Red Mosquito

Yellow Ledbetter vs. Devil Doll vs. Hitchhiker vs. Whale Song

Yellow Ledbetter is top 3 most beautiful songs they've ever written (along with Nothingman and whatever I want number 3 to be in a given moment)

Devil Doll is a serviceable cover, Hitchhiker is a song I actively dislike, and Whale Song is a weird oddity. No hesitation here

stip wrote:Hitchhiker is a song I actively dislike

You fool!

Anyway, yes, that's my vote.

Birds in Hell wrote:

stip wrote:Hitchhiker is a song I actively dislike

You fool!

Anyway, yes, that's my vote.

Mine as well, good sir!

YL

Hitchhiker it is though when all is said and done I am sure Yellow Ledbetter advances - a b-side organic hit song.

Love Hitchhiker!!

That was from a period where Ed was just writing a shit ton of songs... ah, sigh

Whale song is underrated and it’s oddness is its charm

Hitchhiker

Hitchhiker

I love Whale Song. My vote.

God damnit.

This tournament always seems to remind me how good this band was/is. At one point it felt like this band could write any type of song at any fucking moment and blow me away..

Fuck covers.

Devil Doll isn't even PJ playing. Why is it here? Thats Ed and the supersuckers.

Gotta go Ledbetter here but Whale Song and Hitchhiker are fantastic gems.

If the 7 Whale Song voters want to make this a real contest, they should switch their votes to Hitchhiker, since WS ain't gonna win.

I’m to the point I pretty much hate Ledbetter. Go Hitchhiker.

epilogue wrote:If the 7 Whale Song voters want to make this a real contest, they should switch their votes to Hitchhiker, since WS ain't gonna win.

Ok.

I am a chaos muppet.

LET'S FUCKING GO HITCHHIKER!

Switched to hitchhiker

So be gone, Yellow Ledbetter, too soon is too late

Hitchhiker

Ledbetter is fine, but I think I'd like it more if it had proper lyrics