Red Mosquito

Vote

Tough one.

Not really. Hail Hail.

Hail Hail could win this and I'd be happy.

Two very good songs that don't quite crack the top tier.

Nothingman

Oh man. Two of my favorite pj songs. So fantastic. These days i rather listen to Nothingman but Hail Hail is so well produced and - well - just awesome.

tbd

Yea, this one's tough. I'm gonna hold off in hopes that someone offers an iron-clad argument for either one.

This is an easy one, Hail Hail.

"Nothingman" is lovely, but has dropped a bit in my estimation over the years. "Hail, Hail" is just about as perfect a song as this band has made, though. I'd pick "Nothingman" over some others in this round, but I can't do it here.

I picked Nothingman, but I like Hail Hail just as much.

I was torn, but it looks like it's gonna be a blow out, so I've voted for Nothingman just on principle.

Nothingman is my favorite Vitalogy song. I love Hail Hail but this isnt close for me.

Both of these are great songs. Two of the band's best really. But even still, Hail Hail should win easily. And I don't mean that as any kind of slight against Nothingman, which is gorgeous and still refreshing and lovely to listen to. But it's really just a testament to how fucking absurdly phenomenal Hail Hail really is.

I've never much cared for Nothingman while Hail, Hail is one of the band's most perfectly realised songs.

it's egg continues to roll thick and heavy

That line grosses me out.

Two songs with great chord progressions.

I haven't sussed it out, but I'm thinking if one was played in the style of the other, they wouldn't be so different.

I like 'em both!

But "Hail Hail".

I kinda want Hail, Hail or Last Exit to win it all this year.

So when this match closes, Hail Hail will have destroyed two of my all time faves. Fuck
At least they were beaten by a great song.