Red Mosquito

EV

I just don't care about I Got Shit anymore. I still remember the visceral thrill I had when I first heard it, but I haven't been able to recreate it in forever. I don't like getting this one live either. Indifference remains awesome.

I love them both. It's interesting that they kind of approach the same hopelessness in different manners. Ultimately, I think Indifference has more staying power with me. Boy does that original track sound just phenomenal.

Indifference by a small margin.

Imagine being indifferent about having shit.

Love them both. Will go with I got Shit for no valid reason.

I can only imagine what these sessions were like.

Neil: here's what I've got, Ed. "People my age / they don't do the things I do / they go somewhere / while I run away with you."

Ed: here's mine: (recites self-pity party)

Neil: I...ahh...

Ed: pretty good eh? But I think it's too happy, still, so I was gonna try and make it darker before we record.

Neil: we should check with your label. You know? Just...to be sure. I guess. Cos it's probably...I think...it's not gonna be...boy, is it ever warm in here.

Ed: are you sweating?

stip wrote:I just don't care about I Got Shit anymore. I still remember the visceral thrill I had when I first heard it, but I haven't been able to recreate it in forever.

I relate to this in regards to many early Pearl Jam songs but for whatever reason "I Got Shit" isn't one of them. It gets my vote here.

Coin flip. Indifference.

I Got Shit is easily the most overrated song on this board. Indifference.

I heard I got shit at my first ever Pj show and they nailed it that night. But they've never managed to conjure up whatever magic it has ever since I don't think.

how much difference does it make?

Indifference.

I love Indifference, but I Got Shit is on another level. Top 5 for me.

dimejinky99 wrote:I heard I got shit at my first ever Pj show and they nailed it that night. But they've never managed to conjure up whatever magic it has ever since I don't think.

Jack Irons: there's your missing ingredient.

Birds in Hell wrote:

dimejinky99 wrote:I heard I got shit at my first ever Pj show and they nailed it that night. But they've never managed to conjure up whatever magic it has ever since I don't think.

Jack Irons: there's your missing ingredient.

Wow. Never actually even thought of that. Spot on spenno!


(It's a reeeeeaal possibiliteeeeeee)

Tough one.
I Got Shit.

I Got Shit is so so so much better.

chewm wrote:Tough one.
I Got Shit.

chewm wrote:I Got Shit.
Tough one.

Sadly, how much difference will my vote make?