Red Mosquito

Matt Cameron
Jeff Ament
Stone Gossard
Dave Abrruzzese
Dave Krusen
Mike McCready
Eddie Vedder
Jack irons
Matt Chamberlain
Boom Gaspar

Is that a list or a ranking?

Tread carefully, ABNorman. An Incorrect answer gets this thread locked.

Eddie Vedder

Let's call it a hardly-ranked-at-all list. Though I do think peeps give Cameron and Ament far too many kudos.

And if there was an 11th space, BoB would totes be there.

I'm drunk.

Ament isn't overrated. He's barely noticed since he quit wearing funny hats.

Somewhere, Jimmy Shoaf is smiling right now.

BurtReynolds wrote:

Ricky Ramone is underrated.

EJ wrote:Somewhere, Jimmy Shoaf is smiling right now.

I can barely remember what each of the Daves did. Shoaf never had a chance.

Among the fans PJ nerdy enough to sign up for a message board, it's Mccready by a long shot.

For everybody else, it's gotta be EV. He's also the most underrated and most fairly rated.

Mike is the best part of riot act and did good work on st. He has underwhelmed since, for sure

BoB

Ed - overrated
Stone - underrated
Mike - overrated
Jeff - underrated
Matt - overrated
Boom - about right

So, altogether the band is slightly overrated.