Red Mosquito

Tj wrote:I thought that to so I looked at the rule, and because of the Pj20 soundtrack it would be okay
F#&&in up would be okay based on live on 2 legs.The rule reads this-Anything on a random album/compilation/soundtrack attributed to pearl jam

Yeah, but in the first post with the "official rules" he says that the only covers that are fair play are ones that have studio versions, no?

stip wrote:--Any studio recording from a Christmas single
--Any covers recorded in the studio (no live)

Unfortunately it looks like "Crown of Thorns" doesn't qualify. It is a Christmas single, and a cover, but not recorded in studio.

There alot of Live stuff Arms Aloft as well. I just don't want to go in a live direction

Covers have to have been recorded in the studio according to the rules.

Fair enough. It's cool.

Sonic Reducer then.

7. Mankind
8. Sonic Reducer.

super nintendo chalmers wrote:Fair enough.

Sonic Reducer then.

7.Mankind
8. Sonic Reducer.

Well fuck that was gonna be my next pick if it got back to me

Nice choice

Great choice. Where is that on a studio recording I got to have that.

I thought falling down was against the rules at first but
--Any unreleased songs (finished/demo/etc) attributed to the band (studio or live)

Tj wrote:Great choice. Where is that on a studio recording I got to have that.

The first Christmas single im pretty sure

Dr. Van Nostrand wrote:

Tj wrote:Great choice. Where is that on a studio recording I got to have that.

The first Christmas single im pretty sure

92


Theres a Baba from this session too supposedly.

This may raise a few eyebrows, but The End

theplatypus wrote:This may raise a few eyebrows, but The End

Damn you

super nintendo chalmers wrote:

Dr. Van Nostrand wrote:

Tj wrote:Great choice. Where is that on a studio recording I got to have that.

The first Christmas single im pretty sure

92


Theres a Baba from this session too supposedly.

Oh yeah? I know it sounds cheesy but id love to hear studio versions of their most common covers, not a whole album kinda thing, but as Christmas singles and stuff, especially if they are already recorded somewhere

theplatypus wrote:This may raise a few eyebrows, but The End

Fits well with what you are building there. Nice pick

Dr. Van Nostrand wrote:

super nintendo chalmers wrote:Let me know and I can swap. Figure, it was on an Xmas single and the pj20 soundtrack, plus falling down was fair game. Why not Crown?

The only difference will be crown is a cover but falling down and last soldier for me are originals.
If you aren't able to hang around till stip gets here, pm him a replacement in case it isn't ok.

Agreed. Crown Of Thorns is a cover without a studio version. No way it should count. Neither should Fuckin' Up or My Way or History Never Repeats.

The End is a gem if it was on No Code eveybody would call it a masterpiece.

PM'd Stip, but looks like I beat him back!

Sorry for the hold up...

Love Reign O'er Me

Tj wrote:The End is a gem if it was on No Code eveybody would call it a masterpiece.

ugh no

Ahh, fuck it...

Tj wrote:The End is a gem if it was on No Code eveybody would call it a masterpiece.

I don't know about the second part, but I agree that it's a great song. Very elegant from a compositional level. It bugs me that there's no one else from the band in it, so it should've been an Ed song, but I have a good spot for it in the playlist.