Red Mosquito

GL

this match is gonna piss me off

Off Stip Goes!

Off He Goes for sure.

Small Town. Off He Goes is beautiful live though.

Elderly Woman, close one tho.

There are many songs that should be this far rather than these two.

Off He Goes, but I'm waffling.

Off He Goes has become one of PJ's most overlooked songs recently

Small Town, but I don't mind it losing here.

Almost impossible to split... went off he goes but won't be worried if it goes down

Off He Goes

stip wrote:this match is gonna piss me off

Well then, OFF HE GOES it is!

stip wrote:this match is gonna piss me off

I really hope it does. OHG is clearly the superior song.

OHG

I really love them both. But Small Town is one of my all time favorite songs. It's a joy to hear.

Small Town.

I love them both too. The "Go" single found its way into my player not long ago and I was really taken with the acoustic version of "Elderly Woman"--it's amazing how much warmth and intimacy the early versions of that song have, particularly after you've become used to it as a stadium singalong. And as far as general technique I don't really care about Dave A. either way but I will add "Elderly Woman" to the short list of tunes that none of their subsequent drummers have been able to handle with the same finesse. Additionally, it's a song that more or less pulled itself up by its own bootstraps--it was never released as a single by the band and for the first 4-5 years of its existence was really something of a rarity, yet it managed to become one of the band's best loved songs. Probably because it was the one song that everybody's girlfriend likes. A beautiful tune.

But I can't vote for it over "Off He Goes."

off he goes

Is Stip pissed off yet? He hasn't checked in.

I knew this was coming so I just feel the same old familiar disappointment, rather than the outrage that accompanies new depths