Red Mosquito

Porch vs. Black

The end of Pearl Jam 'hear my name...' to the end, is as good as pearl jam gets. Black is a tremendous song, but Porch is still top 5 after all these years

I agree on the cathartic finish to Porch, but the solo in Black is also a big moment. I did vote for Porch.

Both classics, and I don't know if I've ever voted against Black in one of these, but this year Porch is getting this vote.

Black is an all-timer

Somehow missed the last round, and Release is out. Ouch.

Black

How crazy good an album must be if Porch is my tenth favorite song on it.

Black

Porch.

I get we’re considering studio versions, but one of the first iconic live moments of this band was that MTV Unplugged performance of Porch. It was that epic jam and final cathartic finish come to life. It’s put this song in my Pearl Jam mixes and playlists ever since.

I would consider whatever you like. Fast and loose, baby!

FWIW, I only consider studio versions during this tournament. Unless the only option is a live track or if the tournament is specifically live versions or whatever.

But y'all do you.

Round is closed

Porch over Black 14-13.

Which of weird because the current poll is Black over Porch 14-13

oh shit!