Red Mosquito

Here are the results. We are mid-countdown:

87. Leonard Cohen
86. Tori Amos
85. PJ Harvey
84. Phoebe Bridgers
83. Arcade Fire
82. Porcupine Tree
81. Florence + the Machine
80. Taylor Swift
79. Fleetwood Mac
78. Sam Cooke
77. Otis Redding
76. Van Halen
75. Nick Drake
74. The Strokes
73. Laura Marling
72. Daft Punk
71. Björk
70. Deftones
69. Ryan Adams
68. Bill Callahan/Smog
67. Grimes
66. Yo La Tengo
65. The War on Drugs
64. Sonic Youth
63. Steely Dan
62. Faith No More
61. Pixies
60. My Bloody Valentine
59. The Doors
58. Silver Jews
57. The Cure
56. Elvis Costello
55. Godspeed You! Black Emperor
54. Fleet Foxes
53. John Coltrane
52. Broken Social Scene
51. Bon Iver
50. Dinosaur Jr.
49. Johnny Cash
48. Modest Mouse
47. Fugazi
46. Fiona Apple
45. Iron Maiden
44. Mogwai
43. Rage Against the Machine
42. Wilco
41. Kate Bush
40. Elliott Smith
39. U2
38. Wu-Tang Clan
37. Beck
36. My Morning Jacket
35. Pavement
34. The Replacements
33. Jack White/The White Stripes
32. The Clash
31. Stevie Wonder
30. Nine Inch Nails
29. Prince
28. Grateful Dead
27. Sleater-Kinney
26. The Smashing Pumpkins
25. Nick Cave/Nick Cave & the Bad Seeds
24. The Rolling Stones
23. The Who
22. Bruce Springsteen/Bruce Springsteen & the E Street Band
21. Sigur Rós
20. Beastie Boys
19. Led Zeppelin
18. Tool
17. Tom Waits
16. David Bowie
15. Talking Heads
14. St. Vincent
13. The National
12. Nirvana
11. Tom Petty/Tom Petty & The Heartbreakers
10. Pink Floyd
9. Queens of the Stone Age
8. R.E.M.
7. The Beatles
6. Alice In Chains
5. Bob Dylan
4. Neil Young
3. Soundgarden
2. Radiohead
1. Pearl Jam
http://forums.theskyiscrape.com/viewtop ... 2#p1673232


Let's do this again! We will determine what RM's TOP 100 ARTISTS are. I believe the first and only time we did this was in 2006, so it may be time for an update. RM TOP 100 ARTISTS
~~~Original Rules thread 2006
Original Results thread 2006~~~

Submit a ranked list of your top 20 artists via PM to The Argonaut so we can determine definitively what RM's top 100 artists are. You can submit a shorter list of less than 20 artists if it so pleases you.

mowbs ran the 2006 tournament and he did a very good job, so here is an amended version of his ruleset:

-Including Pearl Jam is allowed. This is a change from the 2006 rules. The band and our opinions of it are very different from what they were in 2006. Will Pearl Jam be the favorite band on a Pearl Jam board? I'm honestly not sure. Let's find out.

-If you'd like to vote for Eric Clapton, for example, then that vote will reflect Clapton as a solo artist. If you want to vote for Blind Faith or The Yardbirds or any other group he has taken part in, then one of your votes will have to be specifically for that band. That being said, you can vote for something like The Beatles and all four members individually, but it will have to occupy 5 different spots on your list. So just keep in mind that both Soundgarden and Audioslave could appear on the countdown if you'd like to vote for both.

-Again, the criteria for your list is entirely up to you. Even if an artist had their first release a month ago, you can still vote for them.

-I'm gonna ask that you rank them. Higher-ranked artists on your lists will earn more points (20 points for #1, 19 points for #2, etc). At the end, I'll share all the info about how many points each artist earned and how many total lists they appeared on. Ranking will be based on tally (total appearances on lists) with points as a tiebreaker followed by highest ranking as a second tiebreaker.

Use this thread to ask questions. You can PM me your list whenever you are ready. Once lists start coming in, I'll set a deadline for when you need to get them in by. I'd ask that you refrain for now from posting your complete list. There'll be time for that after.

Boy that original list is BORING

I'm loving this, Argo. Thanks for reviving it. I'll have my list to you shortly.

I don't listen to enough to be able to compile a list.. I'll just say it right now the only three that come to my mind are Tool, Radiohead, Elliott Smith.. call me boring

I said twenty because that's the number mowbs used when he ran it in 2006. It might be too many?

maybe just let people nominate as many artists as they wish

Yeah, that's cool. That can work. Maximum of 20, though. Take your time with your list, though. No rush, yet.

i feel like this place has gotten much less chaotic and mean and you've contributed a lot to this.. thanks for that

I have my preliminary list, Argo. But I need to sit with it for a bit. Make sure I'm locked into it, y'know?

epilogue wrote:I have my preliminary list, Argo. But I need to sit with it for a bit. Make sure I'm locked into it, y'know?

No rush. Well, Rush is allowed if you're a big fan of Rush. But there is no rush to submit your list, which may or may include Rush. up to you

we should be made to post our list for everyone to see rather than by PM so we can be publicly ridiculed.

Jorge wrote:Boy that original list is BORING

please control yourself

I'm sure I participated in this last time. I wonder what my list was then. I bet it's completely different now.

I’m in solely for the public ridicule.

I'll absolutely post my list here once I send it off to Argo.

Unless that's against the rules or something.

i can't believe weezer made the last list

tree_ wrote:i can't believe weezer made the last list

This was 2006. All we had was five albums: The Blue Album - Make Believe. Not a bad run, that. All of those records are good to great.

Pure Prairie League

Player

Chris_H_2 wrote:we should be made to post our list for everyone to see rather than by PM so we can be publicly ridiculed.

Here's the thread where folks posted their lists back in 2006: http://archive.theskyiscrape.com/viewto ... ?p=1517318

It's not against the rules to post your list, do what you gotta do. You don't have to post it publicly, as that will keep the element of surprise alive.