Match BX: Wishlist vs. Santa God

[stip]

Match BX

[stip]

I kinda like santa god for an x-mas song, but wishlist is amazing

[digster]

Wishlist is a great song, and one of their great studio performances. I've never heard a live version that matches it. I always associate the song with Sometimes; both studio versions of those songs generate a similar feel to me.

I think I listened to Santa God once. Man, a lot of those Xmas singles are showing up in this round, and barring the Jackson 5 cover they're pretty bland.

[chewm]

Santa God is a really nice tune.
Wishlist is way better tho

[LetMeSleep]

I had to go for Wishlist. And that hurts. Urgghhh

[Lament]

Wishlist is really nice in the context of Yield. The way begins just barely being audible after the bombast of Given to Fly and then fades out as Ed is still wishing makes it feel almost like you're eavesdropping on a really private moment.

It loses a lot of that appeal outside of the context of the album for me, but within the album it works really nicely.

[malice]

I had to go for Wishlist. And that hurts. Urgghhh

yeah

[bada]

I hate the fade out. I get the idea but I heard the Monkey Wrench version first and that's the version I love. They should have ended it it like that on the record.

[epilogue]

Wishlist.

[CopperTom]

Wish list. I never knew there was so many Xmas songs. I nay make a holiday album next year.