DP: Release vs. Of the Girl
Posted: Wed March 19, 2014 1:08 am
DP
I suspect this will be closer than it should be, but I've been wrong so many times so far.
Obviously release
Red Mosquito
DP: Release vs. Of the Girl
Page 1 of 4
Re: DP: Release vs. Of the Girl
Posted: Wed March 19, 2014 1:16 am
Re: DP: Release vs. Of the Girl
Posted: Wed March 19, 2014 1:28 am
How Rod makes his getaway...
Re: DP: Release vs. Of the Girl
Posted: Wed March 19, 2014 1:30 am
I wish Release or Sleight of Hand would win this whole thing.
Re: DP: Release vs. Of the Girl
Posted: Wed March 19, 2014 1:32 am
While I enjoy Release to a point, I think Of the Girl is clearly the better - and more enjoyable - song.
Re: DP: Release vs. Of the Girl
Posted: Wed March 19, 2014 1:33 am
what would rod do...
Re: DP: Release vs. Of the Girl
Posted: Wed March 19, 2014 1:39 am
Of the Girl is a favorite of mine. of course, it has no chance.
Re: DP: Release vs. Of the Girl
Posted: Wed March 19, 2014 1:57 am
This is a real tough one. Release is a classic that, in my mind, will neeeeeever get old, which doesn't happen much these days (I've voted against Porch and Alive in this tournament), but Of The Girl is on its own planet. But I can't vote against Release.
Re: DP: Release vs. Of the Girl
Posted: Wed March 19, 2014 2:02 am
I really like them both. Of the Girl gets the tiebreaker since that was my first PJ song live.
Re: DP: Release vs. Of the Girl
Posted: Wed March 19, 2014 2:26 am
PHATJ wrote:I wish Of the Girl or Sleight of Hand would win this whole thing.
Re: DP: Release vs. Of the Girl
Posted: Wed March 19, 2014 2:28 am
Moooooo
Moooooo
Oh dear Dad...
Moooooo
Oh dear Dad...
Re: DP: Release vs. Of the Girl
Posted: Wed March 19, 2014 2:28 am
Nice try. One out of two ain't bad.beat wrote:PHATJ wrote:I wish Of the Girl or Sleight of Hand would win this whole thing.
Re: DP: Release vs. Of the Girl
Posted: Wed March 19, 2014 2:35 am
Really though...
Girl should be longer. And needs vibraphone. It's got great mood (when Mikes not wanking live), but as it is it feels like it reaches for I Am Yours when it ahould be an acoustic Zeppelin meander
Release meant more to me before I lost my father, and before his final days were so brutally destructive. So I think I lost some connection because it aches for a bond, and I'm just lost. When a song hits a topic so specifically, I suppose your individual situation can screw with your bond. Either way, I do like the natural rise and fall (as opposed to the designed one of later songs).
No vote.
Girl should be longer. And needs vibraphone. It's got great mood (when Mikes not wanking live), but as it is it feels like it reaches for I Am Yours when it ahould be an acoustic Zeppelin meander
Release meant more to me before I lost my father, and before his final days were so brutally destructive. So I think I lost some connection because it aches for a bond, and I'm just lost. When a song hits a topic so specifically, I suppose your individual situation can screw with your bond. Either way, I do like the natural rise and fall (as opposed to the designed one of later songs).
No vote.
Re: DP: Release vs. Of the Girl
Posted: Wed March 19, 2014 3:02 am
i just Googled "DP release of the girl" trying to find a shortcut to this thread and i was horrified at the search results...
Re: DP: Release vs. Of the Girl
Posted: Wed March 19, 2014 3:05 am
Of the girl is enjoyable, but one of the most overrated songs here in my opinion
Release is my favorite pearl jam song ever.
Not even close.
Release is my favorite pearl jam song ever.
Not even close.
Re: DP: Release vs. Of the Girl
Posted: Wed March 19, 2014 3:49 am
96583UP wrote:i just Googled "DP release of the girl" trying to find a shortcut to this thread and i was horrified at the search results...
Re: DP: Release vs. Of the Girl
Posted: Wed March 19, 2014 4:24 am
Ugh. Release still pulls emotions out of me like no other song in their catalogue can, but Of the Girl is, like, so. fucking. cool.
Re: DP: Release vs. Of the Girl
Posted: Wed March 19, 2014 4:41 am
yupBirds in Hell wrote:While I enjoy Release to a point, I think Of the Girl is clearly the better - and more enjoyable - song.
Re: DP: Release vs. Of the Girl
Posted: Wed March 19, 2014 5:17 am
OtG ...
Re: DP: Release vs. Of the Girl
Posted: Wed March 19, 2014 5:23 am
Sorry to hear it, man... I'm in a similar place with Release, but it actually helped me come to terms with the whole situation. Very powerful song, despite the cows...McParadigm wrote:Really though...
Release meant more to me before I lost my father, and before his final days were so brutally destructive. So I think I lost some connection because it aches for a bond, and I'm just lost. When a song hits a topic so specifically, I suppose your individual situation can screw with your bond. Either way, I do like the natural rise and fall (as opposed to the designed one of later songs).
No vote.