Page 1 of 2
Rearviewmirrow vs. Elderly Woman... vs. Dissident
Posted: Tue March 14, 2017 10:08 pm
by stip
Voting ends 3/15
It's double elimination, baby!
Re: Rearviewmirrow vs. Elderly Woman... vs. Dissident
Posted: Tue March 14, 2017 10:20 pm
by epilogue
Here we go. Finally, a little challenge!
God, man.... these are all good to great. I'm going with Small Town. It's just one of those songs that continues to resonate in me, even after all these years. If it's possible, it's maybe even gotten better in my estimation as time as gone on. I just adore it.
But FUCK RVM is another heavy-hitter. And I have no problem seeing it take the victory. I'll be a tad disappointed (and surprised) if Dissident pulls this out. But it should get a few votes at least.
Small Town.
Re: Rearviewmirrow vs. Elderly Woman... vs. Dissident
Posted: Tue March 14, 2017 10:21 pm
by LoathedVermin72
RVM and it's not even close.
Re: Rearviewmirrow vs. Elderly Woman... vs. Dissident
Posted: Tue March 14, 2017 10:23 pm
by chewm
I'll vote for Reaviewmirror, but I really, really love all these songs.
Re: Rearviewmirrow vs. Elderly Woman... vs. Dissident
Posted: Tue March 14, 2017 10:27 pm
by LetMeSleep
RVM is a monster.
Re: Rearviewmirrow vs. Elderly Woman... vs. Dissident
Posted: Tue March 14, 2017 10:44 pm
by stip
Elderly Woman, though I'd pick RVM over any other song but that one. They're both just amazing
Re: Rearviewmirrow vs. Elderly Woman... vs. Dissident
Posted: Tue March 14, 2017 11:11 pm
by ABNorman
Elderly Woman - I don't care for the other two (especially Dissident).
Re: Rearviewmirrow vs. Elderly Woman... vs. Dissident
Posted: Tue March 14, 2017 11:17 pm
by ABNorman
Elderly Woman made the QFs in 2009, but generally busts out in R3.
Rearviewmirror has only made the final once, in 2008, where it lost to Immortality. It has never dropped out before R4, and has made several QFs and a coupla SFs.
Dissident has never made it past R2.
Re: Rearviewmirrow vs. Elderly Woman... vs. Dissident
Posted: Tue March 14, 2017 11:31 pm
by epilogue
ABNorman wrote:Elderly Woman made the QFs in 2009, but generally busts out in R3.
Rearviewmirror has only made the final once, in 2008, where it lost to Immortality. It has never dropped out before R4, and has made several QFs and a coupla SFs.
Dissident has never made it past R2.
Yeah, this sounds right.
Re: Rearviewmirrow vs. Elderly Woman... vs. Dissident
Posted: Tue March 14, 2017 11:58 pm
by digster
Rearviewmirror for me. Listening to these songs back to back with Ten is pretty striking. In terms of production, Ten certainly sounds of its time. There's a lot on Vs. that sounds to me as if it could have been recording yesterday. It's a spottier record than my absolute favorites of theirs, but the best on this album is as good as anything they've done.
Re: Rearviewmirrow vs. Elderly Woman... vs. Dissident
Posted: Wed March 15, 2017 12:02 am
by PHATJ
Easy vote for Dissident. It's criminally underrated around here.
Re: Rearviewmirrow vs. Elderly Woman... vs. Dissident
Posted: Wed March 15, 2017 12:06 am
by stip
digster wrote:It's a spottier record than my absolute favorites of theirs, but the best on this album is as good as anything they've done.
true dat
If Last Exit doesn't win this year I hope it's RVM. I've gotten back into that song in a huge way recently.
Re: Rearviewmirrow vs. Elderly Woman... vs. Dissident
Posted: Wed March 15, 2017 12:07 am
by Chris_H_2
LoathedVermin72 wrote:RVM and it's not even close.
Re: Rearviewmirrow vs. Elderly Woman... vs. Dissident
Posted: Wed March 15, 2017 12:08 am
by stip
stip wrote:digster wrote:It's a spottier record than my absolute favorites of theirs, but the best on this album is as good as anything they've done.
true dat
If Last Exit doesn't win this year I hope it's RVM. I've gotten back into that song in a huge way recently.
or we could just give a song like Corduroy or Immortality another win. They have never stopped being deserving
Re: Rearviewmirrow vs. Elderly Woman... vs. Dissident
Posted: Wed March 15, 2017 12:10 am
by digster
I'm pulling for Last Exit or perhaps Sleight of Hand, if I am barring the song I think is the best that's already had it's day in the sun.
It surprises me that Rearviewmirror has never won.
Re: Rearviewmirrow vs. Elderly Woman... vs. Dissident
Posted: Wed March 15, 2017 12:12 am
by PHATJ
digster wrote:I'm pulling for Last Exit or perhaps Sleight of Hand, if I am barring the song I think is the best that's already had it's day in the sun.
It surprises me that Rearviewmirror has never won.
Sleight of Hand is PJ's masterpiece.
Re: Rearviewmirrow vs. Elderly Woman... vs. Dissident
Posted: Wed March 15, 2017 12:13 am
by Chris_H_2
PHATJ wrote:digster wrote:I'm pulling for Last Exit or perhaps Sleight of Hand, if I am barring the song I think is the best that's already had it's day in the sun.
It surprises me that Rearviewmirror has never won.
Sleight of Hand is PJ's masterpiece.
i can't wait until it's in a matchup and i post something that completely pisses you off
Re: Rearviewmirrow vs. Elderly Woman... vs. Dissident
Posted: Wed March 15, 2017 12:27 am
by PHATJ
Chris_H_2 wrote:PHATJ wrote:digster wrote:I'm pulling for Last Exit or perhaps Sleight of Hand, if I am barring the song I think is the best that's already had it's day in the sun.
It surprises me that Rearviewmirror has never won.
Sleight of Hand is PJ's masterpiece.
i can't wait until it's in a matchup and i post something that completely pisses you off
Other people's musical opinions don't piss me off. And SoH will still be PJ's masterpiece with or without you.
Re: Rearviewmirrow vs. Elderly Woman... vs. Dissident
Posted: Wed March 15, 2017 12:38 am
by LoathedVermin72
PHATJ wrote:Other people's musical opinions don't piss me off
Well this isn't gonna be very fun
Re: Rearviewmirrow vs. Elderly Woman... vs. Dissident
Posted: Wed March 15, 2017 12:39 am
by PHATJ
LoathedVermin72 wrote:PHATJ wrote:Other people's musical opinions don't piss me off
Well this isn't gonna be very fun
