good to you? Did it put a smile on your face when it kicked in?
As I would hope everyone on the board knows, I am often a cheerleader for the band's weirder Matt Cameron-era rockers. I'm a big fan of Evacuation, Cropduster, Big Wave, Johnny Guitar, My Father's Son, Olé, etc.
I wish I felt the same way about this song. It's not the vocals I have an issue with, it's the song structure, melody and chord choices. It's a bafflingly strange song and not in a "pleasantly weird" way. It feels badly-written, badly-constructed and subsequent listens haven't revealed any hidden depths.
For me, it is definitely "pleasantly weird" and Ed feels excited and committed.