Page 1 of 6

Let's make the Ultimate PJ Album: TRACK 12

Posted: Sat November 16, 2024 5:06 am
by Jorge
"In My Tree" squeaks through with a single-vote victory, and No Code is off the table.

Now vote for track 12! Of course not every Pearl Jam album has a track 12, and three of them have already been eliminated, so pickings are slim.

Red Mosquito's Ultimate PJ Album so far:

01. Can't Keep
02.
03.
04. In My Tree
05.
06.
07.
08.
09. Grievance
10.
11.
12.
13.

Re: Let's make the Ultimate PJ Album: TRACK 12

Posted: Sat November 16, 2024 5:09 am
by Anders
Come Back

Re: Let's make the Ultimate PJ Album: TRACK 12

Posted: Sat November 16, 2024 5:10 am
by Anders
Anything but Future Days.

Re: Let's make the Ultimate PJ Album: TRACK 12

Posted: Sat November 16, 2024 5:34 am
by Leatherhead
Anders wrote:Come Back
Agreed.

Re: Let's make the Ultimate PJ Album: TRACK 12

Posted: Sat November 16, 2024 5:50 am
by Monkey_Driven
I voted Push Me Pull Me, but also considered Come Back (though it's a 3 star song at best).

Re: Let's make the Ultimate PJ Album: TRACK 12

Posted: Sat November 16, 2024 6:17 am
by Leatherhead
Monkey_Driven wrote:I voted Push Me Pull Me, but also considered Come Back (though it's a 3 star song at best).
Push Me Pull Me is great, but DTE might be PJ's best song, so I'm really hoping we can get it for #7.

Re: Let's make the Ultimate PJ Album: TRACK 12

Posted: Sat November 16, 2024 6:48 am
by Monkey_Driven
Leatherhead wrote:
Monkey_Driven wrote:I voted Push Me Pull Me, but also considered Come Back (though it's a 3 star song at best).
Push Me Pull Me is great, but DTE might be PJ's best song, so I'm really hoping we can get it for #7.
Facts

Re: Let's make the Ultimate PJ Album: TRACK 12

Posted: Sat November 16, 2024 7:05 am
by Tj
Facts are something from lightning turd has to be picked.
Are you gonna pic mym over Animal nope

Mfs over Dance or No Way NoWay

Lighting Bolt over Black Won't Tell Marker nope or nothingman

Infallible over Parachutes or Upper Hand
7 o'clock

Pendulum over Dte or Rvm

Swallowed Hole over Corduroy

Get my point.

Future Day at 12 won't derail this you will still get a great closer at 13. And a bunch of solids at 11 ie Setting Sun Release In Hiding

I know it kills everyone but Future Days is the only answer

Re: Let's make the Ultimate PJ Album: TRACK 12

Posted: Sat November 16, 2024 7:30 am
by Leatherhead
Tj wrote:I know it kills everyone but Future Days is the only answer
I don't hate it like I used to.

Re: Let's make the Ultimate PJ Album: TRACK 12

Posted: Sat November 16, 2024 9:07 am
by Birds in Hell
I could definitely live with River Cross here.

Re: Let's make the Ultimate PJ Album: TRACK 12

Posted: Sat November 16, 2024 9:15 am
by Anders
Future Days is the worst song on its album. It will destroy this collection.

Re: Let's make the Ultimate PJ Album: TRACK 12

Posted: Sat November 16, 2024 10:00 am
by Matters
Indifference kills animal
Aye Davanita kills corduroy
Can’t find it in me to vote for any of the others.

Random track order is a great idea.

Re: Let's make the Ultimate PJ Album: TRACK 12

Posted: Sat November 16, 2024 10:41 am
by stip
the problem here isnt which song to pick as much as most of these really work as closers in their own right and there is still a 13th song to follow that will also be a slow one

hmmm

Re: Let's make the Ultimate PJ Album: TRACK 12

Posted: Sat November 16, 2024 10:43 am
by stip
come back is not my favorite on this list but it’s good and fits the bill

Re: Let's make the Ultimate PJ Album: TRACK 12

Posted: Sat November 16, 2024 12:29 pm
by wease
Anders wrote:Future Days is the worst song on its album. It will destroy this collection.
This collection is already destroyed

Re: Let's make the Ultimate PJ Album: TRACK 12

Posted: Sat November 16, 2024 12:32 pm
by stip
I wonder if it would have been better to collapse tracks 12+ into one larger category

Re: Let's make the Ultimate PJ Album: TRACK 12

Posted: Sat November 16, 2024 12:35 pm
by Anders
wease wrote:
Anders wrote:Future Days is the worst song on its album. It will destroy this collection.
This collection is already destroyed
Only decent songs on the album so far.

Re: Let's make the Ultimate PJ Album: TRACK 12

Posted: Sat November 16, 2024 2:03 pm
by Tj
stip wrote:I wonder if it would have been better to collapse tracks 12+ into one larger category
Maybe 13 tracks with the wild card at final voting were we vote first on placement meaning it could be anywhere then we pic a song on Lost Dog to fill that spot.

Any track that is a closer is eligible to be closer even if it is 12 or 11.
If the wild card I'm a vote of the whole catalog then the winner may just have 2 votes. Went to PMPM here after all kills Yield but it's a good second to last song.

Re: Let's make the Ultimate PJ Album: TRACK 12

Posted: Sat November 16, 2024 2:08 pm
by VinylGuy
Come Back. I would prefer River Cross but i think there are better songs from Gigaton i prefer in the list.

Fuuuuck FD. I mean Fuuuuuck FD.

If FD gets chosen im out of this.

Fuuuuck you Future Days, specially the studio version with all its saccharin and awful pianos. It gave me diabetes.

Re: Let's make the Ultimate PJ Album: TRACK 12

Posted: Sat November 16, 2024 2:12 pm
by Farmer John
I'm voting for Indifference for now.