5-13: The Dark vs. Who Ever Said
Posted: Thu March 27, 2025 9:28 pm
The Dark vs. Who Ever Said
Red Mosquito
5-13: The Dark vs. Who Ever Said
Page 1 of 1
Re: 5-13: The Dark vs. Who Ever Said
Posted: Thu March 27, 2025 9:35 pm
Fuck. I love The Dark. Maybe my favorite or second favorite Earthlings song. But Who Ever Said is a 5 star song.
Re: 5-13: The Dark vs. Who Ever Said
Posted: Thu March 27, 2025 9:41 pm
Who Ever Said is a real gem in the latter part of the band's catalogue.
The Dark is, I understand, a song on the Ed/Wotman record.
The Dark is, I understand, a song on the Ed/Wotman record.
Re: 5-13: The Dark vs. Who Ever Said
Posted: Thu March 27, 2025 11:36 pm
WES! 
The Dark is super overrated
The Dark is super overrated
Re: 5-13: The Dark vs. Who Ever Said
Posted: Fri March 28, 2025 12:19 am
I voted for The Dark. It is unreasonably catchy and exactly the sort of thing Ed can excel at without the weight of the rest of Pearl Jam. Who Ever Said is also great, but in a toss up, I think I’d put The Dark in my playlist first.
Re: 5-13: The Dark vs. Who Ever Said
Posted: Fri March 28, 2025 12:28 am
The Dark might be my least favorite Ed solo song.
There, I said it.
There, I said it.
Re: 5-13: The Dark vs. Who Ever Said
Posted: Fri March 28, 2025 4:39 am
The Dark
I love it!
I love it!
Re: 5-13: The Dark vs. Who Ever Said
Posted: Fri March 28, 2025 6:49 am
Who Ever Said
Re: 5-13: The Dark vs. Who Ever Said
Posted: Fri March 28, 2025 10:35 am
this is a crazy thing for you to have saidepilogue wrote:The Dark might be my least favorite Ed solo song.
There, I said it.
Re: 5-13: The Dark vs. Who Ever Said
Posted: Fri March 28, 2025 11:42 am
It is. I got heated and wrapped up in a real life moment and I took it out on poor The Dark.stip wrote:this is a crazy thing for you to have saidepilogue wrote:The Dark might be my least favorite Ed solo song.
There, I said it.
While I honestly don't get the love for the tune, it's not Ed's worst solo song. It's probably not a bad song at all. It just does absolutely nothing for me. And I'm really happy it isn't on a proper PJ album.
Re: 5-13: The Dark vs. Who Ever Said
Posted: Fri March 28, 2025 1:01 pm
it's got a kind of optimistic brightness to it that I would have guessed you would be into
Re: 5-13: The Dark vs. Who Ever Said
Posted: Fri March 28, 2025 1:45 pm
Maybe I should listen to it again...
Re: 5-13: The Dark vs. Who Ever Said
Posted: Fri March 28, 2025 2:04 pm
Okay, I just listened to it. First time in... I don't know how long.
The sentiment is nice. And I didn't have the aversion to it that I remembered. But it's reminds me a lot of everything I like least about 80s era Springsteen.
Still, I owe the song a real apology. Worst Ed solo song? Not by a long shot. I'd completely erased The Haves from my memory.
The sentiment is nice. And I didn't have the aversion to it that I remembered. But it's reminds me a lot of everything I like least about 80s era Springsteen.
Still, I owe the song a real apology. Worst Ed solo song? Not by a long shot. I'd completely erased The Haves from my memory.
Re: 5-13: The Dark vs. Who Ever Said
Posted: Fri March 28, 2025 2:29 pm
It is an 80s springsteen song - so if that's not for you then this makes sense.epilogue wrote:Okay, I just listened to it. First time in... I don't know how long.
The sentiment is nice. And I didn't have the aversion to it that I remembered. But it's reminds me a lot of everything I like least about 80s era Springsteen.
Still, I owe the song a real apology. Worst Ed solo song? Not by a long shot. I'd completely erased The Haves from my memory.
And yes, the Haves is like No More level syrup.
Re: 5-13: The Dark vs. Who Ever Said
Posted: Fri March 28, 2025 6:30 pm
"Try" is my favorite Earthling song too
Re: 5-13: The Dark vs. Who Ever Said
Posted: Fri March 28, 2025 6:32 pm
Peas and carrots, you and me.Kevin Davis wrote:"Try" is my favorite Earthling song too