Page 1 of 2

You Didn't Have To Kill Them All | The Twilight Sad thread

Posted: Wed July 11, 2018 10:53 pm
by run2death
One of the best and most consistent bands of the last 10 years.















New single via Rock Action.


Re: You Didn't Have To Kill Them All | The Twilight Sad thre

Posted: Thu July 12, 2018 4:12 am
by Higgs
I've recently snagged a few of their albums with the intention of diving in. I'll check out these vids as a starter methinks.

Generally speaking I'm a big fan of Scottish bands.

Re: You Didn't Have To Kill Them All | The Twilight Sad thre

Posted: Mon November 19, 2018 7:33 pm
by run2death
New album It Won/t Be Like This All the Time coming Jan. 18 on Rock Action Records.

New single.

Re: You Didn't Have To Kill Them All | The Twilight Sad thre

Posted: Tue January 15, 2019 5:33 pm
by run2death
New album on Friday!

Re: You Didn't Have To Kill Them All | The Twilight Sad thre

Posted: Thu January 17, 2019 3:57 pm
by run2death
Rank 'em!

1. Fourteen Autumns & Fifteen Winters
2. Nobody Wants to Be Here and Nobody Wants to Leave
3. Forget the Night Ahead
4. No One Can Ever Know

If Killed My Parents and Hit the Road counts as a proper album, it'd be #3.

Re: You Didn't Have To Kill Them All | The Twilight Sad thre

Posted: Fri January 18, 2019 2:41 pm
by run2death
Clearly Scott Hutchison's death had a huge influence on It Won't Be Like This All the Time.

Probably their best album yet.

Re: You Didn't Have To Kill Them All | The Twilight Sad thre

Posted: Fri January 18, 2019 3:31 pm
by Stardog Champion
run2death wrote:Clearly Scott Hutchison's death had a huge influence on It Won't Be Like This All the Time.

Probably their best album yet.
Should that album be my starting point with them then?

I saw them a few years ago when they opened for The Cure. I liked what I heard that night, but I got very lazy with following up on it.

Re: You Didn't Have To Kill Them All | The Twilight Sad thre

Posted: Fri January 18, 2019 3:53 pm
by run2death
Stardog Champion wrote:
run2death wrote:Clearly Scott Hutchison's death had a huge influence on It Won't Be Like This All the Time.

Probably their best album yet.
Should that album be my starting point with them then?

I saw them a few years ago when they opened for The Cure. I liked what I heard that night, but I got very lazy with following up on it.

I'd probably start with Nobody Wants to Be Here and Nobody Wants to Leave.

It's got their best melodies and James Graham's vocals are really spot-on.

Re: You Didn't Have To Kill Them All | The Twilight Sad thre

Posted: Fri January 18, 2019 6:56 pm
by Stardog Champion
run2death wrote:
Stardog Champion wrote:
run2death wrote:Clearly Scott Hutchison's death had a huge influence on It Won't Be Like This All the Time.

Probably their best album yet.
Should that album be my starting point with them then?

I saw them a few years ago when they opened for The Cure. I liked what I heard that night, but I got very lazy with following up on it.

I'd probably start with Nobody Wants to Be Here and Nobody Wants to Leave.

It's got their best melodies and James Graham's vocals are really spot-on.
Thanks for the recommendation. I swear I'm actually going to give this band some time this year.

Re: You Didn't Have To Kill Them All | The Twilight Sad thre

Posted: Fri January 18, 2019 8:58 pm
by psychobain
Great band, so underrated.
Cant wait to spin the new one.

That voice...

Re: You Didn't Have To Kill Them All | The Twilight Sad thre

Posted: Sat January 19, 2019 1:03 am
by run2death
Stardog Champion wrote:
run2death wrote:
Stardog Champion wrote:
run2death wrote:Clearly Scott Hutchison's death had a huge influence on It Won't Be Like This All the Time.

Probably their best album yet.
Should that album be my starting point with them then?

I saw them a few years ago when they opened for The Cure. I liked what I heard that night, but I got very lazy with following up on it.

I'd probably start with Nobody Wants to Be Here and Nobody Wants to Leave.

It's got their best melodies and James Graham's vocals are really spot-on.
Thanks for the recommendation. I swear I'm actually going to give this band some time this year.
You really should, they're great.

Re: You Didn't Have To Kill Them All | The Twilight Sad thre

Posted: Sat January 19, 2019 2:23 pm
by psychobain
run2death wrote:Clearly Scott Hutchison's death had a huge influence on It Won't Be Like This All the Time.
.
What about Robert Smith?
The Arbor is pure THE CURE
Sounds like something from the Pornography era

Re: You Didn't Have To Kill Them All | The Twilight Sad thre

Posted: Sat January 19, 2019 2:34 pm
by run2death
psychobain wrote:
run2death wrote:Clearly Scott Hutchison's death had a huge influence on It Won't Be Like This All the Time.
.
What about Robert Smith?
The Arbor is pure THE CURE
Sounds like something from the Pornography era
For sure. Some of The Top and Japanese Whispers in there too. It's even got those weird "echoey" drums and that bassline is pure Cure.

Hutchinson's influence is more in the lyrics.

Re: You Didn't Have To Kill Them All | The Twilight Sad thre

Posted: Sat January 19, 2019 6:25 pm
by psychobain
This album is so good.
Im a huge fan of this band;

Re: You Didn't Have To Kill Them All | The Twilight Sad thre

Posted: Sat January 19, 2019 8:39 pm
by run2death
psychobain wrote:This album is so good.
Im a huge fan of this band;
What are your favorite tracks from the new one?

Re: You Didn't Have To Kill Them All | The Twilight Sad thre

Posted: Mon January 21, 2019 2:33 pm
by run2death
The 4-track run of The Arbor, VTr, Sunday Day13 and I/m Not Here [missing face] is fucking awesome.

Re: You Didn't Have To Kill Them All | The Twilight Sad thre

Posted: Mon January 21, 2019 4:56 pm
by dimejinky99
Two good pals been at me for a long time to get into this band and I somehow haven’t.

The new one has a frightened rabbit influence?

Im gonna check them out.

Re: You Didn't Have To Kill Them All | The Twilight Sad thre

Posted: Mon January 21, 2019 5:12 pm
by run2death
dimejinky99 wrote:The new one has a frightened rabbit influence?
I was referencing the lyrics earlier, not necessarily the sound.

Re: You Didn't Have To Kill Them All | The Twilight Sad thre

Posted: Mon January 21, 2019 6:28 pm
by dimejinky99
That’s still enough to get me on board.

I’m horribly closed off to new music anyways so no harm in giving them a spin.

Re: You Didn't Have To Kill Them All | The Twilight Sad thre

Posted: Thu January 24, 2019 2:51 am
by Stardog Champion
run2death wrote:
Stardog Champion wrote:
run2death wrote:
Stardog Champion wrote:
run2death wrote:Clearly Scott Hutchison's death had a huge influence on It Won't Be Like This All the Time.

Probably their best album yet.
Should that album be my starting point with them then?

I saw them a few years ago when they opened for The Cure. I liked what I heard that night, but I got very lazy with following up on it.

I'd probably start with Nobody Wants to Be Here and Nobody Wants to Leave.

It's got their best melodies and James Graham's vocals are really spot-on.
Thanks for the recommendation. I swear I'm actually going to give this band some time this year.
You really should, they're great.
I've finally started to give this album a few listens. I love the opening. "There's a Girl in the Corner" and "Last January" stood out for me right away. Other tracks are starting to really grow on me. The back half of "In Nowheres" in particular has helped me come around on that track. I love the way it builds from (roughly) the minute before (2:30 mark or so) the nightmares part kicks in.