225. Thin Air vs. Black
Posted: Tue April 06, 2021 11:49 pm
Thin Air vs. Black
Red Mosquito
225. Thin Air vs. Black
Page 1 of 2
Re: 225. Thin Air vs. Black
Posted: Tue April 06, 2021 11:55 pm
Black is rather special.
Re: 225. Thin Air vs. Black
Posted: Wed April 07, 2021 12:10 am
If this is somehow within 15 votes I'm going to be so annoyed
Re: 225. Thin Air vs. Black
Posted: Wed April 07, 2021 1:08 am
Black, but only because of the Unplugged version being one of the best rock music performances I’ve ever seen. Would reach for Thin Air first under any other circumstance
Re: 225. Thin Air vs. Black
Posted: Wed April 07, 2021 1:10 am
stip wrote:If this is somehow within 15 votes I'm going to be so annoyed
Re: 225. Thin Air vs. Black
Posted: Wed April 07, 2021 1:36 am
I'll probably go with Black in the end, though I'm tempted; the song, or at least how the band did it on record, really has not aged well for me. I think the song is one of the few PJ songs where I never return back to the studio version, opting for a version from later in their years when it's shaken off some of Ten's more dated attributes.
Re: 225. Thin Air vs. Black
Posted: Wed April 07, 2021 1:38 am
This is pretty true for me, too, but it's what it does live that makes me wonder if it's their best song.digster wrote:I'll probably go with Black in the end, though I'm tempted; the song, or at least how the band did it on record, really has not aged well for me. I think the song is one of the few PJ songs where I never return back to the studio version, opting for a version from later in their years when it's shaken off some of Ten's more dated attributes.
Re: 225. Thin Air vs. Black
Posted: Wed April 07, 2021 1:41 am
You know it will be.stip wrote:If this is somehow within 15 votes I'm going to be so annoyed
Still Black any damn day of the week.
Re: 225. Thin Air vs. Black
Posted: Wed April 07, 2021 2:33 am
tragabigzanda wrote:Black, but only because of the Unplugged version being one of the best rock music performances I’ve ever seen. Would reach for Thin Air first under any other circumstance
Re: 225. Thin Air vs. Black
Posted: Wed April 07, 2021 3:19 am
My wife and I walked down the aisle together to Thin Air after we were married. The song just means so much to me.
But Black is Black.
But Black is Black.
Re: 225. Thin Air vs. Black
Posted: Wed April 07, 2021 3:39 am
yea i adore thin air and love that its made it this far but Black is Black.
That song still crushes live these days.
That song still crushes live these days.
Re: 225. Thin Air vs. Black
Posted: Wed April 07, 2021 3:46 am
Yeah. Gotta be Black.
Re: 225. Thin Air vs. Black
Posted: Wed April 07, 2021 3:47 am
Will say...
If we were to just put studio version against studio version i'd take Thin Air in a heartbeat.
Dont care much for studio Black.
If we were to just put studio version against studio version i'd take Thin Air in a heartbeat.
Dont care much for studio Black.
Re: 225. Thin Air vs. Black
Posted: Wed April 07, 2021 4:55 am
black should win it all and make everyone haha
Re: 225. Thin Air vs. Black
Posted: Wed April 07, 2021 6:45 am
Wow, that’s cool.epilogue wrote:My wife and I walked down the aisle together to Thin Air after we were married. The song just means so much to me.
But Black is Black.
Vote for Thin Air.
Re: 225. Thin Air vs. Black
Posted: Wed April 07, 2021 2:05 pm
Strat wrote:Will say...
If we were to just put studio version against studio version i'd take Thin Air in a heartbeat.
Dont care much for studio Black.
Re: 225. Thin Air vs. Black
Posted: Wed April 07, 2021 3:43 pm
Black can be fantastic live. Milan 06 is a big memory for me.
Re: 225. Thin Air vs. Black
Posted: Wed April 07, 2021 5:29 pm
I never thought I'd live in a world where I voted for Thin Air over Black, but somehow ... here I am.
Re: 225. Thin Air vs. Black
Posted: Wed April 07, 2021 5:56 pm
Do you even know the songs you are voting for or against at this point?B wrote:I never thought I'd live in a world where I voted for Thin Air over Black, but somehow ... here I am.
Re: 225. Thin Air vs. Black
Posted: Wed April 07, 2021 6:01 pm
Black got me into Pearl Jam but I'm pretty bored with it at this point.