MM 2-15: Immortality vs Smile

[stip]

Voting ends 3/13/24 8 EST

[stip]

well this was not the final I would have predicted.

Immortality hopelessly outclasses Smile

[liebzz]

I voted Immortality but Smile is getting unnecessary guff here. It’s a great song that would almost fit a 70’s Neil Young album. And before you say it’s too goofy, remember that Neil Young had songs like Ride My Llama and Welfare Mothers that decade.

[LetMeSleep]

Smile is nice enough.

Immortality is essential.

[stip]

I voted Immortality but Smile is getting unnecessary guff here. It’s a great song that would almost fit a 70’s Neil Young album. And before you say it’s too goofy, remember that Neil Young had songs like Ride My Llama and Welfare Mothers that decade.

Smile is a perfectly nice song. But nothingman is transcendent. I think the guff is for how far it punched above its weight class.

[Anders]

Smile

[Anders]

And it’s a far better song than Nothingman.

[coptheriotact]

first time voting for immortality...

[Higgs]

And it’s a far better song than Nothingman.

You're beginning to piss me off Anders.

[tommy]

The Smile voters should be neutered

[Ello Sailor]

The Smile > Pearl Jam though, so...

[mray10]

I adore Smile but Immortality is the #1 Pearl Jam song so

[epilogue]

The Smile > Pearl Jam though, so...

Nonsense

[Anders]

Who would wim from Animal vs Immortality?

[digster]

Smile, although these are neck and neck for me, compared to Immortality's last few rounds.

[stip]

Who would wim from Animal vs Immortality?

we may find out in about two months

[Ello Sailor]

The Smile > Pearl Jam though, so...

Nonsense

No u sense

[stip]

In a nail biter, Immortality defeats smile 41-8