Red Mosquito

Vote

Undone is my second favorite song from the Riot Act period. You Are is great music and a wonderful idea that somehow got turned into a middling song

You Are is definitely the cooler song but if you ask me what I want to put on right now, it's Undone.

Undone vs the song that used to be called Undone.
Undone gets my vote but they are both great.

Unfair matchup. I love both of these songs so much it hurts.

I'd be fine with You Are taking this whole thing.

wow, really? What is it you're hearing?

You are.

Fantastic song. Get off it about the lyrics. They work. The mood and atmosphere and riff and shit the band actually doing something different with their instruments is all super exciting words are hard this song is nice and also undone is good too but you are yay

stip wrote:wow, really? What is it you're hearing?

It's such a unique song in their catalog. Hard to describe. But the version from San Diego '06 made me a believer.

You Are is the perfect example of why Matt should write more songs.

You Are.

You Are all fuckin' day.

Thanks LV

E.H. Ruddock wrote:You Are is the perfect example of why Matt should write more songs.

oh and Get Right.

E.H. Ruddock wrote:

E.H. Ruddock wrote:You Are is the perfect example of why Matt should write more songs.

oh and Get Right.

and in the moonlight and evacuation and cropduster and everything

Strat wrote:

E.H. Ruddock wrote:

E.H. Ruddock wrote:You Are is the perfect example of why Matt should write more songs.

oh and Get Right.

and in the moonlight and evacuation and cropduster and everything

srsly.

He's written some real gems.

They create such a singular mood with You Are. That sense of lumbering doom doesn't exist anywhere else in their catalog. The psychedelic inflections, Ed's weary and busted vocal style...the whole thing sounds like a huge, monolithic machine slowly falling apart. "This broken wheel is coming undone" sets the stage perfectly. And then that bridge manages to give some sense of hope of a better life off in the distance.

It's an easy catalog highlight for me.

I love You Are. It has always been my favorite Riot Act track.

PHATJ wrote:I love You Are. It had always been my favorite Riot Act track.

Copy that.

I love the road trip-y vibe of Undone, but You Are gets my vote for all around awesomeness.

Strat wrote:

E.H. Ruddock wrote:

E.H. Ruddock wrote:You Are is the perfect example of why Matt should write more songs.

oh and Get Right.

and in the moonlight and evacuation and cropduster and everything