Page 1 of 2
Division 3 Round 4bc: All Those Yesterdays vs. Of the Girl
Posted: Mon March 02, 2015 2:00 pm
by stip
Division 3 Round 4bc: All Those Yesterdays vs. Of the Girl
Re: Division 3 Round 4bc: All Those Yesterdays vs. Of the Gi
Posted: Mon March 02, 2015 2:07 pm
by stip
All Those Yesterdays easily. I could care less about Of the Girl
Re: Division 3 Round 4bc: All Those Yesterdays vs. Of the Gi
Posted: Mon March 02, 2015 3:09 pm
by epilogue
I'm gonna go with ATY. It hurts, but... JESUS OF THE GIRL IS SOOOOOOO GOOOOOOOD.
Fuck it, I'm going with Of The Girl. Changing my vote now.
Re: Division 3 Round 4bc: All Those Yesterdays vs. Of the Gi
Posted: Mon March 02, 2015 3:09 pm
by epilogue
Fuck I hate myself. Should I change it back to ATY?
I have no idea what to do here....
Re: Division 3 Round 4bc: All Those Yesterdays vs. Of the Gi
Posted: Mon March 02, 2015 3:28 pm
by Norah
This is no knock on aty but otg should win here.
Re: Division 3 Round 4bc: All Those Yesterdays vs. Of the Gi
Posted: Mon March 02, 2015 4:00 pm
by doone
durdencommatyler wrote:Fuck I hate myself. Should I change it back to ATY?
I have no idea what to do here....
give them a listen, it'll become clear.
Tough call but Of the Girl for me.
Re: Division 3 Round 4bc: All Those Yesterdays vs. Of the Gi
Posted: Mon March 02, 2015 4:15 pm
by hlniv
Funny how it seems every one of stip's opinions this round is directly opposite of mine
Re: Division 3 Round 4bc: All Those Yesterdays vs. Of the Gi
Posted: Mon March 02, 2015 4:54 pm
by B
stip wrote:All Those Yesterdays easily. I could care less about Of the Girl
Re: Division 3 Round 4bc: All Those Yesterdays vs. Of the Gi
Posted: Mon March 02, 2015 5:37 pm
by Thejambi
I love them both. I love Of the Girl slightly more.
Re: Division 3 Round 4bc: All Those Yesterdays vs. Of the Gi
Posted: Mon March 02, 2015 5:42 pm
by chewm
All Those Yesterdays against Cropduster was a pretty tough one.
This isnt, AtY is a million times better than Of the Girl.
Re: Division 3 Round 4bc: All Those Yesterdays vs. Of the Gi
Posted: Mon March 02, 2015 6:18 pm
by PHATJ
Of the Girl, but it's close.
Re: Division 3 Round 4bc: All Those Yesterdays vs. Of the Gi
Posted: Mon March 02, 2015 6:33 pm
by darth_vedder
durdencommatyler wrote:Fuck I hate myself. Should I change it back to ATY?
I have no idea what to do here....
Yes, search your feelings!
Re: Division 3 Round 4bc: All Those Yesterdays vs. Of the Gi
Posted: Mon March 02, 2015 6:33 pm
by darth_vedder
Ouch, this is a really hard one, but ATY is one of my personal favorites.
Re: Division 3 Round 4bc: All Those Yesterdays vs. Of the Gi
Posted: Mon March 02, 2015 7:36 pm
by Strat
Of the girl is so fucking good. I would love that song to open every show. And close it down. Its so sexy. Sparse. The interplay is wonderful. Simple yet effective. Sleek yet vigilante
ATY is great too but OTG is just....just..
Ya.
Re: Division 3 Round 4bc: All Those Yesterdays vs. Of the Gi
Posted: Mon March 02, 2015 7:43 pm
by LoathedVermin72
OTG. No contest.
Re: Division 3 Round 4bc: All Those Yesterdays vs. Of the Gi
Posted: Mon March 02, 2015 7:46 pm
by Birds in Hell
All Those Yesterdays.
Re: Division 3 Round 4bc: All Those Yesterdays vs. Of the Gi
Posted: Mon March 02, 2015 8:43 pm
by LetMeSleep
Two songs I've always liked but never to the extent and passion of you guys.
Of The Girl
Re: Division 3 Round 4bc: All Those Yesterdays vs. Of the Gi
Posted: Mon March 02, 2015 10:37 pm
by thesound
chewm wrote:All Those Yesterdays against Cropduster was a pretty tough one.
This isnt, AtY is a million times better than Of the Girl.
I agree. Although I still would have voted ATY over Cropduster.
Of the Girl is overrated in my opinion. I guess it is a nice atmospheric slow jam and something Pearl Jam doesn't do much of, but I still prefer ATY by quite a lot. Shame it will probably lose this match.
Re: Division 3 Round 4bc: All Those Yesterdays vs. Of the Gi
Posted: Mon March 02, 2015 11:01 pm
by Kevin Davis
"Of the Girl" is a fine song, but "All Those Yesterdays" is Pearl Jam at their poppy, Stoney best. The "what are you running from..." bridge, especially in the studio version, is wonderful -- sing-songy and kind of silly-sounding, but also weirdly poised. When I think of why "Yield" is my favorite album, songs like "ATY" are the reason why -- quirky, likable pop tunes void of pretentiousness.
Re: Division 3 Round 4bc: All Those Yesterdays vs. Of the Gi
Posted: Tue March 03, 2015 2:16 pm
by William Bloke
I really love Of the Girl. But listening to these 2 back to back I have to go with ATY. Such a gem.