Page 1 of 1
2-99: It Happened Today vs. Shaking Through
Posted: Sat April 09, 2016 11:59 am
by stip
vote
Re: 2-99: It Happened Today vs. Shaking Through
Posted: Sat April 09, 2016 12:05 pm
by stip
I don't think Shaking Through is close to the best song on murmur, though it's very good.
It Happened Today is in my top 5 of the post Hi-Fi run, and may also be a top 20 song. It is everything REM does well in one incredible song. I could listen to the second half of that song forever.
Re: 2-99: It Happened Today vs. Shaking Through
Posted: Sat April 09, 2016 6:05 pm
by Norah
Shaking Through is the best song on Murmur, you dolt.
Re: 2-99: It Happened Today vs. Shaking Through
Posted: Sat April 09, 2016 6:11 pm
by Mike
Yeah, Shaking Through is great. I really like It Happened Today but it shouldn't win here.
Re: 2-99: It Happened Today vs. Shaking Through
Posted: Sat April 09, 2016 6:23 pm
by stip
cutuphalfdead wrote:Shaking Through is the best song on Murmur, you dolt.
Perfect Circle, Sitting Still, and west of the fields are clearly better
Re: 2-99: It Happened Today vs. Shaking Through
Posted: Sat April 09, 2016 6:25 pm
by Norah
stip wrote:cutuphalfdead wrote:Shaking Through is the best song on Murmur, you dolt.
Perfect Circle, Sitting Still, and west of the fields are clearly better
Nope, you're wrong.
Re: 2-99: It Happened Today vs. Shaking Through
Posted: Sat April 09, 2016 8:38 pm
by stip
cutuphalfdead wrote:stip wrote:cutuphalfdead wrote:Shaking Through is the best song on Murmur, you dolt.
Perfect Circle, Sitting Still, and west of the fields are clearly better
Nope, you're wrong.
Am I?
Re: 2-99: It Happened Today vs. Shaking Through
Posted: Sat April 09, 2016 8:49 pm
by Norah
stip wrote:cutuphalfdead wrote:stip wrote:cutuphalfdead wrote:Shaking Through is the best song on Murmur, you dolt.
Perfect Circle, Sitting Still, and west of the fields are clearly better
Nope, you're wrong.
Am I?
Yes.
Re: 2-99: It Happened Today vs. Shaking Through
Posted: Sat April 09, 2016 8:57 pm
by epilogue
cutuphalfdead wrote:stip wrote:cutuphalfdead wrote:stip wrote:cutuphalfdead wrote:Shaking Through is the best song on Murmur, you dolt.
Perfect Circle, Sitting Still, and west of the fields are clearly better
Nope, you're wrong.
Am I?
Yes.
But is he?
Re: 2-99: It Happened Today vs. Shaking Through
Posted: Sat April 09, 2016 11:03 pm
by chewm
stip wrote:cutuphalfdead wrote:Shaking Through is the best song on Murmur, you dolt.
Perfect Circle, Sitting Still, and west of the fields are clearly better
West of the Fields is probably the worst song from Murmur. The only one that might be better than Shaking Through is Talk About the Passion.
Re: 2-99: It Happened Today vs. Shaking Through
Posted: Sat April 09, 2016 11:03 pm
by chewm
Also, Shaking Through gets my vote, I like It Happened Today but cmon.
Re: 2-99: It Happened Today vs. Shaking Through
Posted: Sat April 09, 2016 11:50 pm
by stip
chewm wrote:stip wrote:cutuphalfdead wrote:Shaking Through is the best song on Murmur, you dolt.
Perfect Circle, Sitting Still, and west of the fields are clearly better
West of the Fields is probably the worst song from Murmur. The only one that might be better than Shaking Through is Talk About the Passion.
is it?
Re: 2-99: It Happened Today vs. Shaking Through
Posted: Sun April 10, 2016 3:20 am
by Norah
stip wrote:chewm wrote:stip wrote:cutuphalfdead wrote:Shaking Through is the best song on Murmur, you dolt.
Perfect Circle, Sitting Still, and west of the fields are clearly better
West of the Fields is probably the worst song from Murmur. The only one that might be better than Shaking Through is Talk About the Passion.
is it?
yes
Re: 2-99: It Happened Today vs. Shaking Through
Posted: Sun April 10, 2016 3:25 am
by AndySlash
i love it happened today. probably my favorite song post-2000. i dig shaking through, but i'm with stip- it happened today is a top 20 song for me.