Red Mosquito

Division 1 Semifinals: Black vs. Daughter

two excellent songs I've worn out over the years. But Black is better. Plus a good we belong together moment trumps a good daughter tag.

Black. It's the song that changed everything for me.

Daughter, though neither are my favorites. Both solid numbers, but I think Daughter is there winner here.

Daughter.

I am so fully invested in Team Daughter it's sickening.

Tough one. Both are, and always will be, classics.

Black will always have a special place for me, though. Daughter has just kind of been there, it never really gives me special moments.

Daughter has aged better for me over the years but I like Black much more.

Thejambi wrote:Daughter has aged better for me over the years but I like Black much more.

I pretty much feel this way too.

Daughter.

Finally, a match-up that I'm winning!

Team Daughter.

"Daughter", no contest.

Daughter, for the splendid hi hat work from Texas' Most Wanted.

Daughter.

Ugh

Daughter is much cooler. Coolness is an accurate measurement of greatness.

Vote to Black. The music still stands. Yeah, I know, the lyrics, but they are honest and come from a real place.

I listen to Daughter now just for the tags.

Black is still pretty wonderful. It's all storm and stress and high melodrama that pretty much mirrors the over the top emotional collapse at the end of an important relationship--and somehow manages to not feel silly in the process.

Black is the song that made me fall in love with PJ, but after listening to this band for over 10 years Daughter impresses me much more.

Ah man ... Black is back in the lead?