Page 1 of 1
Devil Doll vs. Falling Down
Posted: Tue March 07, 2017 11:56 pm
by stip
Voting ends 3/8
Re: Devil Doll vs. Falling Down
Posted: Wed March 08, 2017 12:21 am
by stip
Devil Doll is a perfectly serviceable and unexciting cover.
Falling Down is maybe the best of those live non-song improvs (I prefer out of my mind, but I'm sure i'm in the minority) and probably could have been something special, but it's also one of those songs where its mystery was part of the appeal, and once it was officially released, even the live version, it lost something.
Voting for falling down, but this is the weakest winner of the round.
Re: Devil Doll vs. Falling Down
Posted: Wed March 08, 2017 12:31 am
by Kevin Davis
Wait, why is "Falling Down" included but not "Untitled" from Live on Two Legs? And "Devil Doll" isn't even PJ!
Re: Devil Doll vs. Falling Down
Posted: Wed March 08, 2017 12:55 am
by stip
shit, is devil doll just eddie?
Re: Devil Doll vs. Falling Down
Posted: Wed March 08, 2017 1:26 am
by Chris_H_2
what's the criterion for determining which improvs get included? out of my mind was more of an improv than falling down, but the same as something like saying no or the park where i play the pope. are ALL of those included?
Re: Devil Doll vs. Falling Down
Posted: Wed March 08, 2017 1:40 am
by bodysnatcher
stip wrote:shit, is devil doll just eddie?
Yes.. the one from the holiday single is Eddie and X. I believe there's another, older version with Eddie and the Supersuckers
Re: Devil Doll vs. Falling Down
Posted: Wed March 08, 2017 1:52 am
by chewm
I like Falling Down
Re: Devil Doll vs. Falling Down
Posted: Wed March 08, 2017 2:15 am
by stip
bodysnatcher wrote:stip wrote:shit, is devil doll just eddie?
Yes.. the one from the holiday single is Eddie and X. I believe there's another, older version with Eddie and the Supersuckers
well if it made it onto a single it'll count.
i really like that poor girl
cover he did w them
Re: Devil Doll vs. Falling Down
Posted: Wed March 08, 2017 3:17 am
by evenslow
Fuck these two
Re: Devil Doll vs. Falling Down
Posted: Wed March 08, 2017 3:18 am
by PHATJ
evenslow wrote:Fuck these two
Totally
Re: Devil Doll vs. Falling Down
Posted: Wed March 08, 2017 3:18 am
by evenslow
PHATJ wrote:evenslow wrote:Fuck these two
Totally
Haha nice sig!
Re: Devil Doll vs. Falling Down
Posted: Wed March 08, 2017 3:31 am
by PHATJ
evenslow wrote:PHATJ wrote:evenslow wrote:Fuck these two
Totally
Haha nice sig!
I did it, man.
Re: Devil Doll vs. Falling Down
Posted: Wed March 08, 2017 5:19 am
by LetMeSleep
Ditch these 2 and bring back In The Moonlight.
Falling Down
Re: Devil Doll vs. Falling Down
Posted: Wed March 08, 2017 10:29 am
by ABNorman
This will be the first time one of these reaches R2
Re: Devil Doll vs. Falling Down
Posted: Wed March 08, 2017 3:55 pm
by evenslow
ABNorman wrote:This will be the first time one of these reaches R2
And hopefully, last.
Re: Devil Doll vs. Falling Down
Posted: Wed March 08, 2017 6:07 pm
by Kevin Davis
"Falling Down" is weird -- it's a cool little improv, and fits nicely within the flow of that show, but for as much as I miss PJ doing stuff like that, putting into this kind of melting pot with all their work really puts it in its place.
That said, I'm voting for it over "Devil Doll."