MM 2-7: Whipping vs. Pry, To vs. Satan's Bed
Posted: Sat March 09, 2024 1:10 am
Whipping vs. Pry, To vs. Satan's Bed
Voting ends 3/10 8pm EST
Voting ends 3/10 8pm EST
Red Mosquito
MM 2-7: Whipping vs. Pry, To vs. Satan's Bed
Page 1 of 1
Re: MM 2-7: Whipping vs. Pry, To vs. Satan's Bed
Posted: Sat March 09, 2024 1:32 am
Tough choice but I’ll take Satan’s Bed since there’s whipping in Satan’s Bed so it’s like getting two for one!
Re: MM 2-7: Whipping vs. Pry, To vs. Satan's Bed
Posted: Sat March 09, 2024 1:33 am
Pry, To isn't really a song as much as it is an extended transition, so we'll ignore it.
This is so hard. Two songs I discovered (with everyone) during the Atlanta 94 broadcast, and which may remain the definitive live versions (certainly for Satan's Bed). I think I prefer the studio whipping to the studio Satan's Bed, but that's partially because I'm so in love with that live version. For a brief period it was my favorite Pearl Jam song, until I discovered Corduroy with the album's release.
Vote for Satan's Bed on the strength of Atlanta 94
This is so hard. Two songs I discovered (with everyone) during the Atlanta 94 broadcast, and which may remain the definitive live versions (certainly for Satan's Bed). I think I prefer the studio whipping to the studio Satan's Bed, but that's partially because I'm so in love with that live version. For a brief period it was my favorite Pearl Jam song, until I discovered Corduroy with the album's release.
Vote for Satan's Bed on the strength of Atlanta 94
Re: MM 2-7: Whipping vs. Pry, To vs. Satan's Bed
Posted: Sat March 09, 2024 1:34 am
way to maximize the value of your vote!liebzz wrote:Tough choice but I’ll take Satan’s Bed since there’s whipping in Satan’s Bed so it’s like getting two for one!
Re: MM 2-7: Whipping vs. Pry, To vs. Satan's Bed
Posted: Sat March 09, 2024 2:00 am
Whipping. The second song I ever saw them do live. In 94 a week before the Atlanta show. It blew my mind then and still does.
Re: MM 2-7: Whipping vs. Pry, To vs. Satan's Bed
Posted: Sat March 09, 2024 5:21 am
Satan’s Bed
Re: MM 2-7: Whipping vs. Pry, To vs. Satan's Bed
Posted: Sat March 09, 2024 12:14 pm
Whipping.
Re: MM 2-7: Whipping vs. Pry, To vs. Satan's Bed
Posted: Sat March 09, 2024 1:09 pm
Yikes…it’s like a tie for me with Whipping and Satan’s Bed. But…maybe Satan’s Bed by a smidge.
Re: MM 2-7: Whipping vs. Pry, To vs. Satan's Bed
Posted: Sat March 09, 2024 3:26 pm
Whipping has always fallen a little short for me. Satan's Bed was an album favorite from the jump, but has fallen off a bit as time has gone on. I'd say they're about equal for me now. Enjoy both well enough but never reach for either.
Re: MM 2-7: Whipping vs. Pry, To vs. Satan's Bed
Posted: Sat March 09, 2024 3:44 pm
Egad, man! How did you vote?!epilogue wrote:Whipping has always fallen a little short for me. Satan's Bed was an album favorite from the jump, but has fallen off a bit as time has gone on. I'd say they're about equal for me now. Enjoy both well enough but never reach for either.
Re: MM 2-7: Whipping vs. Pry, To vs. Satan's Bed
Posted: Sat March 09, 2024 3:48 pm
OH!stip wrote:Egad, man! How did you vote?!epilogue wrote:Whipping has always fallen a little short for me. Satan's Bed was an album favorite from the jump, but has fallen off a bit as time has gone on. I'd say they're about equal for me now. Enjoy both well enough but never reach for either.
Satan's Bed
Re: MM 2-7: Whipping vs. Pry, To vs. Satan's Bed
Posted: Sat March 09, 2024 3:48 pm
But I could be swayed.
Re: MM 2-7: Whipping vs. Pry, To vs. Satan's Bed
Posted: Sat March 09, 2024 4:23 pm
While I’m a huge fan of the song, I’ve always kinda seen Satan’s Bed as more a “joke” song like Mankind or Dirty Frank. The lyric about sucking Satan’s dick? Come on.
Whipping is the better, more powerful song.
Whipping is the better, more powerful song.
Re: MM 2-7: Whipping vs. Pry, To vs. Satan's Bed
Posted: Sun March 10, 2024 11:54 pm
Satan's Bed advances