Page 1 of 1
7-7: River Cross vs Happy When I'm Crying
Posted: Tue April 01, 2025 12:33 pm
by stip
River Cross vs Happy When I'm Crying
Re: 7-7: River Cross vs Happy When I'm Crying
Posted: Tue April 01, 2025 12:42 pm
by stip
Love River Cross - so lost and desolate but wrapping itself around that one guttering flame of hope and breathing life back into it before the end. So good.
Happy When I'm Crying is a fun secret song that RM has helped me appreciate. But River Cross was the perfect encapsulation of how I felt in the early stages of COVID. It's an Everybody Hurts for me. I don't listen often. But when I do, it always hits hard
Re: 7-7: River Cross vs Happy When I'm Crying
Posted: Tue April 01, 2025 1:12 pm
by Anders
Happy
Re: 7-7: River Cross vs Happy When I'm Crying
Posted: Tue April 01, 2025 1:17 pm
by Higgs
I am quite the Rivers Cross fan.
Re: 7-7: River Cross vs Happy When I'm Crying
Posted: Tue April 01, 2025 1:33 pm
by Kevin Davis
I'd cross a river to vote for "Happy When I'm Crying"
Re: 7-7: River Cross vs Happy When I'm Crying
Posted: Tue April 01, 2025 1:42 pm
by Farmer John
Happy When I'm Crying should win this whole thing, dammit
Re: 7-7: River Cross vs Happy When I'm Crying
Posted: Tue April 01, 2025 1:43 pm
by Farmer John
One of my favourite Jack Irons memories is when I asked him on Facebook if he wrote Happy When I'm Crying (a question I already knew the answer to) and he replied "yes".
Re: 7-7: River Cross vs Happy When I'm Crying
Posted: Tue April 01, 2025 1:48 pm
by Kevin Davis
Farmer John wrote:One of my favourite Jack Irons memories is when I asked him on Facebook if he wrote Happy When I'm Crying (a question I already knew the answer to) and he replied "yes".
This alone should be reason enough for it to win
Re: 7-7: River Cross vs Happy When I'm Crying
Posted: Tue April 01, 2025 8:52 pm
by epilogue
I don't think these songs are particularly well matched.
Happy When I'm Crying should steamroll this one. And I say that as a fan of River Cross.
Re: 7-7: River Cross vs Happy When I'm Crying
Posted: Wed April 02, 2025 1:31 am
by Matters
I’m Happy When I see these results.
Re: 7-7: River Cross vs Happy When I'm Crying
Posted: Wed April 02, 2025 2:04 am
by Birds in Hell
epilogue wrote:Happy When I'm Crying should steamroll this one. And I say that as a fan of River Cross.
Same.
Re: 7-7: River Cross vs Happy When I'm Crying
Posted: Wed April 02, 2025 4:43 am
by bodysnatcher
Never gotten into River Cross for whatever reason. But HWIC is top 15 if not maybe 10.