Red Mosquito

Help Help vs. Immortality

One of the worst, against one of the best.

Vote for Immortality

I love HelpHelp, but I try to vote on pure preference, and Immortality on the right day is my favorite Pearl Jam song.

I haven't listened to Immortality in months. I probably average 1 Help Help listen a week.

Leatherhead wrote:I haven't listened to Immortality in months. I probably average 1 Help Help listen a week.

Same. Immortality holds a hallowed place in my history with this band, but these days I’m teaching for Help Help

Another tough one since I love help help but immortality is top 4

I adore both of these songs...

Going with Help Help for now but I don't know...

Leatherhead wrote:I haven't listened to Immortality in months. I probably average 1 Help Help listen a week.

Wow. I haven’t listened to PJ that regularly in 15 years.

liebzz wrote:I love HelpHelp, but I try to vote on pure preference, and Immortality on the right day is my favorite Pearl Jam song.

I’m not quite that high on Immortality, but I can definitely say on the right day it’s top 5 or 10. And I do love Help Help, but it can’t top that.

Vacate

Immortality quite easily.

For sure on my overall rankings Immortality is higher. It's the better song. It deserves to win. But I think Help Help is the best song on Riot Act and so I'm voting for it knowing full well it won't win. And that's okay.

Giving a sympathy vote to "Help Help." It's a song I really like, but do I enjoy it more than "Immortality"? Not every day, but I want to acknowledge it here, knowing full will it will lose.

I really like stones chorus riff vs Jeff’s bass line in help help. It’s like they are competing.