Again Today vs Out Of Sand

[Anders]

Two new studio songs (one by Pearl Jam, one by Eddie Vedder) in a short space of time. Which one is better?





A poll would be nice.

[stip]

here you go


Not sure which i prefer - they scratch different itches

[Anders]

Thank you.

Out Of Sand reminds me of of the Into The Wild soundtrack. I wish Ed would release another album like that. Proper studio album, good production, effort into every song. The song fits his current voice perfectly.

Again Today is obviously more of a rock song. But Ed sounds out of place, straining his voice. The band meanwhile fades into the background, not being allowed to shine. It's modern Pearl Jam at its worst.

PS Not that it matters. But can you imagine something like Again Today on Vitalogy? No? Thought so.

[darth_vedder]

I think I like "Again Today" slightly better, but not crazy about either. Like Anders said above, Ed's voice is more suited for "Out Of Sand" but for me, I'm not that crazy about the Into The Wild stuff, so something that similar to it doesn't really interest me. The music to "Again Today" has potential but also like Anders said there are some elements of what I don't like about modern day PJ there.

[Got Some]

Out of sand easily . I can't even finish Again Today

[epilogue]

I'm gonna go with Out of Sand. But I really dig both of them.

[TremorJam]

I like both, but voted for Out Of Sand. It's a pretty decent Ed song. Somber in tone and effective. There's also some pretty interesting chord changes.

[Jorge]

"Out of Sand" is a terrible song. Vote for "Again Today" because I like the composition better, even if the arrangement isn't all that.

[evenslow]

I could see myself listening to Again Today much more than Out of Sand. *closes eyes* yes there i am, listening to... oh wait no it's hail hail again. *opens eyes* Stip what are you doing here?!?!?!?

[bada]

There needs to be a third option.

[dprival78]

out of sand is horseshit. again today is fine, and it's growing on me too

[McParadigm]

So it's come to this

[Kaius]

This thread is a microcosm of modern day Pearl Jam music.

[epilogue]

I changed my vote to Again Today. Because today it's the better song.

But I really like both of these. As Stip said, they scratch different itches. I think which one I prefer will always depend on mood.

[Norah]

Haven't listened to Out of Sand. Not sure when I will.

[Jorge]

Haven't listened to Out of Sand. Not sure when I will.

Don't be so lazy. Listen now. It's like 3 minutes long, though it feels like 10

[evenslow]

Haven't listened to Out of Sand. Not sure when I will.

Don't be so lazy. Listen now. It's like 3 minutes long, though it feels like 10

well now i'm sure he's gonna listen to it

[Kaius]

Why would Pearl Jam cover an artist as mind numbingly boring as Brandi Carlisle?

[Kaius]

Oh right.

[epilogue]