Red Mosquito

Betterman vs. Porch

Vote is for Porch, but these are maybe the two best songs in this round.

Better Man

At its peak -- live '95 -- Porch was unstoppable. But it hasn't had that energy for two decades now (despite the fun resurgence with the Earthlings), while Betterman is still a welcome number in any live set.

"Porch" from Salt Lake City '95 is my favorite version of the song -- it really is a peak of sorts. But I pick "Better Man" too -- the first PJ song I loved.

i'm really tired of betterman and porch is a worthy opponent.

The porches from the spring ‘92 euro tour are my absolute favorites, with Dave hitting the triangle throughout the end of the solo. I miss that time.

But despite those, my vote’s for betterman.

Porch is just better, man.

Two obvious PJ classics. Should be a good match. Porch had never worked for me the way it has so many others. So this is an easy vote for Better Man. But I think both deserve the win.