Red Mosquito

Help Help vs. Someday at Christmas


Help Help is okay (it tries a little too hard for me - it rings just a little false, and it is part of the run of songs where Riot Act starts to lose me, so it's positioning doesn't help). I think it plays much better live.

Someday at Christmas is one of my favorite Xmas single songs. I love everything about it. See my comments from Around and Around, but x10. Vote for Someday

Help Help. Absolutely love the groove on this song.

I really love this Someday cover. But Help Help is my favorite song on Riot Act and so gets my enthusiastic vote.

This is tough; Help Help has vastly improved for me in the years I've continued to live with it, but Someday at Christmas is one of my favorite PJ covers; it really shouldn't work, but it does. I think the songwriting power and its status as an original PJ track push it over the top, but this may be the hardest matchup this round.

This might be the first one where im going totally against the grain but Someday at Christmas for me.