Notes:
- * There are no vote tallies for 2004, but 2005 lists the seeds. For this post, I just ignored 2004 rather than populate vote tallies.
* 2018 was a series of survivor mini tournaments before the championship elimination tournament. I just assigned the average vote of each song overall to the results in 2018, though it could probably be fine-tuned to take into account how early they were voted out and what percentage of the elimination vote they received.
* 2006 and 2007 were run through TSIS, and got a LOT more votes. I've separated these out to give the "RM-only" list.
As determined by the results of all March Madness tournaments except 2004, 2006 and 2007
Corduroy has an average of 156 votes per tournament across all its appearances, making 6 finals.
Mind Your Manners has an average of 66 votes per tournament across all its appearances.
1. Corduroy
2. Immortality
3. In My Tree
4. Last Exit
5. Rearviewmirror
6. Hail, Hail
7. Release
8. Black
9. Do The Evolution
10. Go
11. Dance Of The Clairvoyants
12. Insignificance
13. Brain Of J.
14. Faithfull
15. Alive
16. Sad
17. Tremor Christ
18. Porch
19. Long Road
20. Not For You
21. I Got Shit
22. Given To Fly
23. In Hiding
24. Sleight Of Hand
25. Animal
26. Take The Long Way
27. All Those Yesterdays
28. Pendulum
29. State Of Love And Trust
30. Off He Goes
31. Grievance
32. Smile
33. Nothing As It Seems
34. Daughter
35. Indifference
36. Hard To Imagine
37. Severed Hand
38. Parting Ways
39. Comes Then Goes
40. No Way
41. Present Tense
42. Red Mosquito
43. Light Years
44. Life Wasted
45. Rival
46. Yellow Ledbetter
47. Nothingman
48. Elderly Woman Behind The Counter In A Small Town
49. Unthought Known
50. Mind Your Manners
Now, if we add 2006 and 2007 back in
The top 10 looks like this:
Black has an average per-tournament vote tally of 503, which shows how heavily skewed to 2006/2007 these results are.
1. Black
2. Corduroy
3. Release
4. Rearviewmirror
5. Porch
6. Do The Evolution
7. Immortality
8. Alive
9. In My Tree
10. State Of Love And Trust
And rounding out the top 50:
- Spoiler: show
Past 5 tournaments only
Last Exit has amassed an average of 205 votes per tournament, with Hail, Hail managing 175.
1. Last Exit
2. Hail, Hail
3. In My Tree
4. Go
5. Corduroy
6. Brain Of J.
7. Dance Of The Clairvoyants
8. Rearviewmirror
9. Sleight Of Hand
10. Immortality
And the rest of the top 50:
- Spoiler: show
