Page 1 of 1

11. Habit (2:40-3:36) vs. Johnny Guitar (2:18-2:44)

Posted: Wed May 10, 2017 11:31 am
by stip
Habit (2:40-3:36) vs. Johnny Guitar (2:18-2:44)

Voting ends 5/11

Re: 11. Habit (2:40-3:36) vs. Johnny Guitar (2:18-2:44)

Posted: Wed May 10, 2017 6:12 pm
by mikejasond
I think Habit is pretty awful. That part is pretty nice. I REALLY like Johnny Guitar but that's the worst part...

Somehow I find myself voting for Habit :(

Re: 11. Habit (2:40-3:36) vs. Johnny Guitar (2:18-2:44)

Posted: Wed May 10, 2017 11:57 pm
by stip
I always forget how short Johnny Guitar is. I like the ending of it fine, but it's hardly the most memorable part of the song.

The ending of Habit is fantastic. Another moment (like Life Wasted and RVM) where everyone is just locked in and playing the fuck out of their instruments.

Re: 11. Habit (2:40-3:36) vs. Johnny Guitar (2:18-2:44)

Posted: Thu May 11, 2017 1:57 am
by evenslow
Habit outro has a darkhorse shot at winning this whole thing if people aren't idiots. And this is coming from a guy who was never the biggest Habit fan. It creeped up on me slowly, debilitating me until I soldiered on in spite of negative consequences.

Re: 11. Habit (2:40-3:36) vs. Johnny Guitar (2:18-2:44)

Posted: Thu May 11, 2017 3:23 am
by PHATJ
evenslow wrote:Habit outro has a darkhorse shot at winning this whole thing if people aren't idiots. And this is coming from a guy who was never the biggest Habit fan. It creeped up on me slowly, debilitating me until I soldiered on in spite of negative consequences.
Habit fucking shreds.

I didn't like it for years, now I love it. It crept up on me too. There have been a few songs like that in the PJ catalog (Evacuation, Wishlist, & Get Right are in the same category) that I just really disliked for a long time and then the switch flipped and now I love 'em. And the finishing minute of Habit is absolutely fucking awesome.

Re: 11. Habit (2:40-3:36) vs. Johnny Guitar (2:18-2:44)

Posted: Thu May 11, 2017 1:06 pm
by evenslow
PHATJ wrote:
evenslow wrote:Habit outro has a darkhorse shot at winning this whole thing if people aren't idiots. And this is coming from a guy who was never the biggest Habit fan. It creeped up on me slowly, debilitating me until I soldiered on in spite of negative consequences.
Habit fucking shreds.

I didn't like it for years, now I love it. It crept up on me too. There have been a few songs like that in the PJ catalog (Evacuation, Wishlist, & Get Right are in the same category) that I just really disliked for a long time and then the switch flipped and now I love 'em. And the finishing minute of Habit is absolutely fucking awesome.
Agree with Evac and GR as well. Those two and Habit all share simple (at first blush, bland) choruses that turned me away from the song.

NEVER THOUGHT YOU'D HABIT!! NEVER THOUGHT YOU'D HABIT!!

EVACUATION!! E-VAC-U-A-SHUUUUUUUN!!

I wanted to get riiiiiight, I wanted to get riiiiight

After years of filing them away (and honestly thanks to March Madness), I started listening for the music underneath and that's when it clicked.

Re: 11. Habit (2:40-3:36) vs. Johnny Guitar (2:18-2:44)

Posted: Thu May 11, 2017 1:26 pm
by PHATJ
evenslow wrote:
PHATJ wrote:
evenslow wrote:Habit outro has a darkhorse shot at winning this whole thing if people aren't idiots. And this is coming from a guy who was never the biggest Habit fan. It creeped up on me slowly, debilitating me until I soldiered on in spite of negative consequences.
Habit fucking shreds.

I didn't like it for years, now I love it. It crept up on me too. There have been a few songs like that in the PJ catalog (Evacuation, Wishlist, & Get Right are in the same category) that I just really disliked for a long time and then the switch flipped and now I love 'em. And the finishing minute of Habit is absolutely fucking awesome.
Agree with Evac and GR as well. Those two and Habit all share simple (at first blush, bland) choruses that turned me away from the song.

NEVER THOUGHT YOU'D HABIT!! NEVER THOUGHT YOU'D HABIT!!

EVACUATION!! E-VAC-U-A-SHUUUUUUUN!!

I wanted to get riiiiiight, I wanted to get riiiiight

After years of filing them away (and honestly thanks to March Madness), I started listening for the music underneath and that's when it clicked.
Yep, basically same for me. And MM was what got me listening to those songs again too. See, this is why I love stip and could never kill him.

Re: 11. Habit (2:40-3:36) vs. Johnny Guitar (2:18-2:44)

Posted: Thu May 11, 2017 3:10 pm
by mikejasond
evenslow wrote:
PHATJ wrote:
evenslow wrote:Habit outro has a darkhorse shot at winning this whole thing if people aren't idiots. And this is coming from a guy who was never the biggest Habit fan. It creeped up on me slowly, debilitating me until I soldiered on in spite of negative consequences.
Habit fucking shreds.

I didn't like it for years, now I love it. It crept up on me too. There have been a few songs like that in the PJ catalog (Evacuation, Wishlist, & Get Right are in the same category) that I just really disliked for a long time and then the switch flipped and now I love 'em. And the finishing minute of Habit is absolutely fucking awesome.
Agree with Evac and GR as well. Those two and Habit all share simple (at first blush, bland) choruses that turned me away from the song.

NEVER THOUGHT YOU'D HABIT!! NEVER THOUGHT YOU'D HABIT!!

EVACUATION!! E-VAC-U-A-SHUUUUUUUN!!

I wanted to get riiiiiight, I wanted to get riiiiight

After years of filing them away (and honestly thanks to March Madness), I started listening for the music underneath and that's when it clicked.
They're not bland, they're ear-screechingly awful and corny <_<

Well not get right, that one is good.

Re: 11. Habit (2:40-3:36) vs. Johnny Guitar (2:18-2:44)

Posted: Thu May 11, 2017 3:12 pm
by darth_vedder
The ending of Habit is one of the best things ever recorded by the band.

Re: 11. Habit (2:40-3:36) vs. Johnny Guitar (2:18-2:44)

Posted: Thu May 11, 2017 3:57 pm
by Hatfield
darth_vedder wrote:The ending of Habit is one of the best things ever recorded by the band.
:thumbsup: :thumbsup: :thumbsup:

This jam and me had a run in with some magic mushrooms a few years back and I will forever argue your point to be true.

Re: 11. Habit (2:40-3:36) vs. Johnny Guitar (2:18-2:44)

Posted: Thu May 11, 2017 4:19 pm
by PHATJ
darth_vedder wrote:The ending of Habit is one of the best things ever recorded by the band.
Agreed.

Re: 11. Habit (2:40-3:36) vs. Johnny Guitar (2:18-2:44)

Posted: Thu May 11, 2017 6:39 pm
by chewm
I had to vote for Habit but I like the other song a lot better.

Re: 11. Habit (2:40-3:36) vs. Johnny Guitar (2:18-2:44)

Posted: Thu May 11, 2017 6:46 pm
by TremorJam
I remember when they released "Who You Are" to radio. After about a week, the DJ started playing "Habit" instead. Incendiary! It was pretty hilarious and this helped to whittle the fan base down drastically. PJ became an "Acquired Taste" with one single. :lol: