18-Hail Hail vs. In My Tree
Posted: Tue March 28, 2017 9:12 pm
Voting ends 3/29
Red Mosquito
18-Hail Hail vs. In My Tree
Page 1 of 2
Re: 18-Hail Hail vs. In My Tree
Posted: Tue March 28, 2017 9:14 pm
Both very good songs. My vote is swayable.
Re: 18-Hail Hail vs. In My Tree
Posted: Tue March 28, 2017 9:15 pm
Fully expect Hail Hail to win. No shame in losing to such a fantastic song. But my heart and my vote, as always, belong to In My Tree. 
Re: 18-Hail Hail vs. In My Tree
Posted: Tue March 28, 2017 9:17 pm
Pretty much this.durdencommatyler wrote:Fully expect Hail Hail to win. No shame in losing to such a fantastic song. But my heart and my vote, as always, belong to In My Tree.
Re: 18-Hail Hail vs. In My Tree
Posted: Tue March 28, 2017 9:25 pm
Hail, Hail is top of the Pearl Jam mountain, a moment of perfection.
Re: 18-Hail Hail vs. In My Tree
Posted: Tue March 28, 2017 9:36 pm
Hail Hail is one of their best.
Re: 18-Hail Hail vs. In My Tree
Posted: Tue March 28, 2017 9:37 pm
It sure is. But so is In My Tree.LetMeSleep wrote:Hail Hail is one of their best.
Re: 18-Hail Hail vs. In My Tree
Posted: Tue March 28, 2017 9:38 pm
Hail Hail is the best track on No Code.durdencommatyler wrote:It sure is. But so is In My Tree.LetMeSleep wrote:Hail Hail is one of their best.
Re: 18-Hail Hail vs. In My Tree
Posted: Tue March 28, 2017 9:39 pm
If you say so. But I'm pretty sure that's incorrect. For example, In My Tree is on No Code.LetMeSleep wrote:Hail Hail is the best track on No Code.durdencommatyler wrote:It sure is. But so is In My Tree.LetMeSleep wrote:Hail Hail is one of their best.
Re: 18-Hail Hail vs. In My Tree
Posted: Tue March 28, 2017 9:40 pm
This is like 1a and 1b. I'm going with IMT, but I hate voting against Hail Hail.durdencommatyler wrote:If you say so. But I'm pretty sure that's incorrect. For example, In My Tree is on No Code.LetMeSleep wrote:Hail Hail is the best track on No Code.durdencommatyler wrote:It sure is. But so is In My Tree.LetMeSleep wrote:Hail Hail is one of their best.
Re: 18-Hail Hail vs. In My Tree
Posted: Tue March 28, 2017 9:44 pm
Couple of things about Hail Hail. It's lyrically better than IMT, it's melodically better and (you'll love this one) it's a previous MM winner.durdencommatyler wrote:If you say so. But I'm pretty sure that's incorrect. For example, In My Tree is on No Code.LetMeSleep wrote:Hail Hail is the best track on No Code.durdencommatyler wrote:It sure is. But so is In My Tree.LetMeSleep wrote:Hail Hail is one of their best.
Re: 18-Hail Hail vs. In My Tree
Posted: Tue March 28, 2017 9:44 pm
Every song left in this thing is tip top.
In My Tree
In My Tree
Re: 18-Hail Hail vs. In My Tree
Posted: Tue March 28, 2017 9:45 pm
Farmer John wrote:Every song left in this thing is tip top.
In My Tree
Re: 18-Hail Hail vs. In My Tree
Posted: Tue March 28, 2017 9:45 pm
Interesting. I have independently verified that two of your three points are patently false.LetMeSleep wrote:Couple of things about Hail Hail. It's lyrically better than IMT, it's melodically better and (you'll love this one) it's a previous MM winner.durdencommatyler wrote:If you say so. But I'm pretty sure that's incorrect. For example, In My Tree is on No Code.LetMeSleep wrote:Hail Hail is the best track on No Code.durdencommatyler wrote:It sure is. But so is In My Tree.LetMeSleep wrote:Hail Hail is one of their best.
Re: 18-Hail Hail vs. In My Tree
Posted: Tue March 28, 2017 9:51 pm
I do think "Hail Hail" is lyrically better. But "In My Tree" goes to deeper places musically -- there are parts during those choruses where I feel less like I'm listening to a rock band playing and more like I'm just being pummelled by a tidal wave, not only a force of raw sound but also of take-your-breath-away emotion. Not an easy vote, but I'm saying "In My Tree."
Re: 18-Hail Hail vs. In My Tree
Posted: Tue March 28, 2017 10:10 pm
Hail Hail has some really fantastic phrases. Some powerful lyrical moments. But In My Tree is stunning through and through. There's really no comparison for me.
Re: 18-Hail Hail vs. In My Tree
Posted: Tue March 28, 2017 10:24 pm
oh, joey.
Re: 18-Hail Hail vs. In My Tree
Posted: Tue March 28, 2017 10:25 pm
Joey is right
Re: 18-Hail Hail vs. In My Tree
Posted: Tue March 28, 2017 10:49 pm
Hail Hail no contest for me.
Re: 18-Hail Hail vs. In My Tree
Posted: Tue March 28, 2017 11:48 pm
Hail Hail not even close