Red Mosquito

vs.

This is a big one. It would have been a worthy final

I had to listen to both to be sure; ultimately Basket Case is probably the signature song of this genre of music in my mind. It was my first real introduction to pop/punk and I freaking loved that album as a 14 year old. I loved Smash too, and this was close, but I just can’t get around the impact Basket Case had not only on me, but much more importantly music in general at the time.

Pretty sure there was a stretch in 94 where i my just flipped between Dookie and Smash in my walkman.

I have to say its criminal how much Offspring is left in the top 8

if osspring had a different singer i'd maybe like them

just don't like the singer

basket case is alright

I have to vote The Offspring for the better riff here

Welcome to Paradise would have really annihilated the finals in place of Basket Case

Wow, can't believe Basket Case might lose. SOMEBODY SWITCH THEIR VOTE

Nooooooo