Red Mosquito

Elderly Woman... vs. Army Reserve

Easy vote for Small Town, just a phenomenal performance (one of Eddie's best) of an amazing song. Army Reserve is an interesting idea and a good story that never quite came together for me the way it should have, though the immediate and abrasive production values of S/T aren't doing that song many favors.

I'd much prefer to hear Army Reserve both live and on record.

Army Reserve is tremendous musically, but, yeah, it's never done much for me emotionally. Not that that would matter much in this matchup.

LetMeSleep wrote:I'd much prefer to hear Army Reserve both live and on record.

Ab so lutely

Proud vote for Army Reserve. That last minute is some of the best music they've ever made and still gives me chills. Elderly Woman is a beautiful composition and it is beloved for a reason, but it hasn't given me chills in years.

I'm going with Small Town, though I think the distance between the two is much closer now then it would have been several years ago.

I love the last minute of Army Reserve. Glad to see some ST songs starting to get some appreciation around here.

Army Reserve. Such a cool groove.

Small Town is top tier. It's always in contention for best PJ song.

Love both these songs